Digital ID cards: zombie policy or important modernisation?
By Hugh Halsey
Tony Blair and William Hague on BBC Radio 4 discussed their new push to introduce ID cards. For some, this may give a sense of Déjà vu after the former prime minister’s failed attempt to introduce them at the end of his tenure in 2006. However, have times changed? Today, the aim is to digitise these cards and bring them to smart phones. With lots of resistance and concerns expressed by the British public, has opinion changed at all since Blair’s last attempt?
The former political rivals made big claims on the Today programme that the country would fall behind other large powers without the introduction of these marvellous cards. Although I’m not sure I would go that far, there is an important point being made. Technology has progressed at an extraordinary rate over the last 20 years and with the rise of AI systems such as ChatGPT, it shows no sign of slowing down.
We now use our phones for everything. Banking, texting, emailing, socialising, and travel. You notice it when you don’t have it and it was probably some time ago that you went without yours. My point is that we are no stranger to trusting technology with bank cards, tickets, and other sensitive information. One extra identity card is not a huge leap of faith.
Is the technology currently available sufficient to protect this vast quantity of sensitive data?
However, is the technology currently available sufficient to protect this vast quantity of sensitive data? Members of the public have expressed their concern over the security of government-held data. Any database containing that much personal data would certainly attract constant cyber-attacks and the idea of criminals getting their hands on that data doesn’t bare thinking about.
But it’s not like databases like these don’t already exist. Facebook and Instagram have built up vast quantities of data on your movements, activities, and interests. So many times I go onto YouTube or Facebook and the recommendations feel like my mind is being read.
Back in 2020 in an interview, Blair commented on the data required for his scheme saying, “people probably will give more information to their supermarket than to the government”. So perhaps the security threat is not as severe as some would make it out to be.
But what good is any of this if the public do not support it? There is a long history of tried and failed attempts to introduce an ID card system. During the first world war a mandatory identification card was introduced to wild unpopularity. Although it was accepted due to unique times, it was scrapped soon after the end of the first world war.
Public opinion has never been sympathetic with the government having information about us
However, the government didn’t give up and in 1939 reintroduced the system in light of the second world war. This was more successful than the first. However, public opinion was never fully convinced by the scheme and after rationing finished, it wasn’t long after that the identification cards were once again scrapped. Public opinion has never been sympathetic with the government having information about us even if we are willing to trust Facebook with it.
Regardless of the benefits provided by the scheme, if public opinion is against the proposal, we are unlikely to see it happen. Data collection has occurred in other ways over the years as seen with Facebook and Instagram. But they haven’t exactly filled the public with confidence with regular scandals resulting in a great public desire to restrict these vast businesses. That is why I believe we are unlikely to ever see this system on our phones.
Public opinion is not showing any sign of swaying in favour, with increasing security concerns with technology and greater desire for data protection from companies such as Facebook. I actually think this scheme would be valuable for society. It would make identification much simpler and not to mention stop you losing your student ID card at the college bars. But until the public are persuaded that ID cards are safe and would be an asset to this country, they will never be any more a part of our lives than a discussion on the Today programme.

