Review: Brontë

By Ralph Hargreaves

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Third Space Theatre Company’s iteration of Polly Teal’s Brontë is an entirely charming production that marks the end of another successful term of student theatre under the lights of the Assembly Rooms Theatre.  At its core, a number of excellent performances elevate the play into resounding success.

Brontë tells the story of the life of the Brontë sisters and the struggles and conflicts which inspired their iconic literature. The story follows the three as they deal with their burdening careers, all in secret from their authoritative father and belittling brother. 

Brightening this set is some lovely lighting, designed by Cassia Thurston, that is varied in both scope and colour, rising to the challenge of spotlighting characters

Immediately striking is the beautifully designed stage that is fully fleshed out to create the Brontë’s home. All the wooden furniture is perfectly fitting; the back wall is filled with books and hung with pictures all to build up this domestic affair. Brightening this set is some lovely lighting, designed by Cassia Thurston, that is varied in both scope and colour, rising to the challenge of spotlighting characters entering down past the audience a number of times. Similarly, I thought the sound design, designed by Oliver Fitzgerald, backed up the more emotional moments very well, although I thought there needed to be a more noticeable fade for the end of effects so that music didn’t end quite so abruptly. Additionally, I really liked the costume design by Ellie Kinch as the three sisters are decorated in period-accurate dresses and three different colours to give them visually distinct appearances. 

However, the key to this performance’s success is undoubtedly the strength of the acting, which is consistently good across a cast of just seven actors. The dynamic between all three Brontë sisters is brilliant, with the most time given to fleshing out the bubbling tensions between Charlotte (Peony Reece) and Emily (Martha Buttle). The two play off each other very well with their frequent clashes constantly raising tensions and building the drama. I also enjoyed Jake O’Donnell’s performance as the domineering, and quite frankly scary, father figure who tries to keep the three girls in line; he is totally in control of his dynamic range the whole way through to establish authority. Similarly, Matthew Lo delivers wonderfully in his trio of roles, delivering an unexpectedly hilarious turn in the play’s climax. Nevertheless, the most committed performance comes in the form of Branwell Brontë, played by Jack Guilfoyle, who embodies this utterly detestable character before his downfall in the second half. 

I also thought there were a number of great directorial choices, under the watchful eye of Grace Graham, that contributed to the creation of this spectacle

I also thought there were a number of great directorial choices, under the watchful eye of Grace Graham, that contributed to the creation of this spectacle. Throughout the play, different characters suddenly switch into fictional characters from within the Brontë’s books and deliver lines in perfect unison with the sisters. The use of the three sisters as narrators at varying moments also works well, seamlessly switching from sister to narrator and back again. However, even if you are familiar with the Brontës’ fiction, it’s sometimes a little confusing when a character switches from a historical figure into a fictional one from their writing – although I think this is more a pitfall of the original script. I’d have also liked to see a little more consistency over accents, as the cast doesn’t seem unified over one specific accent choice. 

Nevertheless, the play builds towards a dramatic ending that pulls on the audience’s heartstrings as characters die – as in real life –  suddenly and unexpectedly. Branwell’s death scene in particular features a really touching choice that sees the sisters mourning at the front of the stage, as he acts out childhood fantasies on a chair in the middle of the stage, recalling the first half’s initial domestic bliss that has subsequently been shattered. 

Overall, the play is a resounding success through its balancing over excellent performances all-round with suitable directing choices that bring the Brontë sisters’ story entirely to life. The consistent standard set throughout all facets of the production really exemplifies what makes student theatre so brilliant in Durham.

Brontë is playing in the Sir Thomas Allen Assembly Rooms until Friday 12th December, 2025. Get your tickets here. 

Image credit – Third Space Theatre Company via thirdspacetheatrecompany on Instagram.