Snowed Under: The Durham Difference

By Stuart Flegg

Durham_Cathedral_2011

“The dentist didn’t like Durham.” Another one of my mother’s strange conversations. I sit and listen. We don’t really have much else to talk about given that neither of us find “that ANOVA I ran one time” especially interesting.

I should explain; the dentist’s daughter is in my brother’s class. They are both at that age where the ‘national university tour’ is mandatory.

“He thought it was too small.” This is paraphrased (I’m not in the habit of transcribing phone conversations to my mother). “He said he wanted to see Stockton, people kept saying good things about it.”

Firstly, the student campus in Stockton is tiny by comparison. I didn’t really understand the dentist’s point of view here. However he had picked up on a great point. People are always going on about how great it is ‘down at Queen’s’. There was an article only last week about respecting the Queen’s sports teams. “Stockton is not Beruit” – that would be my favourite reply.

My editor asked me to weigh in on this too (that’s right-this one’s a commission) but part of me feels that the conversation is getting a little bit old. I am part of Durham University, it says Durham University on my CV and nobody is going to tell me otherwise. It’s more subtle than that, the divide only exists from inside the bubble. Clearly there is a difference; it’s not something big, not the value of my degree (sorry if you thought otherwise as a way of justifying those sleepless nights revising for A level). So what is the difference? What is different about being in Durham?

The setting is very pretty. I’m currently in the Cathedral library having been at a meeting in the Pemberton Rooms. Out the window to my right is the steep bank of the river and to my left is a collection of medieval stonemasonry punctuating the rows of leather bound books. These in themselves are organised using roman numerals and section XXII is titled ‘Diocesan Clergy’. I can confirm that the library at QC does not have such a section but on the other hand, I’m not really interested in that. I’d rather read ‘Discovering Statistics Using SPSS’ and yes, they do have copies of that. Even though it’s nice here, I think I’ll have to leave soon. There’s a draught and no Wi-Fi, so I can’t look up what ‘Diocesan’ means (I’m not so curious as to walk across the room).

I think I might go over to Bill Bryson, I will be more comfortable there, even if the aesthetics displease me. There will be modern things; it won’t look nice but I will be able to feel my fingertips again (typing this right now is unbelievably hard). Essentially, it will be more like Stockton.

Sometimes I am impressed by the atmosphere on the Bailey. By Hatfield chapel and by Castle bar. We don’t have anything like that, apart from the ruined Abbey at the end of Yarm Lane. But then again, neither do Butler, Trevs or Collingwood.

The truth is that I don’t know. We are all complex people, we want to live in a castle with sandstone walls yet somehow we want those walls to let through the Wi-Fi. We want to explore the cobbled streets but we want them to be wheelchair accessible.

I think we try to pin it down to something tangible in the end, for the sake of a debate or a witty opinion piece but that is really not the right thing to do. People will flip – flop there preference for pretty or practical, big scale or small based on which side of the argument they want to take.

If you boil the tangible things down, you miss the point. Of course you can do music, drama or sport at Queen’s, there’s a river, a sports hall and a gym; a theatre, studio and canteen. We all have DUO and the same library catalogue. Both sites even share staff members but that doesn’t mean there is no difference. I can’t help but suspect that everyone earwigging my dentist feels somehow that it’s an inferior product. It’s not, and you can never prove that it is but to deny differences is equally ridiculous. It’s like an intercollegiate rivalry; college facilities may be the same but the feel and culture is different. And as with colleges, you can either love it or hate it. Either you enjoy being in Aiden’s or sit reeling about not getting into Chad’s.

Yes, QC is not in Durham. Rocks are hard. Water is wet. Fire is hot. You’re stating the obvious, what do you want? A Blue Peter badge?

Photograph: commons.wikimedia.org