Right-wing presidents, online conspiracies and the threat to democracy

By Eve Mustin

Two years ago, the democratic transfer of power from President Trump to President Biden was  threatened by a violent attack on the Capitol by angry Trump supporters and far-right protesters.  Two years later, almost to the day, Bolsonaristas were incited to do the same – this time to  Brazil’s Congress, Supreme Court and presidential palace after President Lula’s swearing in ceremony on January 1st.  

The chaos in Brasília is reminiscent of the Capitol’s insurrection, but the tension in Brazil  has been brewing for many months now, and finally the political unrest erupted on Sunday. Since  the election on October 30th, Bolsonaro supporters have camped outside army headquarters in  hope that the military would intervene. They have disrupted roadways, protested throughout the  country, and one man was even arrested for planting a bomb ahead of Lula’s inauguration. 

What is behind their resistance to the election? For months, Bolsonaro has been spreading seeds  of doubt in the country’s electronic voting system, leading supporters to question the legitimacy  of the results. They also falsely accuse Lula of being a communist and view him as an ex-convict  after his 2017 imprisonment for corruption, despite these convictions being annulled by the  courts.  

Whilst Bolsonaro has not directly opposed the election results, he has not accepted them either,  refusing to attend the inauguration, thus mimicking Trump’s response to his defeat.  However, Trump’s involvement in the Capitol riot is evident, as on the day of the certification of  Biden’s election victory he held a political rally where he urged supporters to march over to the  Capitol. In Brazil, Lula had already been inaugurated and the results had been certified by the country’s electoral court. The Brazilian Congress was not in session, and Bolsonaro was in the US on  January 8th.  

For months, Bolsonaro has been spreading seeds  of doubt in the country’s electronic voting system, leading supporters to question the legitimacy  of the results.

Although the attack in Brasília may not have completely aligned with the Capitol insurrection,  political alliances were developing between right-wing commentators in the US and  Bolsonaristas. Steve Bannon, Trump’s former White House chief strategist, has propagated  election denialism rumors on social media and on his podcast ‘War Rooms’, even describing the rioters on Sunday as ‘Freedom Fighters.’ He also remains close to Eduardo Bolsonaro, Jair  Bolsonaro’s son. The director of the right-wing group Project Veritas, Matthew Tyrmand,  appeared on Fox’s Tucker Carlson Tonight to proclaim without any evidence that agent  provocateurs working for the new government were behind the destruction. He is also an adviser  to Eduardo Bolsonaro. In the wider US conservative movement, the prominent Conservative  Political Action Coalition has held conferences in Brazil to which Jair Bolsonaro himself attended.  

As with the lead-up to the Capitol riots, conspiracy theories were circulating on online forums, WhatsApp group chats and Twitter with hashtags such as #GoTrumpReeleito and  #BrazilianSpring. Democratic lawmakers even sent a letter to President Biden on Thursday  requesting that he reassess Bolsonaro’s status in the country, as “the United States must not  provide shelter for him, or any authoritarian who has inspired such violence against democratic  institutions.” For them, there is a direct link between the former president and the attack in  Brasília, whether or not Bolsonaro was in Brazil at the time, as there was between Trump and  the Capitol insurrection.  

The violence itself is what is most comparable between January 6th and January 8th. On both  days, thousands of rioters stormed federal buildings draped in their nation’s flag. They attacked  journalists and police officers, broke windows, destroyed artwork and furniture, vandalized offices  and stole documents. They took videos of their destruction, and posted them online, visibly proud  of what they had achieved. 

Brazil’s democratic history is not as long-standing as America’s; its presidential and federal  system of government is modeled after the United States’. The country only became a  democracy in 1985 after decades of military dictatorship. This recent attack could pose an even greater risk to Brazil’s newer institutions, with Lula supporters already describing it as an  attempted coup. Whether or not the Capitol insurrection had a direct influence on Bolsonaristas, it demonstrated to the world the fragility of modern democracy. So, did it set a precedent for future attacks? 

Image: Marcelo Camargo via Wikimedia Commons