New World Order or disorder under Trump? 

By Natalie Andrusyschyn

The international system established in the Cold war era situated the west against the east: Europe and the US allied together based on shared democratic values against autocratic China, Russia and North Korea. However, the foundations of this order have become very shaky since Trump took office for the second time. Trump, through his parroting of Kremlin talking points on the war in Ukraine; erection of steep tariffs against Canada and Europe, countries who have historically been the US’ allies; and withdrawal from international aid organisations is threatening the stability of the transatlantic order.

A once united West in their stance on the war in Ukraine now stands divided. Whilst Trump humours the Kremlin, European leaders have continued to back Ukraine by coming to Zelenskyy’s defence. If the US joining North Korea and Russia in voting against a UN resolution condemning Russia’s aggression towards Ukraine does not spell out the US’ 180 degrees policy shift on the Russo-Ukrainian war from the previous Biden administration’s, the decisions made by Trump that followed certainly do. Trump and JD Vance joined together in a tag team humiliation of Zelenskyy in the Oval Office. Trump called Zelenskyy, not Putin, a “dictator”, despite Russia having had rigged elections for the over half a century that Putin has been in power overall. The US then suspended military aid and intelligence sharing to Ukraine. When Zelenskyy refuted Trump’s claim that he does not want peace by agreeing to enter peace talks, Trump still expressed sympathies with the Russian side. Trump described his talks with Putin as “productive”, despite the Kremlin not agreeing to the terms of his proposed ceasefire which only served to drag the war out for longer. This is while European leaders, like the UK’s PM Starmer have continued to align with Ukraine’s position that Putin is the one “not serious about peace”, both as a result of these talks and because Putin caused the war by invading Ukraine– a reality that Trump has not accepted. 

Trump called Zelenskyy, not Putin, a “dictator”, despite Russia having had rigged elections for the over half a century that Putin has been in power overall

As historian Timothy Snyder has aptly written: “during a war of aggression, the aggressor cannot simply be humoured, as Trump proposes, during a process that aims at peace”, so why is Trump not taking a tough stance on Russia? There are several possible explanations. Firstly, to satisfy Trump’s personal interests: he has long had the desire to drive the US towards an autocracy by abandoning their commitment to its democratic European allies in favour of pursuing an alliance with dictators like Hungary’s Orban and Russia’s Putin. Trump longs for what Putin has: unchecked power, and a press that cannot criticize him. Secondly, because Trump likes the ‘might is right’ approach whereby strong countries decide the fate of smaller ones. Trump wants to return to a world in which the great powers call all the shots, seen in his mineral deal with Ukraine. Whilst the US has given Ukraine $67 billion in aid, they want to extract seven times as much from Ukrainian mineral deposits. This signals Trump’s broader desire to create a world dominated by autocracies in which the lesser powers are forced to fall in line. Lastly, Trump wants to normalize his relationship with the Russians, as a senior European official stated after the Munich security conference. Trump has flirted with the idea of removing sanctions to rebuild economic relations with Russia, which could also serve to draw Russia away from an alliance with China. Whatever Trump’s motives, the Kremlin is jubilant, with Russian TV propagandist Solovyov describing Trump as Russia’s “situational ally.” 

Trump longs for what Putin has: unchecked power, and a press that cannot criticize him

Trump’s shift in allyship has already seen to spell an irreversible shift in the liberal international order. His abandonment of his commitment to Europe, especially to NATO, has forced Europe to step up. Merz, the new German chancellor declared German independence from the US as an “absolute priority.” This belief is already seen through the pledges of European nations to increase defence spending. The US’ 80 years of power and prestige, gained in part by its establishment of NATO in 1949 and its hitherto leadership of the military alliance, has crumbled and it is difficult to imagine European trust in the US being restored. 

The tariffs Trump has erected on China, Europe and Canada do not come as a total surprise, signalling a continuation of the “America First” policies of his first term in office. However, the aggressiveness of these tariffs of up to 50% is more unprecedented, ending decades of US trade policy. They fail to differentiate between what have historically been the US’ allies – EU nations, and the US’ strategic competitors – mainly China. This is under Trump’s strongly held belief that Europe is leeching off the American economy. 

Looking to the other side of the pond, Trump’s threat of 50% tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminium emerges through his attempts to gain leverage over Canada as he continues to float the idea that Canada should become the 51st state of America. This expansions ambition is fanatical; it fails to consider the long-term ramifications of destroying the US’ relationship with its historically closest ally and of absorbing a country of 40 million people. Canada’s newly elected PM Carney called these “dark days” caused by “a country we can no longer trust.” As a result of the announcement of these tariffs, the US stock market plunged amid uncertainty. It is unclear to what strategic ends Trump is making these decisions. These tariffs signal a departure from the 1990s, thought to mark the “end of history” where the liberal capitalist values of free trade and globalization triumphed over the autocratic policies of the Soviet Union. Trump has withdrawn from that liberal ideal with great cost. China is now in the position to market itself as a more reliable trade partner than the US. 

Lastly, Trump’s assault on international organizations marks a steep departure from past US foreign policy. Roosevelt established the UN to bolster global cooperation after WW2. Since then, the US has been heavily involved in multilateral institutions to support peace and prosperity. However, the days of US involvement in such organizations seems to be coming to an end. Trump has signed an executive order that gives the US government 180 days to review US participation in multilateral organizations. He also shut down US AID, withdrew the US from the UNHRC, and from the aid agencies providing aid to Palestinian refugees. 

For the US to have had a leading hand in the establishment of the UN and then for Trump to have done this is telling of the world view of the new administration – one that wrongly concludes that these institutions quell, not bolster, US power. Trump fails to see that rules-based institutions were set up to project US influence. It was not as an act of charity, but as an act of  US self-interest. These institutions serve the same purpose today: to continue propagating US dominance through a shared legal and institutional framework led by the US and spread to member states. Trump has said that the costs of US membership outweigh the benefits. However, this is just not the case. In 2022, the US contributed $18 billion to the UN, a meager 2% of what they spends annually on military defense. As Oscar Wilde said: a cynic is “a man who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing.” Trump so perfectly fits this description in his view of these important multilateral institutions.

We are in the unfortunate situation in which the US seems to be unravelling the liberal order that it set up and that has served it and its allies well in the past. Trump has abandoned the US’ defense of democracy by cosying up to Putin, the aggressor who caused the war in Ukraine, and restricting free trade by erecting tariffs against the US’ long term allies. The US’ global prestige risks being irreversibly shattered thanks to Trump’s shortsighted decision to withdraw from international organizations. Order exists only when it flows from a power source; with the US ceasing to engage productively with its allies, the liberal order is beginning to break down and descend into chaos. 

Image credit: European Commission via Wikimedia commons