Are scientific breakthroughs all they’re cracked up to be?

By Hugh Halsey

With the constant onslaught of hard hitting headlines, from global politics to scandal, it can be hard to appreciate the many wonderful things happening in society. So when an article describes a new scientific discovery that might make a small part of life a bit better, it’s really exciting. It brings a glimmer of hope amongst a collection of grim articles, boosting engagement from the public and driving support for more funding towards future scientific innovations.

One recent discovery is that a single nasal spray vaccine could protect against all colds, flus and coughs. This would be an extraordinary breakthrough for science and something that could prove revolutionary for modern medicine. Also, I would imagine, particularly popular for freshers week! The spray moves away from the basic principles of traditional vaccines, which train the immune system to defend against one specific disease such as small pox, measles, or the flu. Viruses causing the flu are able to mutate and reduce the effectiveness of a specific vaccine meaning every year a new vaccine is created to protect the most vulnerable in society.

If publications are too keen to release new discoveries before research has been complete, the public may take these things as fact and end up disappointed

Instead the spray initiates an immune response in white blood cells so they are on alert for when a disease is encountered. This increases the speed of the immune response and the patient does not experience the symptoms of the cold, cough, or flu. This is early days for the research and has been described as ‘exciting’ by Johnathan Ball, professor of molecular virology at Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine. However, it is also pointed out that there may be considerable drawbacks and side effects from having a constantly elevated immune response, including the immune system targeting the body itself.

There are many hurdles to overcome before a product can hit the shelves or be prescribed, which raises the question of whether revealing these big breakthroughs is really such a great idea. It can bring a little bit of good news to otherwise quite depressing news cycles, but if the discoveries being announced might not work at all it has the potential to create distrust in science. The public could lose interest in something that is definitely worth funding. A previous public announcement of a science discovery was the plastic eating bacteria. By adding bacterial spores to plastic, when the plastic encounters the nutrients of compost the bacteria will begin digesting the plastic in the compost heap. A discovery that promised a revolutionary change to plastic consumption that might alter the direction of plastic waste. That was headline news in 2024 and very little has been reported on it since then. 

I think the fundamental problem is that the way journalism operates is so different to that of scientific research. Journalism is looking for the next story that will capture people’s attention and when the reporters are not experts in the area of research, they will be tempted to make the headlines bolder and punchier than scientists would like.In the case of the nasal spray, the results have been promising, but have only come from tests in mice. It has been estimated that if the spray enters clinical trials it will be at least another 5 to 7 years before it can be implemented on a broader scale.

Whilst these early releases might be good for scientific public engagement and boosting funding for exciting projects, if publications are too keen to release new discoveries before research has been complete, the public may take these things as fact and end up disappointed. 

Image: Nuimageclub via Wikimedia Commons