Oval Office Dispute: A Win for Russia? 

By Natalie Andrusyschyn and George Baker

“Zelenskyy does not want peace.” This was the claim made by US President Donald Trump and echoed by the Kremlin after Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Mr Trump clashed over the terms of a peace deal to end the war in Ukraine. The consequence of this remarkable incident in the Oval Office was a significant breakdown in once-close Ukraine-US relations. Whilst the length of this breakdown is uncertain, Mr Trump’s behaviour towards Mr Zelenskyy was music to the ears of Kremlin officials, who were no doubt closely watching.

Mr Zelenskyy was the target of a tag team humiliation by Mr Trump and Vice President JD Vance: he was accused of being “ungrateful” for US aid despite him having opened the meeting by thanking Mr Trump. Since the start of the war, CNN reporting indicates Mr Zelenskyy has thanked the US over 33 times for their support. Following the spat, Mr Zelenskyy was made to leave the White House without signing what was supposed to be a critical mineral deal, with Ukraine’s president told to come back when he was “ready for peace”. 

This publicly aired humiliation appears to have been pleasing to the Kremlin, helping it to disseminate its message that it is not Vladimir Putin, but Mr Zelenskyy, who wants the war to continue. This is despite Russia’s invasion and continued bombardment of Ukrainian cities. Deputy Chair of Russia’s Security Council, Dmitry Medvedev, celebrated the “slap down” Mr Zelenskyy “finally” got in the Oval Office, posting his thoughts on X, praising Mr Trump in the process.

This pause in aid from the US following the press conference is another obvious win for Russia

Hours after the press conference, Mr Zelenskyy took to Fox News, once again thanking the US for their past military support. He also stressed the need for guarantees of future protections for Ukraine to be central to any “just and lasting” peace deal. This is viewed as crucial, as without them there are fears Russia would be given ample time to rearm and invade Ukraine once again. Tass, a major Russian state broadcaster, praised the US and Russia for being “responsible great powers”, whilst European nations still advocating for security assurances were deemed “less capable” and ultimately a barrier to progress in negotiations. The US’ reluctance to offer Ukraine any security guarantees led Kremlin Press Secretary Dmitry Peskov to claim that the US is “largely aligning with our [Russian] vision”, signalling that Mr Trump had given Russia the outcome it desires. 

Moscow will also celebrate a divided West. After the incident, European leaders doubled down in their support of Mr Zelenskyy on X. Trump, however, took to X to further express his frustration at Mr Zelenskyy’s alleged lack of desire for peace. This rhetorical divide was mirrored in the actions taken in the days following, with UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer announcing a new £1.6bn missile package for Ukraine, in stark contrast to the US’ decision to suspend military aid to the country. Aid already on its way will now stay in Poland, significantly disadvantaging Ukraine’s position on the battlefield with almost immediate effect. Ukrainian leadership fears that, even with Europe likely to substantially ramp up its aid contributions, fighting without the US’ support is unsustainable due to a reliance on American weapons and assistance in servicing F16 fighter jets. 

This pause in aid from the US following the press conference is another obvious win for Russia, as it claims the pause is Trump’s “best contribution to peace” thus far, as Ukraine loses significant leverage. There are now reports Mr Zelenskyy has begun to consider a partial truce which would not include security guarantees at this stage, due to the difficulties Ukraine would encounter in continuing to fight without US support.

Image: The White House via Wikimedia Commons