Could the Equal Rights Amendment technically be ratified?
By Daisy Rought-Oram
“Do you want to lose your life savings because we put a weak and foolish woman in the White House?”; “somehow – a woman – somehow she’s doing better than [President Joe Biden] did”; “you’ve got to deny, deny deny, and push back on these women”. All these phrases have been spoken by the 47th President of the United States. Donald Trump appears to possess very little respect, if not outright contempt, for women. With the original intention of the Constitution’s conveners being to protect the rights of citizens – granted, the scope of rights has expanded from that of the Founding Fathers – from the potential for such rights to be taken away, ratification of the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) would ensure the US Constitution lived up to its intended purpose. In his final days before leaving office, Joe Biden declared the Equal Rights Amendment the 28th Amendment of the US Constitution. Not an executive action, or a call for legislative or public progress, but an affirmation of what he considered to be an existing truth.
The Equal Rights Amendment was first written in 1923 by women’s rights activist Alice Paul. It would provide for constitutional equality on the basis of sex, with Section 1 stating “equality of the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex”. Section 2 goes on to give Congress the power of enforcement. The ERA was first introduced to Congress in the same year of its writing, and continued to be reintroduced until it was approved in 1972, with a deadline for the ratification by ¾ of state legislatures set for March 1979. Having been ratified by 35 of the 38 required states by 1977, in 1978 Congress voted to extend the deadline to 1982. Despite the fact that Jimmy Carter, a proponent of the ERA, sat in the White House during this extended period, no further states ratified. Since then, however, multiple states have announced a decision to ratify, most recently Virginia in 2020, which became the 38th state.
However, since the original window for ratification, five states – Idaho, Nebraska, South Dakota, and Tennessee – have chosen to rescind their decision. This has been a substantial cause for contention of those, like Mr. Biden, who claim that the ERA is already the 28th Amendment, and that the US Archivist should add it to the Constitution accordingly. In addition, as the original deadline has already passed, in line with the formal process outlined by Article V of the US Constitution, the ERA could only hope to be made the 28th amendment if it was to be reintroduced to Congress, and for the process to begin again. Without this, the amendment would lack legal and constitutional legitimacy.
The appearance of genuine legal and constitutional legitimacy is necessary to ensure the prospective amendment holds the power it needs at a time in which women’s rights are coming increasingly under threat
The American Bar Association’s position is that “no time limit was included in the text of the Equal Rights Amendment”, and that “the Constitution’s framers wisely avoided the chaos that would have resulted if states were able to take back the ratifying votes at any time” (CNN), referring to the fact that Article V does not give formal legitimacy to states rescinding earlier ratification. On the other hand, Shogan, US Archivist, whose role is “purely ministerial” said in December that the amendment cannot be codified “due to established legal, judicial, and procedural decisions”, citing conclusions from 2020 and 2022 by the Office of Legal Counsel that stated the ascribed deadlines for ratification are enforceable. Shortly before her death in 2020, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, a “die-hard” supporter of the ERA declared that “we’ll be starting over again collecting the necessary states to ratify it”.
Simply the fact that such a division of opinion exists demonstrates the need for Congress to reintroduce and re-approve the amendment. Already contentious, the Equal Rights Amendment would only possess the strength so desperately needed in the current climate if the process were to begin again. The appearance of genuine legal and constitutional legitimacy is necessary to ensure the prospective amendment holds the power it needs at a time in which women’s rights are coming increasingly under threat. With a President in office who has boasted about appointing the “anti-abortion justices” who overturned Roe, the ERA needs all the legitimacy it can get.
The well-meaning tactic employed by campaigners of insisting on the existing ratification of the ERA as the 28th Amendment is a tried and failed attempt. Going forward, supporters of the ERA in Congress should keep the battle alive, albeit under a President who will not issue such supportive statements as Mr Biden has done. President Trump’s residence in the White House makes the Congressional battle for ERA ratification all the more important.
Image credit: The US National Archives via Wikimedia commons

