Review: The Freshers’ Showcase 2025

By Alex Roy

Rating: 5 out of 5.

What better way to commence review-writing for this academic year than with Tone Deaf Theatre Company’s highly-anticipated The Freshers’ Showcase 2025! It is always an absolute joy to witness the promising talent that will grace Durham’s stages over the next year. Tonight, the DST community reunited, breathing life into a showcase of well-known musical works. Truly, watch this space: if tonight is any indication, the year ahead promises brilliance.

The showcase took us on a journey through time, from the Golden Age right up to the present day, oscillating between tonal beats, styles, and eras. At its heart, it celebrated connection: the joy and humanity that musical theatre embodies, both as a genre and as a craft. Co-direction by Talia Tobias and Maggie Thompson brought this vision to life. The choice to include off-stage narration to guide the audience through each era was inspired: not only did it cleverly disguise set and costume changes, but it also maintained a through-line that kept the audience anchored. 

Act One

We began in the Golden Age of theatre: Broadway in the 1940s. Fugue for the Tinhorns from Guys and Dolls set a high standard from the outset. It was a gorgeous ensemble number, featuring one of the few props in the evening, our very own Palatinate newspapers: a playful choice. From here, we moved chronologically to Something’s Coming from the 1957 West Side Story. The careful sequencing of songs made the concept feel cohesive, guiding the audience through a timeline of musical evolution. Sue Me, another Guys and Dolls number, followed, maintaining momentum beautifully.

The all-black costumes combined with this formation projected a professional polish that belied the performers’ fresher status

Transitioning into the 1960s and 70s, a more vibrant era of musical theatre, the narration introduced us to a new sonic landscape. The cast opened with Pure Imagination from the 1971 Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, a song choice that ignited magic. Each of the seven cast members took a single line before merging into a unison, underlining the ensemble’s cohesion. Grace Graham’s choreographic vision was striking, particularly through the ‘V’ formation upstage centre. The all-black costumes combined with this formation projected a professional polish that belied the performers’ fresher status.

Professionalism prevailed with Celine Delahaye’s rendition of Nancy’s As Long As He Needs Me from Oliver!. This piece allowed Delahaye to demonstrate gut-wrenching, character-driven power, her performance anchored in seemingly genuine yearning. This led seamlessly into Everything Was Beautiful at the Ballet from A Chorus Line, performed as a trio by Delahaye, Irini Sozomenou, and Lara Sowande. Sozomenou’s gorgeous alto tones complemented Sowande’s stunning soprano belt, creating a performance that was both delicate and dynamic.

Dixon commanded the space, evoking audible gasps from the audience: her performance was mesmerising

We then entered the “era of the mega-musical”: the 1980s. All I Ask of You from The Phantom of the Opera opened the section, showcasing the band’s ability to perfectly replicate familiarity: note for note, this was perfect. Noah Ligertwood’s lighting design, bathing the stage in deep blue, cleverly mirrored the iconic West End production, while the duo’s timing with the live accompaniment highlighted the tight coordination evident throughout. This was followed by Rainbow High from Evita, with Lizzie Dixon rising to the challenge of channeling Rachel Zegler’s viral rendition. The band’s dynamics here were essential, supporting Dixon and the ensemble, Louis Williams and Teni Taiwo, without overshadowing them. Dixon commanded the space, evoking audible gasps from the audience: her performance was mesmerising. Yasmine Berrada and Louis Williams then presented Waltz for Eva and Che, blending character work and choreography seamlessly.

Act One closed with a medley from Les Misérables. Taiwo’s rendition of Stars was painstaking and emotive, transitioning into the ensemble’s Do You Hear the People Sing?, a stirring, emotionally charged moment underscored by the band’s powerful accompaniment (directed by Zac Smith and Ben Armitage). Delahaye and Dixon then delivered I Dreamed a Dream/On My Own, their voices blending beautifully, doing utter justice to this gorgeous arrangement. Act One concluded with One Day More, colourfully lit in French flag hues, with clever gender-bending and playful exaggeration from Delahaye’s Madame Thenardier that elicited both laughter and applause.

Act Two

After the interval, the showcase turned to contemporary theatre. Welcome to the Rock from Come From Away opened the second act, an ensemble piece that oscillated between driving rhythms and gentle legato, drawing the audience into the theme of connection. Here, Graham’s choreography mirrored recent professional productions, and the band’s nuanced control of the tonal versatility in this number did not go unnoticed. Sowande then shone in Your Daddy’s Son from Ragtime, her commanding stage presence nodding to an increase in her confidence levels: a wonderful sight!

It was tender, emotional, and boundlessly beautiful

Williams and Sozomenou’s hilarious Therapy from Tick, Tick… Boom! highlighted their impeccable timing, supported by crisp, energetic playing from Zac Smith and Ben Armitage. Sozomenou and Berrada followed with Slipping Through My Fingers from Mamma Mia!, the harmonies were exquisitely framed and vocally nuanced. It was tender, emotional, and boundlessly beautiful. Taiwo and Delahaye closed the late noughties section with All the Wasted Time from Parade, their chemistry palpable.

Present-day theatre was showcased with Good For You from Dear Evan Hansen, featuring Delahaye, Sowande, Taiwo, and Williams. Backpacks and formations captured the essence of the original, while the band’s versatile playing – from Tilly Watkin’s expressive guitar to Smith and Armitage’s sensitive accompaniment – anchored the performance. Sozomenou followed with Say the Word from The Unauthorized Autobiography of Samantha Brown, a beautifully phrased, emotionally resonant number. Taiwo’s raw Leave, Luanne from 35mm: A Musical Exhibition was a masterclass in intensity and precision, spotlighting the potential of lesser-known contemporary musical theatre.

Heathers: The Musical concluded the show’s dramatic arc, with Dixon’s commanding Candy Store. Costuming subtly delineated characters (with red, green and yellow details), and Graham’s choreography captured the essence of the original production while remaining accessible and effective. The co-direction of Tobias and Thompson shone here, balancing humour, tension, and style: it was the choice to imagine the characters of Veronica and Martha, rather than actualising them that I took joy in. The subsequent option to invoke an imitation rather than an actualisation was effective, and hilarious. This moment was testament to the depth of the creative vision of these reimaginings. 

The penultimate number, Berrada’s When He Sees Me from Waitress, combined deliberately awkward physical comedy with breathtaking vocals, demonstrating both technical skill and characterisation. Finally, the ensemble delivered a triumphant From Now On, tying together the evening’s choreography, vocals, and narrative themes. The band’s performance was a highlight: vibrant, precise, and responsive, enabling each cast member to shine while maintaining a cohesive musical fabric. Williams’ soaring moments, and Sowade’s impressive riffs drew audible gasps, underscoring the evening’s triumphant conclusion.

In all, this year’s cohort of freshers have exceeded every expectation. TDTC’s The Freshers’ Showcase 2025 was a masterclass in musical theatre, showcasing the talent of both the cast, band and creatives with care. If the rest of the year is anything like this, Durham Student Theatre is in for a phenomenal season.

Tone Deaf Theatre Company’s The Freshers’ Showcase 2025 was performed on Saturday 25 October, 2025 at the Sir Thomas Allen Assembly Rooms Theatre.

Image credit – Tone Deaf Theatre Company via Instagram