Review: Freshers’ Showcase 2026
By Anna Pile
Just when you thought the bar of talent at Durham couldn’t be raised, TDTC’s annual Freshers’ Showcase arrives to prove you wrong. Unlike previous years, co-directors Louis Williams and Celine Delahaye (assisted by Lois Barnett) gave this showcase a clear structure, grouping songs by genre. It was an inspired choice, offering a wide range of tones and styles for the audience to enjoy, and never once feeling repetitive.
The curtains opened on a gorgeous piano solo from musical director Ben Armitage, before the cast, all in black with a colourful top layer (the first of many outfits that night), launched into “Magic to Do”. The choreography was impressively detailed and uniform, and ending with white-gloved hands raised to the sky truly captured the spirit of a ringmaster, perfect for Pippin. Unfortunately, that spirit fell on somewhat deaf ears, as the sound of the vocals was too quiet for the majority of the group numbers.
The choreography was impressively detailed and uniform
Moments like these showed great directorial initiative and a willingness to take risks, but including twenty-six songs in the setlist was a risk that didn’t fully pay off. Not only was the night much longer than one would expect, but certain numbers were clearly more rehearsed than others, with bursts of confidence swiftly followed by moments of unassuredness, whether in the performances or in a lack of ingenuity with the blocking. With that said, the well-rehearsed numbers were unforgettable, and left the audience much less antsy in their seats.
The first section of the night was dedicated to musicals based on novels. Elen Johnson was handed the daunting task of the first solo number, but you would never have known it. Her diction and tone were perfect, each word dripping with anger and determination as she belted higher and higher. The moments of softness were just as powerful, with her baby clasped to her chest as she looked down lovingly. The vocal control and emotional resonance were undeniable, and her beautifully belted final note left me with goosebumps.
The cast then took inspiration from the big screen, beginning with Santo Thomas bathed in a pool of pink light, immediately setting the jazzy, romantic tone of “It Takes Two” from Hairspray. Thomas made excellent use of a standing mic, tilting and turning it with smooth suaveness. His performance exuded charisma and control, providing confident belts before finishing on a lovely delicate, high riff. Not long after, he was joined by James Farrow, whose lower range blended perfectly with Thomas’, and their rendition of “Man or Muppet” was easily one of the highlights of the night. Farrow’s comedic timing and delivery were unmatched, and his humour suited the tune perfectly, taking an already hilarious number to new heights.
[Farrow’s] lower range blended perfectly with Thomas’, and their rendition of “Man or Muppet” was easily one of the highlights of the night
With showcases and cabarets, it can be hard to transition easily between numbers, especially when their tones differ wildly. Luckily, the lighting, designed by Abigail Harvey and operated by Madeleine Spraigue (supervised by Johnathon Wilson-Downs), did almost all of the heavy lifting in setting the mood, which was particularly tricky given some of the tight tonal shifts. This was certainly true of “Kindergarten Boyfriend” from Heathers, which followed straight after “It Takes Two”. With hazy blue lighting and Rosie Freeman’s heartwrenchingly expressive voice, the adjustment was effortless. For those unaware, the number is a heavy one, but with a few comedic moments slipped in, and Freeman took it in her stride, eliciting laughs before suddenly filling the room up with sorrow. Despite lacking a sense of desperation by the end, her powerful final vocals and a bright spotlight made the ending exactly as agonising as intended.
Molly Gribbon’s comedic timing was also a tour de force. “The History of Wrong Guys” from Kinky Boots is already amusing enough on the page, but Gribbon’s dedication made it hilarious. Every sudden gleam of hope, and the following exasperated sighs all landed, and the image of her hiding her face behind a newly crafted pair of shoes will stay with me for while, and left the audience in stitches. The act then closed with a splendid rendition of “Sunday” from Sunday in the Park with George, which eased the drag of the act, thanks in no small part to Amelia Ewing’s stunning, impressively high final note.
Ewing also shone in her duet with Gigi Donald in the next section: rock musicals. Tackling one of the most iconic musical openings, “Science Fiction, Double Feature” was brilliant, with both performers commanding the stage, Ewing’s vocals sounding as easy as breath and Donald working wonderfully to hype up the crowd. Their energy bounced off one another, only growing the longer they spent on stage, culminating in a stunning blend of their voices that only made the final harmonies resonate all the more.
“The History of Wrong Guys” from Kinky Boots is already amusing enough on the page, but Gribbon’s dedication made it hilarious
Evie Tickner’s “I Don’t Know How to Love Him” was the perfect match for her tone and vocal quality. Her face full of desire, she captured Mary Magdalene’s indecision with a beautifully controlled vibrato. A few members of the band struggled with this number, but Tickner refused to be thrown. Instead, she went up an octave for the final line, and the leap made the song’s closing admission of love feel all the more impassioned. She had already shown her range earlier in the night, with a tricky tap solo in “Someone in the Crowd” that never missed a beat.
While there were certainly difficulties with the sound, band and direction, I want to emphasise that this was easily one of the best showcases I have seen in Durham. When the direction was good, it was brilliant, filling the stage with charm, wit and unbridled energy. The sound during the solo and small group numbers worked well, and although the band faltered at times, they played admirably given the sheer amount of music asked of them. Above all, these freshers were unbelievably talented. Vocal chops, incredible acting, stage presence, chemistry with one another: even when something felt under-rehearsed, their skill kept it not just afloat, but soaring.
Durham student theatre should brace itself, because some insane talent has just walked through the door. Leaving the Assembly Rooms that night, all I could feel was an unshakeable anticipation for the future, for if these freshers are Durham’s new talent, then by god are we in safe hands.
Tone Deaf Theatre Company’s Freshers’ Showcase 2026 was performed at the Assembly Rooms Theatre on November 8th 2026.
Image Credit: Tone Deaf Theatre Company via @tdtcdurham on Instagram.

