Review: ‘Asteroid City’
By Tom Lister
Asteroid City is the inevitable conclusion of a filmmaker’s aesthetic obsession. Ever since 2014’s The Grand Budapest Hotel (arguably still Wes Anderson’s greatest work), he’s gone down a path of increasingly cold and mechanical filmmaking, accelerating with The French Dispatch (2021) and now barrelling into the station with Asteroid City – his least accessible and most idiosyncratic film to date. Nearly every major recurring Anderson actor has returned for an incredibly self-indulgent celebration of his signature style, and that’s what you’re guaranteed to get out of this: a whole lot of style.
Anderson’s signature sensibilities have been parodied to death, but nobody has come close to the levels of precision and detail you’ll find in the genuine article. These clockwork worlds are the perfect setting for a tight, clockwork plot – but that’s what’s really missing here. With no real tension or intrigue to drive the story forward, the film ends up a perfectly-tuned machine with no real purpose. Moments of emotion or profundity are buried deep in the actors’ stilted performances, to the extent where it’s unclear if certain scenes are intended to be comedic or tragic. While Anderson’s style is as striking as ever, it’s reached the point where it’s obstructing the story rather than enhancing it.
But perhaps that’s the wrong way to look at Anderson. The typical priorities of film may very well be reversed – the style is the meat and the story is the seasoning. Taking this approach, there’s plenty to sink your teeth into.
It’s a specific type of unreality that only Anderson could pull off
The production design is the real draw of this movie, no doubt about it. It’s a specific type of unreality that only Anderson could pull off: exaggerated and cartoony, but still grounded and tangible. Nothing illustrates this better than the incredible opening shots of a steam train racing across an endless desert – clearly a miniature, and clearer still a false backdrop, but somehow more exciting than what most filmmakers would achieve by shooting a real train. The construction of the scene is immediately striking, and sets the stage perfectly for what’s to come. We share Anderson’s excitement to arrive in this heightened world, and indeed, the craft is more impressive still once we reach the titular city.
The set designers are the real stars of the show, and Anderson’s intricate framing helps you appreciate every detail. The artistry is such a selling point that an Asteroid City exhibition in London was opened before the film even released. And while the story remains mostly dry, there’s a plethora of humour baked into the world itself. There are gags to be found in the architecture, the props, the costume design, the blocking – the absurd levels of artifice are all very intentional, highlighted by a meta narrative running throughout the film.
But it’s this same self-awareness that ultimately steals the characters’ limelight. Anderson certainly intends to make some statement by deconstructing his ‘story’ so heavily, through both the nature of the staging and the script itself, but the full meaning is hard to decipher. All that’s plainly evident is the film’s unwillingness to engage with the story it’s seemingly trying to tell.
Asteroid City is ornate, but often hollow. The characters and story come across as an afterthought compared to the superb craft that enhances every frame – it’s an unmissable experience for Anderson aficionados, but a hard sell for the rest of us.
⭐6/10⭐
Image: Olaf Hüttemann via Unsplash
