Pearly whites: how pearls functioned as markers of identity in the Late Renaissance
By Mya Downing
Pearls are notorious in visual culture for being an emblem of purity. They are a symbol of great virtue and chastity, and this meaning is understood by many, regardless of their level of understanding in material history. Yet, there is a greater, more unknown element to this precious gemstone: its ability to also symbolise the mistress. Please, I ask you, to grab a cup of tea, come sit with me, and relax, as we venture on a short journey through the Late Renaissance and discuss how the pearl developed from being a token of virginity and lasting power, to one of liminal promiscuity and rapid social ascendancy.
Throughout the 16th and 17th centuries, pearls were inextricably linked to a woman’s political identity and her perceived worth and value
Throughout the 16th and 17th centuries, pearls were inextricably linked to a woman’s political identity and her perceived worth and value. We can look to the example of Queen Elizabeth I to help us truly understand the nature of this gemstone’s representation. Elizabeth’s incessant adornment in pearls highlights her great favour for the jewel, and no clearer may its symbolic attributes be seen than in the Armada Portrait (fig. 1), which is now currently hanging in the National Maritime Museum in Greenwich. In it, we can see the Queen heavily ladened with the gemstone. The hundreds of pearls Elizabeth wears act as a well-understood symbol of purity. The round shape of the pearl, along with its milky surface, enabled early modern memory to allude to the moon and conceptions of the Roman Goddess Diana. In doing so, the mind was permitted to wander and create subconscious connections between the Queen of England and chastity as well as, though seemingly contradictory, motherhood, in linking Diana, goddess of fertility and childbirth, to Elizabeth, the ‘mother’ and protector of England. It is also no coincidence that there is an uncanny similarity between the Queen’s complexion and the surface of the pearl. It further succeeds in portraying Elizabeth as even more ‘pearl-like’ in the audience’s gaze. Yet, the Armada Portrait is not meant to purely be a display of the Virgin Queen but is moreover a demonstration of her immense maritime power, and this idea is also enabled by the application of the pearl to Elizabeth’s identity. The Armada Portrait was a commemoration of the English’s victory over the Spanish. The use of the pearl, owing to its associations with the sea, is therefore additionally highlighting the naval prowess of the British Crown. Therefore, when understanding the pearl’s symbolism in association to Queen Elizabeth I, it appears, more than anything, to be a reflection of her inner virtue. If we consider Elizabeth as the pearl of England, we may understand the gemstone through our understanding of her: an emblem of both immense chastity and impressive victory.

However, the above is all information that most would regard as common: pearls being symbols of purity. I know we are all here to comprehend how this token of chastity transitioned so extremely to also being one of sexuality. How did such a gemstone go from dressing the Queen to dressing the courtesan? To answer this question, I ask you to turn your gaze to Caravaggio’s infamous painting of The Penitent Magdalene (fig. 2). In it, we may see a defeated Mary, broken and discarded, with this pathos being reflected in her abandonment of the pearls that once hung around her neck. The pearls in this picture, as ever, represent purity, yet their broken nature embody a new development to their characterisation, that of ruptured chastity. There has been vast debate on Caravaggio’s distinctive approach to portraying Mary Magdalene as a 16th century girl-next-door, rather than the heralded saint most tend to present her as. Yet, it has been theorised that the violent realism Caravaggio afforded to Mary, seen through her broken pearls and swollen face and hands, may be a form of political commentary on the mistreatment of courtesans by the police in Rome during Caravaggio’s time. In aligning a saint, a being of perhaps the greatest purity, with the courtesan, we can deduce how the gemstone of virginity succeeded in its great tonal shift, and how it may have transitioned from adorning the monarch most pure, to adorning the mistress.

Their monetary worth frequently fluctuated, and this changeability was adored by artists, since it could be applied as a metaphor for a change in power
Now that we have traversed through why the pearl may display dual associations to sanctity and sensuality, let us perceive how these ideas of sexual accessibility and political mobility were portrayed. In the court of Charles II, the pearl was preferred in dressing the courtesan rather than the king. If we look at Verelst’s portrait of Eleanor Gwynn (fig. 3), one of Charles’ many mistresses, this incredible distinction may be clearly depicted. The central display of pearls on Gwynn’s neck in the portrait draw the eye to her bare chest, hinting at her unrestrained sexuality, applying the gemstone to highlight sensuality, rather than its traditional purity. Not only is the gemstone applied to demonstrate sex, but it is also implemented to accentuate the rapid rise in power of Gwynn. Pearls were a commodity of no fixed value. Their monetary worth frequently fluctuated, and this changeability was adored by artists, since it could be applied as a metaphor for a change in power. The humble-born Gwynn was able to wear such extravagant jewels, which not long ago had adorned one of the most successful monarchs England had ever seen, owing to her recent rise in status from a person of no noble standing to someone able to control, albeit sexually, the King of England. Pearls were a jewel that could display changing fortunes, and as such were worn by those who exhibited the same oscillating nature in Caroline portraiture.

So where does that leave us, in understanding how the pearl was used to illustrate Late Renaissance identity? Whilst it was traditionally applied to portraits of Queen Elizabeth I to demonstrate her purity and military prowess, it could also be used to signify the sexuality and social mobility of courtesan women, as highlighted by its use in regard to Eleanor Gwynn. Ultimately, the unknowable value and fluctuating status of the pearl enabled it to emblemise the differing depictions of female identity in the early modern court, allowing it to be both a token of virginity and a declaration of sex. Next time you declare something to be as ‘pure as a pearl’, make sure to signify you are speaking in Elizabethan terms, since otherwise you may be misunderstood as calling someone an unstable harlot, rather than a virgin queen.
Images: via Wikipedia and The National Portrait Gallery

