Law students outraged at summative question change

Law_cut

By Justin Villamil

Following the early circulation of an outline answer for a summative question, Durham Law School students have reacted with outrage against a decision to add a new summative question.

The error, which preceded the absence of Criminal Law professor Johnny Doak, was made after many students had already completed the question.

According to sources who spoke to Palatinate after the announcement, many students stormed out of the lecture halfway through. Some students left in tears.

All of Professor Doak’s lectures, tutorials, and dissertation students have been given to other instructors.

Professor Roger Masterman, Head of Durham Law School told Palatinate:

“This decision was made because the inadvertent circulation of guidance took place ahead of the assignment deadline and therefore compromised the integrity of the process.

“Fairness in the assessment process was our guiding objective. The replacement question ensures that the independent work of all students can be assessed on the basis of the same question.

“The Law School has apologised to the affected students, and has put in place measures to ensure that all students receive the support they need in the lead up to the examinations process.”

The answer outline was reportedly uploaded to DUO because it had a similar name to a revised version of the original question.

Though Doak initially allowed students to submit completed essays after upload if put in immediately, this decision was then reversed.

Professor Doak initially told students:

“Even though it is likely that only a small number of students viewed the document, our only option in these circumstances is to set a new question.”

Palatinate obtained a detailed copy of the answers from disgruntled students almost immediately.

However, the initial willingness of Professor Doak to look at answers submitted on the Friday proved problematic.

An email sent out on Tuesday 25th February indicated that essays would be accepted if put in before the following Friday, giving students with an outline three days to complete the assignment.

Many students rushed through the reading, skipping lectures and tutorials in order to complete the summative, according to sources who spoke with Palatinate.

Then, when the announcement came that essays would not be accepted after all, there was an outcry.

According to students taking the Evidence and Criminal Process module in the Law department, this is not the first time Professor Doak has made an early upload error, but sources claim that it is by far the most egregious.

Photograph courtesy of Durham University.