The Bleak Winter of Christina Rossetti’s Midwinter
By Phoebe Rogers
Following a year of rising energy prices and geopolitical strife, we might resonate more with Christina Rossetti’s ‘In the Bleak Midwinter’ than any other jovial carol this Christmas. Rossetti’s solemn refrain was employed by Tim Luckhurst, Principal of South College, to invoke the wartime struggles of 1942. In subsequent decades, the energy crisis of the nineteen seventies plunged Britain into blackouts and was similarly reported as the ‘bleakest Christmas in years’. In these frosty climates where the ‘Earth stood hard as iron’, Rossetti’s verse signifies the importance of simple comforts, and her literary offering of ‘my heart’ advocates the solace of reading and listening to festive poetry in turbulent economic times.
Financial difficulties had burdened Christina Rossetti since childhood, yet the central form of economy in her poetry is more provocatively sexual. Goblin Market considers the commercial exchange of prostitution, as the ‘goblin merchant men’ tantalise two sisters to ‘come buy our orchard fruits’. From her experiences working at the St. Mary Magdalene Penitentiary for ‘fallen’ women, Rossetti recounts the torturous price of feminine redemption. From drug addiction to antisemitism, critics have offered varying interpretations of the evil influences in her sordid Garden of Eden. However, it is unanimously agreed that sisterly love cures Laura and Lizzie from the poisonous goblin fruits.
Sexual temptation is similarly overcome in Rossetti’s Speaking Likenesses, which she modelled from the uncanny world of Lewis Carroll’s Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. Rossetti described her 1874 collection as ‘a Christmas trifle, would-be in the Alice style, with an eye to the market’. However, the Victorian publishing market was dominated by seedy male writers and Rossetti struggled to compete as a female poet. With rumours circulating of Wilde’s homosexuality and Carroll’s paedophilia, her sordid goblin merchants became caricatures of the perverse Victorian ‘gentleman’.
Rossetti recounts the torturous price of feminine redemption
Whilst Speaking Likenesses never paralleled the commercial success of Carroll’s Alice tales, feminist critics celebrate Rossetti’s ‘critique of patriarchal amatory values’. Angela Carter’s The Bloody Chamber was published during the second wave of feminism in 1979 and imitates Rossetti’s Goblin Market, as she writes ‘eat me, drink me; thirst, cankered, goblin-ridden’. Utilising the form of children’s fantasy, both Carter’s revision of the Grimms’ Fairy Tales and Rossetti’s Speaking Likenesses involve scolding paedophilic implications. Rossetti’s biographer Jan Marsh suggests she was motivated by her own paternal incest, as she petitioned for the legal protection of children against prostitution and sexual exploitation. This protest is revived in Carter’s short story The Snow Child, as she echoes Rossetti’s carol in revealing the grotesque erotic reality of ‘Midwinter – invincible, immaculate’.
As ‘snow on snow’ falls in Rossetti’s ‘In the Bleak Midwinter’, the white blanket of poetic form has been employed by writers to conceal moral impurity. In T.S. Eliot’s The Waste Land, post-war numbness covers ‘the Earth in forgetful snow’, as he uncovers spiritual decay in the wake of trench warfare. This modernist disorder is portrayed by W. B. Yeats as ‘the uncontrollable mystery on the bestial floor’ in his Christmas poem, ‘The Magi’. After witnessing ‘Cavalry’s turbulence’ during the Crucifixion, the Wise Men return to Yeats’s Nativity scene, which is wrought with the desperate search for divine meaning.
Feminist critics celebrate Rossetti’s ‘critique of patriarchal amatory values’
The birth of Christ arouses similar questions of devotion in Rossetti’s poem: ‘what can I give him, poor as I am?’. As Yeats describes the Magi as the ‘pale, unsatisfied ones’, Rossetti accordingly suggests that their material offerings are outweighed by the Virgin Mary’s nurturing ‘kiss’. Moreover, the poet suggests that the resolution to our financial concerns might be found in the curative power of unconditional love.
Since Rossetti was commissioned by Scribner’s Monthly in 1872, her poetic gift of ‘my heart’ has been immortalised by the enduring popularity of her Christmas carol. Composed by Harold Darke, ‘In the Bleak Midwinter’ has been broadcasted every year since 1930 by King’s College Choir, Cambridge and was named the favourite of choirmasters in a 2008 BBC poll.
From feminist fruits to the modernist Magi, the works of Christmas poets are rife with tales of dissatisfaction and greed. However, the lyrical warmth of Rossetti’s carol reminds us that generosity of spirit might provide us with comfort in this ‘bleak midwinter’.
Image Credits: Vyacheslav Argenberg via Wikimedia Commons
