Review: The Hunchback of Notre Dame

By Anna Pile and Alice Groth

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Arguably one of Alan Menken and Stephen Schwartz’s most impressive feats, The Hunchback of Notre Dame is a heart-achingly human tale of love, loss, and everything in between.

Adapted from the novel of the same name, written by Victor Hugo, the narrative begins with Claude Frollo, the cathedral’s archdeacon, who is asked to take care of his late brother’s son. Disgusted by the boy’s mixed heritage, Frollo decides to raise him at the top of Notre Dame, away from the outside world. This only lasts so long though, as Quasimodo soon dreams of his freedom, something that is only exacerbated at the sight of the beautiful street dancer Esmerelda.

The sound and lighting teams were instrumental in curating the atmosphere of the production right from the start

The sound and lighting teams were instrumental in curating the atmosphere of the production right from the start. As the audience took their seats, soft choral music transported us to the titular cathedral. Beams of gentle red-and-yellow light streamed down on the stage, mimicking the effect of sunlight on stained glass, while the haze emerging from the wings seemed to evoke clouds of incense. The choir seated along the back wall completed the transformation of the theatre space into Notre Dame.

The sound was designed by Oliver Fitzgerald and operated by Tom Haigh, Elizabeth Wooldridge Smith and Olly Stones. The audio mix was skilfully done, adeptly moving between focalising the actors, choir and orchestra and ensuring that both lyrics and music were clearly audible. Audio clips of the bells of Notre Dame were played between scenes, a nice touch that kept the audience immersed in the world of the show.

Being one of their most impressive musicals, its complexity comes as no surprise. Phoenix Theatre understood this, and made decisions with clear effort to display every intricate detail with passion and respect. One of these decisions was to place the band and choir on the main stage, a nice tribute to just how crucial a part the score plays in the narrative and its themes. This directive decision of Grace Grady (assisted by Primavera Jones) was certainly an inspired one, but it must be said that there were multiple instances that the actors being on solely the apron was to their detriment, with my neck having to strain multiple times to watch the action, and certain instances of heavy movement feeling slightly stilted.

With this being said, the set design, by Josie Coyle and painted by Bee Wilkes, Emily Hogen, Nicola Ho, and Ming Zhang, as well as the stage crew, managed by Aniket Garg, deputy manager Aoife Bowles, assisted by Anna Devonshire, with fly operators Gemma Christie and Kai Doak, did an excellent job of utilising the space. While the Assembly Rooms stage may have been too small to truly pull off this idea, every inch was evidently used – and used well. The stage itself transported you into a gorgeous church, with a large stained window hanging above the band, its beauty immediately catching the eye, which was paired with a backdrop painted with the same design – some clear vision and dedication.

Amelia Awan should be proud for bringing to life a multitude of beautiful harmonies

The levitated area for the choir was also painted with wonderful detail, and showcased production manager Eva Ryan and her assistant Erin Bullen’s innovative creative vision that used the space to the best of its ability. Putting the choir above the band also allowed for their talent to truly shine. The problem lay with their use of microphones, which somewhat undermined their purpose as a group. They struggled to blend and their few instances of uncertainty were a lot more evident. However, their efforts tackling this challenging material were clear, and their vocal musical director Amelia Awan should be proud for bringing to life a multitude of beautiful harmonies.

Conducting not only a fourteen-piece band but also the choir is a daunting feat to say the least – but band musical director Timothy Tsang handled this with apparent ease, never allowing anyone to falter. The band themselves evidently deserved their spot in the centre of the stage, doing Alan Menken justice with an almost perfect rendering that elevated the entire night.

Taking on a role such as Frollo was a daring choice, but Fred Walmsley truly encapsulated the character with stride, bringing each insidious and unfathomable decision and motivation to the stage with a commanding vocal and physical presence. Although faltering at times to be as intimidating as Frollo demands, you could always see his unsettling thoughts coming to fruition beneath his eyes – an incredible acting touch. Louis Williams as Quasimodo perfectly captured his inner turmoil, with visible flinching, stutters in his dialouge – everything felt full of dread. Making Quasimodo’s “hunchback” to be purely a myth was a bold decision, and while a few moments did feel slightly confusing because of it, William’s performance never skipped a beat when insuring the character stayed just as sympathetic and endearing.

Her [Yasmine Berrada] strong yet angelic vocal tone, quality, and control left me in awe

Yasmine Berrada as Esmeralda danced onto the apron with such an amazing balance of grace and self-assuredness. With a tambourine in hand, she immediately took over the stage, and her strong yet angelic vocal tone, quality, and control left me in awe. She also provided a stellar acting performance, depicting both Esmeraldas strongest and weakest moments with unwavering spirit, along with sharing an electric energy with Pheobus, portrayed by Ben Armitage, and their slow-burn from foes to lovers was as heart-warming as it was, eventually, devastating.

Speaking of Armitage, his rendition of Phoebus took the audience to the heights of hilarity, then plunged us down into agonizing heartbreak – an incredible range. His comedic talent was present from the start, with his delivery of the line “I like all kinds of girls” followed by a proud smoulder left the audience creasing. Special mention must also be given to Moritz Afridi as Clopin, who filled the stage with energy and vocal precision, along with the ensemble, Abi Godden, Adam Johnston, Emma Rowson, Joshua Brooks, Sejal Khadakkar, and Joe Wilson for their flawless execution of their multiple roles, with each a very distinct, new character that was constantly performed with skill around the board.

The lighting for the production—designed by Val Devereux with Sarah Johnston and operated by Alex Richardson, Felix Napier and Siyi Ann—was deployed to great effect, heightening the intensity of climactic moments in the story. The colours were vibrant and evocative, a kaleidoscope of hues echoing the bright swirl of the stained- glass window at the back of the stage. The lighting strongly evoked the themes of the show; red light, whether a subtle hint or a full wash, was often used to augment the menacing presence of Frollo, while a cold blue wash emphasised Quasimodo’s isolation in his chilly tower room. In a particularly memorable moment, intense flickering red-and-yellow lights provided a visceral visualisation of the flames Frollo imagined engulfing Esmerelda. In the show’s finale, a flare of white light backlit the cast and bathed the audience in brightness, implicating us all in the consideration of its final question: “What makes a monster and what makes a man?”.

To conclude, this rendition of Huntchback of Notre Dame transported you into fifteenth-century Paris in almost every sense, with a sweeping atmosphere, incredible acting and vocal quality, and a set of gorgeous proportions. It was a joy to wonder at every aspect, and each and everyone involved deserves the upmost praise.

Image credit – Phoenix Theatre via @phoenix_theatre on Instagram.