Censorship in cinema: Hollywood and the Hays Code
By Zara Mason
By the 1920s, a state of moral panic surrounded Hollywood. Scandals such as the conviction of actor Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle in connection with the death of actress Virginia Rappe and the unsolved murder of William Desmond Taylor incensed religious pressure groups against the perceived debauchery and depravity of the film industry. In the wake of the Great Depression and faltering profit margins, studios wanted their films to have as much mass appeal as possible. Then in 1929, a group of Catholics came together to devise a list of moral restrictions, which formed the basis for the Motion Picture Production Code, later known as the Hays Code, declaring what was and was not appropriate to be seen on screen. Strict enforcement began in 1934 under the oversight of Joseph Breen and a seal of approval from the Production Code Administration became essentially mandatory for a film to be released in the US.
The Code condemned any works that “lower the moral standards” of viewers and decreed that “the sympathy of the audience shall never be thrown to the side of sin.” This prohibited the discussion or depiction of any sexually suggestive material including extramarital affairs or overly passionate kissing, no depictions of homosexuality (deemed ‘sexually perverse’), a ban on profanity and a necessity for the ‘bad guys’ to always meet a sticky end. This led to filmmakers having to alter scripts, and tone down their work. For example, Alfred Hitchcock’s 1940 adaptation of Rebecca alters the manner of Rebecca’s death, having her die accidentally rather than being murdered so as to not have the murderer escape without consequences. So, in order to present their artistic vision in an acceptable manner, filmmakers had to get creative.
In order to present their artistic vision in an acceptable manner, filmmakers had to get creative
Resistance through compliance?
Rather than relying on explicit portrayals of sex, violence, and criminal behaviour, films turned to coded references and double entendre so that everything not permissible lay just under the surface instead. Hitchcock was the king of skirting around the Code; to resist constraints on ‘excessive or lustful kissing,’ in Notorious the romantic leads break apart every few seconds mid two minute long kiss, and North by Northwestf amously ends with the main couple embracing, before cutting to a rather suggestive scene of a train rushing into a dark tunnel.

Critic Nora Gilbert argues that censorship actually worked with the filmmaker rather than against, with tales of subversive desire being well suited to an atmosphere of subtlety and subtext that is created when one cannot be explicit. Furthermore, the genres that gained prominence during this era of Hollywood like film noir and psychological horror thrive off the need for coded dialogue and innuendo. The restrictions of the Code forced writers to rely on sharp dialogue and suggestion, without relying on obscenity to create gripping films — yet there is still an unavoidable tension between this creativity and restriction limiting what could be done on screen.
Hitchcock was the king of skirting around the Code
The end of the Code
By the end of the 1950s, the Code’s grip on filmmakers gradually lost its tight hold. In 1959, Some Like It Hotwas released without the approval of the PCA due to its depiction of cross-dressing. Despite this, the film was a massive success, weakening the power of the censors by demonstrating that a film could be financially viable despite being condemned as ‘morally objectionable.’ As the 1960s progressed, the rise of television and foreign cinema as well as a decline in stringent moral standards of the past necessitated a loosening of the censors’ power, until the Code was officially abolished in 1968 and replaced by today’s modern MPAA rating system.
But echoes of the Code persist into the modern day, some more harmful than others. The ‘foot pop,’ a trope coined in The Princess Diaries, describes how a female character will raise her foot during a passionate embrace on screen, and may derive from Code era constraints on showing scenes with couples in bed together. However, with the Code forbidding depictions of interracial relationships, people of colour were passed over for parts in films and cut out of scripts for decades, with a lack of representation persisting long after the official end of the Code. Additionally, under the Code any characters that were subtextually coded as LGBTQ could only exist if they were portrayed as villains or were killed off, due to restrictions on ‘sexual perversity.’ This phenomenon of a disproportionate amount of queer characters being killed off in film continues to this day, suggesting even years later the Code’s influence still lingers over Hollywood.
Illustration: Eloise Nickols

