No easy options: why there is no easy fix for UK water companies
By Hugh Halsey
For years, we have been bombarded with stories denoting the horrifying state of our waters. Sewage runs freely into rivers and oceans, destroying ecosystems while making the public pay more for the privilege of using it. Rightly, public outcry has been colossal and in the summer of last year, the government announced a holistic response to a national enquiry conducted by Sir Jon Cunliffe.
That response has now been released in a new statement laying out the plans for major reform to the regulation of the UK water companies. Described as “a new once-in-a-generation plan”, this white paper lays out plans for a new chief engineer, smart metering for appliances and cracking down on sewer misuse. The Environment Secretary Emma Reynolds said the water companies will “have nowhere to hide”.
The proposal will also aim to improve stability in the water industry to increase investment and maximise the security of UK water. However, it has been commented by many that the statements are vague and lack detail, which may be rectified in the upcoming ‘Transition Plan’ that promises to present a clearer plan of how the goals set out are intended to be achieved.
Whilst these changes are generally welcomed by investors, many are less convinced by the proposed changes. Surfers Against Sewage, a charity aimed at ending sewage pollution in UK waters, explained their concern that until water companies no longer prioritise profit, the problems will remain.
How can water quality improve when the fundamental problem hasn’t been addressed?
This is the crux of the issue. Whilst the document lays out the clear and public problems with poor water quality in the UK, it fails to address one of the biggest calls that people are making. How can water quality improve when the fundamental problem hasn’t been addressed? The water companies are driven by profit. Costs to the public and environmental protection will remain secondary concerns when the company is faced with the fact that, unless they turn a profit, they no longer exist.
The recent report tells a very different story. No party is blamed for the failure in the water industry, but rather a more overall failure in industry regulation that lost its way. Whilst there may be truth to this factually, with the regulators having the water companies “marking their own homework”, surely the solution is to remove the risk altogether by bringing the water companies in-house? That way, we won’t need to balance the interests of profit with regulation, but can have a service with pricing and environmental protection at its centre.
The situation that the industry currently faces was certainly not intended or envisaged, so we cannot be sure that the regulators won’t find themselves in a similar situation again. How can the regulators confidently say that they are bringing about reforms when it can be argued that they are the biggest perpetrators in this scandal?
However, the lack of conversation about nationalisation may be revealing in and of itself. The government may not feel able to take on the responsibility. Sir Dieter Helm, a professor of economic policy at the University of Oxford, gave his views to BBC News: “I think there’s a very sensible view around government that the government probably isn’t competent and capable to run these businesses”. Nationalisation may not bring the promised benefits that campaigners would claim.
But you could take a more cynical view that the government doesn’t want the responsibility simply because they can currently blame faults on someone else, or in this case, no one at all. But regardless of your view on nationalisation and regulators, if there is going to be change, more focus needs to be put on implementation rather than diagnosis and grand plans.
One of the key takeaways from this is that real reform takes far longer than people want, and the dramatic changes that people may romanticise about are unlikely. If change is to be seen in water quality and affordability, then it will take at least a few years.
Image: Ben Wicks via Unsplash

