Review: Blood Brothers (Sunderland Empire)

By Ralph Hargreaves

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Willy Russell’s Blood Brothers sits firmly in the theatrical canon as one of the most distinctly British shows of all time, and has been enthralling audiences for decades. Back again to tell its harrowing tale of friendship, class and tragedy, Blood Brothers has returned to the Sunderland Empire as part of its latest tour. So if you haven’t heard the story of the Johnstone twins, it might be worth taking the time to come and experience it for yourself.

Starting in 1960s Liverpool, Blood Brothers centers around two twin brothers, Mickey and Eddie, who are separated at birth and grow up in polarising conditions – one as rich and the other as poor. Yet despite their divergent economic positions, they cannot help but intersect into each other’s lives as they barrel towards the play’s emotional ending. It is an ending which is foretold from the show’s very first moment but yet it keeps the audiences hanging on in the hope that, as the musical’s first and last number beg, it’s not true.

Despite the main plot revolving around the two brother’s plight, the central character and the driving heartbeat of the story is their mother, Mrs Johnstone. Taking up the role is Vivienne Carlyle who is undeniably excellent. Carlyle consistently anchors the story’s emotional beats and it is through her that the show’s incredible highs and devastating lows run. Time and time again, the emotional spectacle of the entire show is firmly established by her dynamic performance and soaring vocals. Breathtaking vocals are not in short supply either with Kristofer Harding’s portrayal of the narrator. He is almost sinister in his languishing of such a foreboding role as the narrator seems to revel in his knowledge of the show’s tragic turns. 

Time and time again, the emotional spectacle of the entire show is firmly established by her dynamic performance and soaring vocals

Younger audiences may be most familiar with this musical through its seeming ever-presence as a text on the GCSE drama syllabus. However, those who studied it at this level will likely be unfamiliar with these lines being delivered with such will and dramatic quality. In fact, the show shines brightest during its portrayal of the character’s younger versions. The use of adults playing the roles of children can – in other shows – be a little jarring, and yet the duo of Eddie (Joe Sleight) and Mickey (Sean Jones) are simply excellent. From the start, the two characters are just seven years old (“Nearly eight!”) but nevertheless every single one of the actors’ mannerisms and movements remain wholly believable in creating the figures of children. Jones’ Mickey is petulant and easily frustrated whilst Sleight’s Eddie is rigorously well-mannered and ignorant, and together the pair’s dynamic is simply wonderful. The subtle shifts to their characters, fundamentally to the way they move and talk, is realised on stage in front of the audience’s own eyes and almost acts as its own stunning showcase of the pair’s acting range.

Every single staging transition is carried out with near-perfection

It would be remiss to go much further without mentioning the show’s technical qualities, which only serve to enhance the acting on show. Designer Andy Walmsley creates a stage that entirely brings this world of 20th Merseyside to life, with brick housing rising on both sides of the stage to create the illusion of the street. Additional set pieces, that transform the street from urban jungle to rural landscape, are all beautifully crafted and are often lowered to the stage from the ceiling. Every single staging transition is carried out with near-perfection, never once interrupting the show’s flow. The lighting too is yet another hallmark of the show’s technical excellence, frequently making use of spotlights to illuminate characters in their most isolated moments. In one moment, the stage is entirely flooded with red light as a gripping visual indicator of the show’s climax. The show’s music is also underscored by a live six-piece band, led by Musical Director Matt Malone on the keys, which further places the show into the 1980s with its shimmering synths and sweltering saxophones. The instruments are bathed in layers of layers of reverb, that whilst occasionally can be a little overbearing, still work to create an ethereal atmosphere as the characters go about their lives unaware of the ending awaiting them.

Any of my reservations with the show largely lie in the original script, as the pacing does seem to lag a little near the middle, but by the time the climax does eventually come it is an entirely earned emotional finale. The show’s final moments are overtly signposted and yet when the shocking, final moment occurs it had almost every member of the audience out of their seat – it was so intense that a wave of laughter broke out as people recovered from the most shocking moment.

Blood Brothers is at once laugh-out-loud funny and at another heart-wrenchingly pained. It is an emotional odyssey that will bring a tear to the eye of even the most stoic of audience members, and even after 40 years the show remains an unmissable experience.

Blood Brothers was performed at the Sunderland Empire on 17th March 2026, running for another four performances until the 21st March.

Image credit – Jack Merriman