HMP Durham criticised for improper use of restraints on inmate

By Oliver Smith

HMP Durham has been criticised in a recent Prisons and Probation Ombudsman report which labelled the restraining of a William Dawson, a 64-year-old disabled prisoner, as “unjustified and not in line with the policy framework”. Dawson was being escorted to hospital, where he died two months later from pancreatic cancer, when he was restrained with a long metal cable with cuffs at either end. The report found that the use of restraints was “unjustified,” given his deteriorating condition. It concluded that prison officials failed to adequately assess Dawson’s mobility and health needs, leading to unnecessary and disproportionate security measures. 

The policy for restraining inmates – The Prevention of Escape: External Escorts states that restraints should be used in cases of limited mobility. However, Dawson’s medical section of his risk assessment did not mention he was a double-leg amputee or that there should have been medical objections to restraints. He also suffered from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and required a wheelchair. 

The report also criticised the prison for not following national guidelines on the treatment of seriously ill inmates, which state that restraints should only be used when there is an assessed risk of escape or violence. In Dawson’s case, the ombudsman found no such risk. 

Prison officials failed to adequately assess Dawson’s mobility and health needs

HMP Durham has previously faced criticism for its handling of inmates with complex health needs. Simon Parkinson, a former inmate, was restrained while receiving hospital treatment despite having no coordination or movement in his right arm and leg. He remained in restraints at the hospital for two days, secured with a single cuff and escort chain. Following this period, he became completely paralyzed on his right side and lost the ability to speak or swallow, according to a report on his death. 

The report concluded that restraining Parkinson was unjustified. Additionally, a January 2023 report by the Prisons and Probation Ombudsman (PPO) on the death of Jonathon Hogg at HMP Durham found that the 53-year-old was handcuffed and chained when taken to the hospital, despite being unresponsive and seriously ill. Investigators noted that his risk assessment incorrectly stated that he had no medical condition which affected the risk of escape. 

 A 2023 report by HM Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) described the prison as overcrowded and struggling to provide adequate healthcare. The facility, which primarily serves as a reception prison for new inmates, has been flagged multiple times for poor conditions and high rates of self-harm among prisoners. In 2020, the Senior Assistant Coroner, Crispin Oliver stated that action needed to be taken to address the ‘’critical lack of staffing’’ at the prison following the suicide of inmate Michael Smith 32. An inquest also found that the restraining methods used when escorting him to the segregation unit. 

“The situation at HMP Durham is unacceptable”

prison officers association

In August 2024, the HMIP reported that the prison was running at 172% capacity and a report from February this year stated that attempts to solve the problem have been ‘’insufficient’’. It concluded that a third of prisoners spend around 22 hours a day in their cells and often sharing cells meant for one inmate. Additionally, concerns have been raised around the adequacy of medical tests upon arrival, which could contribute to a breakdown in communication over appropriate restraints. 

Mark Fairhurst, National Chair of the Prison Officers Association (POA) stated: “The situation at HMP Durham is unacceptable.”

“Our members are trying to deal with an overcrowded prison where tensions are high and out of cell time limited; this stokes rising levels of frustration and violence.”

HMIP told Palatinate that the report ‘’does show insufficient progress in many of the concerns we raised at our previous inspection.’’ 

Image Credit: Gareth Milner via Flickr