‘1899’ and the fatal flaw of the TV mystery

By Tom Lister

The 2022 Netflix series 1899 chronicles the supernatural happenings onboard the steamship Kerberos, as it carries a diverse group of immigrants from England to New York City. It topped viewership charts for the first few days of its release and remained high on the list for over a month afterwards. While an intriguing series, it never entirely drew me in, and I felt myself strangely reminded of another show throughout – 2021’s WandaVision.

While the two couldn’t be more different when it comes to subject matter and tone, both are fundamentally trying to tell the same kind of story – a mystery in which the puzzle being solved relates to the nature of the world itself. Giving the matter more thought, I realised that the recently released The Devil’s Hour fits this pattern as well, although you’ll need to watch all six episodes to understand why. Not only are all three shows built on a similar foundation, but they all encounter the exact same problem – where do you put the twist?

As the big reveal in all three shows relates to the nature of reality and single-handedly explains every strange occurrence we’ve witnessed so far, it’s inevitable that the audience won’t have a clear idea of what’s going on until it’s unveiled. On the flip side, once the premise is laid bare, there’s no longer any element of mystery to keep viewers engaged. Each of these shows attempts to solve this dilemma in a different way. So, let’s dive into each, picking apart what works and what doesn’t.

Once the premise is laid bare, there’s no longer any element of mystery to keep viewers engaged

WandaVision

The first of Marvel’s TV spin-offs takes the least common approach in handling its mystery – placing the solution only a few episodes in. The grand reveal takes place in episode four, less than halfway through the series, and spends 35 minutes providing an explanation for every strange event witnessed thus far, alongside the larger contexts in which they’ve been popping up. It’s an entertaining episode, no doubt, as the answers provided are simultaneously logical and humorously unexpected. But it leaves us with a problem – we know the nature of Wanda’s world, while all its inhabitants are left in the dark. As we watch them slowly discover the truths hidden from them, their investigation can’t help but feel neutered, we hold power over the characters through our knowledge of the solution.

Although a few mysteries are left unsolved until the end, the overarching intrigue was lost, and the show resorted to filling its final episode with unnecessary action. The show remains an interesting case study, with some very effective drama towards the middle, but ultimately failed in tackling this article’s central dilemma.

The Devil’s Hour

This six-episode series from writer and producer Tom Moran takes the opposite approach. The audience are left in the dark until the very last episode – and it’s easy to see the downside of such structure. While we’re able to invest in individual characters and smaller plotlines, we’re in complete freefall when it comes to the larger story. There’s nothing to latch onto, nothing to provide even a crumb of understanding, until everything is finally revealed at once.

Audience investment aside, there’s perhaps a larger problem with structuring a mystery this way – the premise can’t be used until the final episode. It’s impossible to tell someone what The Devil’s Hour is ‘about’ without spoiling the entire thing. And when the concept is finally revealed, it’s so genuinely interesting that the previous five episodes almost feel like a complete waste of time.

1899

We’ve now arrived at this article’s titular series, which attempts to blend the approaches of the two prior examples by gradually offering new clues and discoveries as the show progresses. On paper, this seems like the perfect approach to keep the audience engaged, but it’s not without its flaws. If you manage to guess the twist from the clues provided, then the actual reveal becomes toothless, drawing out the obvious conclusion for far too long.

Like every good season of a TV mystery, you’re left simultaneously satisfied and wanting more

However, most audience members likely won’t guess the twist until a few episodes before the finale, if at all. Although new information is technically uncovered in each episode, without knowing the framework of the overarching solution, these clues don’t seem to provide us with any answers. All viewers are given are more questions, and it eventually becomes impossible to create a satisfying answer to them all. Instead, a broader solution attempts to brush them all under the rug.

Coincidentally, this approach, along with the effectiveness of its final reveal, is identical to the critically panned 2022 film Don’t Worry Darling. However, unlike its filmic counterpart, 1899’s use of location and production design are strong enough to make it a far more worthwhile viewing. Although these shows seem to fail at their very premise, there have also been a number of successes that we must examine.

Stranger Things

The initial season of this worldwide phenomenon is far more successful as a mystery, because unlike 1899, it doesn’t put all its eggs in one basket. The mystery of Hawkins Lab is largely separate from the mystery of the Demogorgon, which itself is separate from the mystery of the missing boy. Because of this, the show is able to hand out clues for three individual mysteries, giving audiences a better chance of grappling with each one. Additionally, the way in which all three are connected is left for the show to reveal on its own terms, stopping viewers from spoiling their own experiences.

Dark

Perhaps the most fitting case study is 1899’s direct predecessor – the three-season science fiction epic, Dark. Much like Stranger Things, the mystery of a vanished child acts as the hook, but what’s unique about Dark is how quickly this premise is sidestepped to introduce a far grander, more expansive concept, which keeps viewers engaged through its originality and breath-taking scale. And the cherry on top? By the end of the first season, the original queries are answered, along with dozens more introduced along the way. Unlike 1899, the answers are enough to satiate the questions, and like every good season of a TV mystery, you’re left simultaneously satisfied and wanting more.

Image: Kamil Feczko via Unsplash