Jimmy Lai sentenced to 20 years in prison
By Avesta Afshari-Mehr
Lai ‘Jimmy’ Chee-ying (黎智英), the Hong Kong media entrepreneur and founder of the now-defunct newspaper Apple Daily, has been sentenced to 20 years in prison under Hong Kong’s national security framework. Lai’s case has drawn international attention and renewed debate about governance, media practice and the boundaries of political expression in the city.
Mr Lai, 78, was convicted on charges including conspiring to collude with foreign forces and conspiring to publish seditious material. People’s Republic of China’s prosecutors have made the case that his activities, which were conducted through his media organisation and public advocacy, crossed legal red lines relating to national security. The defence maintained that Lai’s actions fell within the scope of journalistic work and political commentary.
The trial, which took place under the 2020 Hong Kong National Security Law, which was introduced following the large-scale protests of 2019. The law criminalises any kind of secession, subversion, terrorism and collusion with foreign forces.
Mr Lai, 78, was convicted on charges including conspiring to collude with foreign forces and conspiring to publish seditious material
Supporters of the verdict argue that national security legislation is a standard feature of sovereign states and that Hong Kong, as a Special Administrative Region of China, is constitutionally required to safeguard national security. They contend that the case demonstrates the authorities’ commitment to enforcing the law where they believe boundaries have been exceeded.
However, those who criticise the verdict, such as that of the United States as well as several states in Europe, have insisted that Lai is a pro-democracy campaigner, and have contended that the proceedings reflect internationally recognised standards of press freedom.
Now, the American government have called for Lai’s release on humanitarian grounds, namely citing his age and health. During the previous US administration under Donald Trump, officials publicly urged authorities to grant him humanitarian parole. More recently, members of Congress from both major parties have reiterated calls for clemency and have raised the case in diplomatic exchanges. However, there is no indication from either Beijing or Hong Kong as to whether this would be granted.
So why have Chinese authorities characterised Lai as a dissident figure? From Beijing’s perspective, the primary concern has been national sovereignty and political stability. Officials have repeatedly stated that activities perceived as inviting foreign political intervention, advocating sanctions, or challenging the constitutional order fall outside acceptable limits. In this framing, Lai’s meetings with overseas politicians and his media platform’s editorial stance were interpreted not simply as dissent, but as actions with potential national security implications.
Lai’s meetings with overseas politicians and his media platform’s editorial stance were interpreted not simply as dissent, but as actions with potential national security implications
This case is an excellent representation of the differing conceptions of journalism and governance. In liberal democratic systems, adversarial media and open advocacy for systemic political change are generally protected within broad free speech norms. China’s political system, by contrast, the role of media and political participation operates within a different constitutional and ideological framework. One that places a premium on social stability, unity and Party leadership.
The impact of the case on pro-democracy movements within Hong Kong and mainland China is undoubtedly complex and nuanced. Since the implementation of the national security law, public protests in Hong Kong have significantly declined: with several activist groups have disbanded, and prominent figures either prosecuted, exiled from the SAR, or withdrawn from public life. For the general population, it appears that residents prioritise economic stability and a return to normalcy after years of disruption and the COVID-19 pandemic.
Within mainland China, public discourse regarding the case has been notably restrained, with state media primarily presenting the proceedings as a lawful response to significant offences. Comparable organised pro-democracy movements, such as those observed in Hong Kong in 2019, have not emerged in other major Chinese cities; this remains unlikely due to the presence of the Great Firewall and a predominantly homogenous society.
Image: Studio Incendo via Wikimedia Commons

