Review: And Then There Were None

By Ralph Hargreaves

Rating: 4 out of 5.

As our evenings get colder there is perhaps no greater pleasure than getting wrapped up in a good old-fashioned murder mystery story. Thus, I found Sixth Side’s production of Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None to be the perfect remedy for my chills, a classic whodunnit executed with charm and comic wit in generous supply.

I consider And Then There Were None to be one of my favourite mysteries; the premise is devious: 10 strangers on a remote island, all gathered by a shadowy, unknown figure (mysteriously called “U.N Owen”), who suddenly begin perishing in accordance with a chilling poem about 10 soldier boys. As the numbers dwindle, the characters are forced to turn upon each other and consider whether the figure orchestrating the debacle is amongst them. 

the cast’s immediate greatest strength resides in their ability to create 10 distinct characters

Staged in the Dowrick Theatre of Trevelyan College, the cast are working with an incredibly small and sparsely decorated stage which features a long couch centre-stage, with the ten characters perching on and mingling around it. The cast’s immediate greatest strength resides in their ability to create 10 distinct characters that stand out from the next, especially as in such a small space it could be easy for characters to blend together. Upstage lies a table with 10 little figurines – the 10 “little soldier boys” from the mystery’s central rhyme – which curiously start to disappear in turn as characters perish. At times, I became distracted in an effort to notice the palming of each figurine by passing characters, with each disappearance falling in line with that of a character.

The standout performance comes from Jasper Kyriakoundis’ suspicious Mr Davis, whose ridiculous South African accent is downright hilarious, leaving the audience – and almost some members of the cast – in stitches. Truthfully, the entire cast appears eager, and enthusiastic, managing to strike the right balance of individual suspicion, such that the audience are left guessing until the very end. Another favourite performance was that of by William Bradley, playing the old, and slightly crazed, Mackenzie with total energy. One particular moment sees his previously frail character burst out of his chair in a state of mania that almost had me jumping out of my own chair; alongside Bradley’s stellar performance, moments such as this are testament to the genius direction of Joshua Brooks. 

One of the biggest difficulties of staging this particular production is in the technical handling of some of the play’s murders which frequently contain complex elements; yet the direction of Brooks carefully balanced having various murders happen both on-stage and off – with characters at times opening the theatre’s doors to peer outside onto an implied grisly scene. The lighting, operated by Layla Rodrigues, is also utilised most effectively in a thrilling moment when an out-of-view scream prompts the entire stage to be plunged into darkness with characters forced to grope around under dim candlelight, before the lights come up to reveal yet another body. 

a change that I found hugely successful as it allowed for the impact of the reveal to be felt

The play builds up to a fever pitch by the end, although at times all the actors are giving out so much effort that the coherence of line delivery is forced into question. However, the overall flow is rarely disrupted and the cast are able to successfully pull off one of my all-time favourite literary climaxes. Whilst I won’t spoil the ending of the play, the production chooses to change Agatha Christie’s decision in the book to reveal the murderer in an epilogue separate to the main events. Instead, the main villain is revealed in entirety to the audience in a change that I found hugely successful as it allowed for the impact of the reveal to be felt: certainly the number of people behind me who audibly gasped at the reveal agreed at least. 

Overall, I thought that the performance did utter justice to one of the most beloved whodunnits ever written, bringing equal parts drama, comedy and – most importantly – mystery to the stage. I had come into the theatre chilled from the cold outside, and left chilled only by such an enjoyably twisted production. 

And Then There Were None was performed at Trevelyan College’s Dowrick Theatre by Sixth Side Productions on Thursday 30th and Friday 31st October 2025.

Image credit – Sixth Side Theatre via Instagram (@sixthsidetheatre)