Israel and Hamas reach long-awaited ceasefire

By George Baker

After 15 months, Israel and Hamas have reached a ceasefire – an agreement which came into effect at 9:15am GMT on Sunday 19th January. In the two exchanges so far, 7 Israeli hostages have been released in exchange for 290 Palestinians held by Israel.

Palestinians and Israelis alike have marked a pause to the long and brutal war with celebration, grief and apprehension – a war which has levelled Gaza, shaken the foundations of Israeli society, and changed the Middle Eastern political landscape dramatically.

The latest war in a decades-long conflict began when Hamas attacked Israel, killing 1,195 and kidnapping 251 hostages. What followed was an intense Israeli bombardment and invasion of Gaza – actions now subject to an ICJ genocide case, a UN genocide investigation, and ICC arrest warrants. The Hamas-run Gazan Health Ministry says 46,913 Palestinians have now been killed, with the Lancet medical journal estimating a death toll 40% higher, at 64,260.

The ceasefire deal, which is hoped to end the conflict, was negotiated over many months in Doha with Qatari, Egyptian, and US mediation. The deal uses terms set out originally by the Biden Administration in May 2024.

The Ceasefire Deal

The ceasefire deal is to include three phases, with phase one – to last six weeks – now in progress. Phases two and three are to be negotiated by Israel and Hamas during phase one, with provisions made to extend the six weeks of phase one should agreements for further phases not be made in time.

33 Israeli hostages will be released at regular intervals through the period, with those released to be women, children, or elderly. Israel will also release an undisclosed number of Palestinians held in prison. Those released are to be prisoners held for reasons unrelated to the 7th October attack.

Israeli forces will withdraw from densely populated regions of the Gaza Strip, to allow for Palestinians to return to their neighbourhoods. As displaced Palestinians are allowed to return home, a surge of aid into the Gaza Strip is being orchestrated, involving 600 trucks a day. Additionally the Rafah Crossing will open, allowing Palestinians to seek medical treatment in Egypt.

Negotiations for what will be involved in phase two are set to begin on day 16 of phase one, the 4th February. If agreed to by all parties, phase two will involve the release of all remaining living Israeli hostages, including male soldiers, in addition to the release of more Palestinian prisoners from Israeli prisons. Additionally, Israel would begin to remove all troops and military hardware from the Gaza Strip.

Phase three is likely to then involve the repatriation of the bodies of deceased Israeli hostages, and the initiation of a plan to reconstruct the Gaza Strip, with international support and supervision from regional powers and the US. It is unclear who would administer Gaza in this period. This remains subject of tension within the Israeli government – though the US has pushed for the Palestinian Authority to take this role.

A New Administration in the US

As news that a deal had been struck began to emerge, then-President Elect Donald Trump was quick to take credit for the deal, stating on his social media site Truth Social that such a deal would not have been reached if he had not won in November’s election. Whilst comments and questions from journalists over who was to be credited drew anger from then-President Joe Biden, few doubt that Mr Trump’s influence was instrumental.

It was President Biden and his team who worked to secure terms for ceasefire deals at numerous times during the final year of his Presidency. A deal was almost reached in early-May 2024, with Gazans beginning to celebrate on the streets, before Israel then invaded Rafah. Again, in late-May, a President Biden heralded Israel’s agreement to another “enduring ceasefire proposal,” which was also rejected. The Biden Administration, too, mediated the 27th November ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah, which though not fully adhered to has remained in place.

All hell will break out. If those hostages aren’t back, I don’t want to hurt your negotiation, if they’re not back by the time I get into office, all hell will break out in the Middle East.

US President Donald Trump

What appeared to shift the needle, however, was an off-hand comment made by Mr Trump about the release of hostages in January. “If they’re not back by the time I get into office, all hell will break out in the Middle East.” Discounted at the time as Trumpian bluster against Hamas, commentators and Israeli officials now argue that Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu is the one who took notice.

A fear of refusing current terms and being made to accept more undesirable terms under the incoming Trump Administration appears to have forced Mr Netanyahu’s hand, with the Israeli PM appearing to opt for stability for fear of Mr Trump’s wrath, in the view of former Israeli PM Ehud Olmert. Mr Netanyahu, like many world leaders, tech CEOs, and American officials, is also handling Trump 2.0 with an intense charm offensive. With the intention to push for tougher action on Iran and aims to thwart a two-state solution, Mr Netanyahu appears to understand he needs the new president firmly on his side. Intentionally reneging on ceasefire deals and outwardly violating the demands of sitting US presidents appears to have come to an end. Such actions were only in Mr Netanyahu’s playbook for as long as the Biden Administration remained in control, it would seem.

Barriers to Ending the War

A ceasefire deal is promising, and is right to be deemed cause for celebration, but experts and commentators alike are quick to point out the fragility of the agreement. For even the ceasefire to remain in place, both Israel and Hamas must adhere to all conditions. For the deal to progress into a wider peace agreement, concerted and deliberate effort and compromise is required from both sides. 

The day the ceasefire came into force, there was a three-hour delay in its implementation, as Israel refused to enter a ceasefire if Hamas did not release a list of the hostages it would be releasing that day. In the 3-hour delay, the Hamas-run Gaza Civil Defence Agency said 10 Palestinians had been killed by airstrikes. Such tense moments are likely to happen again and again, with both sides needing to restrain themselves carefully from violence, miscommunication, and disagreement. In previous ceasefires between Israel and Hamas, minor incidents have spiralled into crises which have ended ceasefires early.

Following the initial phase of the ceasefire, there is also no guarantee that negotiations be taken further, with Mr Netanyahu saying Israel retains the right to continue fighting should negotiations collapse. The Israeli PM also faces intense internal pressure from factions of his coalition – with Itamar Ben-Gvir withdrawing his Otzma Yehudit party from the ruling coalition and resigning his role as Minster of National Security in Israel’s cabinet. Mr Ben-Gvir had previously called the ceasefire a “complete victory for terrorism.”

Israel has also endangered the fragile peace by undertaking military operations in the occupied West Bank. Though not explicitly in contravention of the ceasefire agreement, any action at such a tense time is risky.

We reserve the right to resume the war if necessary, with American support

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyau

The role of President Trump in future negotiation, too, is also an added complication. Whilst the current ceasefire deal is credited at least partly to him, little has been announced by the incoming administration in the way of concrete policy. Whilst Mr Trump seems willing to push ceasefire negotiations the full way to a peace deal, Mr Netanyahu has thanked the incoming administration for lifting restrictions on providing weapons and munition to Israel – something less than consistent with peace.

As hopes run high on both sides that 15 months of violent conflict are drawing to an end, and the hostages still alive are to be reunited with their loved ones, there are further hopes that the momentous ceasefire will stay in force, see phases two and three negotiated, and eventually a full peace deal will be signed.

Image Credit: Emad El Byed via Unsplash