Durham academic holds launch for groundbreaking book on dyslexia
By Justin Villamil
Professor Joe Elliott, principal of Collingwood College, has recently made waves in the academic, professional, student and lay community for calling the dyslexia diagnosis “unscientific and lacking in rigor”.
Elliott, whose new book The Dyslexia Debate is co-authored with Yale University Professor Elena Grigorenko, will be holding a book launch on Tuesday the 11th this week.
Palatinate recently had the opportunity to sit down with Professor Elliott to discuss the implications of his new work.
Elliott has recently been in the media spotlight with appearances in the national media and, more recently, publication of an op-ed piece for the Times Higher Education.
Professor Elliott told Palatinate that he had originally begun to question the efficacy of the dyslexia diagnosis during his early work in the 1970s as a teacher of children with special educational needs and then subsequently during a five-year stint as an educational psychologist.
“People would always ask me about this term ‘dyslexia’,” Elliott told Palatinate.
“It just seemed to me to be this totally amorphous term, and there are so many different ways you can approach it.
“Based on this experience, I later produced a book called Children in Difficulty back in 1998 in which I wrote a chapter on dyslexia, partly to help me to come to grips with the construct. But I never really managed to discover what this term might mean or how it helped our understanding of how to help those with problems.”
Elliott said that he later was approached by a TV producer to make a documentary for Channel 4 called The Dyslexia Myth, which kicked off a media storm. He was subsequent asked to give evidence to the House of Commons Science and Technology Select Committee, which subsequently endorsed his views.
Elliott told Palatinate that a major problem with reactions to his research is that it is often misinterpreted.
“One of the problems is that some people say many daft things about dyslexia (that it is a middle class excuse to excuse laziness or stupidity), and people assume that because I’m challenging the dyslexia construct I’m saying such things also.
“The anger and outrage are understandable although these emotions are often based upon misunderstandings of the issues. Many find the term personally meaningful so resent suggestions that its scientific basis is flawed.
“Clearly, there’s also a significant element of projection operating where people’s prior experiences of hurt and humiliation influence the messages that are perceived,” he told Palatinate.
“Although I’m arguing against the continued use of the term ‘dyslexia’, I try to address the difficulties caused by a complex reading disorder with a biological basis, that can really make people’s lives a misery.
“But people think that because I’m challenging dyslexia I’m discounting this sometimes incapacitating difficulty at the same time.”
In 2009, Professor Elliott signed a book contract with Cambridge University Press. The book, to be released on Tuesday the 11th, is co-authored by Elena Grigorenko.
Elliott told Palatinate that Professor Grigorenko is “one of the world’s leading geneticists in learning and reading disabilities”.
In terms of the research for the book, he told Palatinate:
“Between the two of us we cover all the key disciplines: genetics, neuroscience, cognitive science, education and social policy. So what the book tries to do is analyse through all of these different disciplines the work that’s been done and arrive at some kind of synthesis.”
Professor Elliott identified three major problems with the current dyslexia debate, first that the term itself is unscientific, second that it doesn’t offer any useful information for guiding intervention and third is that it sustains a situation where only some who struggle with reading receive appropriate help and understanding.
“The term itself is not rigorous or scientific – it means all things for all people. For dyslexia, a diagnosis tells you absolutely nothing.”
Professor Elliott’s book advocates an increasingly popular approach to teaching students that he calls ‘response to intervention’, the idea that intervention should take place immediately after a child begins to struggle, rather than waiting for the child to fail and seeking a dyslexia diagnosis.
Professor Elliott’s new book is written for a scholarly audience and explores the debate in significant depth. He observes that media reports have resulted in many messages – some of praise and others of condemnation.
He hopes that the launch of the book will permit examination of the key issues rather than outraged reactions based upon newspaper headlines.
He will be joined by Professor Grigorenko and specialists at Collingwood on April 22nd for a full day’s Book Launch conference.
Photograph Courtesy of Venus Loi

