It takes two to tango

By Adam Leese

Mohammad Shtayyeh, the Prime Minister of Palestine, has denounced Benjamin Netanyahu, the long-time Israeli Prime Minister, and his announcement that plans to annex occupied Palestinian territories in the West Bank, including the entirety of the Jordan Valley, will commence on July 1st.

Netanyahu’s announcement makes good on his promise made during the first of the three elections contested in 2019 to annex territories in the West Bank, an electoral carrot dangled to shore up right-wing support against Benny Gantz, a former army chief, who opposed unilateral action.

Under Israeli military occupation since the 1967 Arab-Israeli War, Palestinian territory in the West Bank has been further encroached upon by the construction of military outposts and Jewish settlements in the region, home to some 500,000 Israelis. As such, the 2.5 million Palestinians living in the West Bank have been squeezed into a series of enclaves. 

Annexation would likely represent the final blow to a two-state solution

Netanyahu’s desire to “apply sovereignty” to Palestinian territory would push these Palestinians into an increasingly precarious position; the military occupation of the West Bank has enabled Israel to escape challenges over the status of the Palestinians, their citizenship, and their equality before the law. However, annexation, an official legal declaration that the West Bank belongs to the Israeli state, would raise serious concerns over the rights and living conditions of the Palestinians who, under the 2018 Israeli “nation-state” law, are considered second-class citizens.

At a press conference on June 9th, Shtayyeh said that Palestine will have no choice but to declare statehood if Israel proceeds with annexation. 

Fearful over the “existential threat” annexation presents to a peace deal based on the two-state solution, Shtayyeh said that “it takes two to tango”, indicating his belief that the move would betray mutual efforts to resolve the enduring conflict. Annexation would likely represent the final blow to a two-state solution; the Palestinians have counted upon the territories under consideration forming part of their future state, so a formal Israeli absorption of the West Bank would make the land hard to relinquish in any future agreement.

The Palestinian PM promised that a declaration of Palestinian statehood would involve the “manifestation of a state on the ground” based on the borders prior to the 1967 War, sovereignty over the West Bank and Gaza, and claiming Jerusalem as the Palestinian capital. Moreover, such a declaration would involve a “call on the international community to recognise this land” to ensure that “Israel does not get away with murder”.

Shtayyeh’s comments follow a decision taken in May by Mahmoud Abbas, the President of Palestine, to end Palestinian security cooperation with Israel and the US, naming the threat of Israeli annexation as motivation to do so.

Shtayyeh said that Palestine will have no choice but to declare statehood if Israel proceeds with annexation 

Whilst it is unclear how the international community would respond to a Palestinian declaration of statehood, the United Nations and major nation states have signalled their intent to criticise Israeli annexation as such acts are “firmly illegal” under international law. Likewise, the Jewish settlements in the West Bank are illegal under the Geneva Convention. 

Moreover, Netenyahu faces domestic pressure against the annexation; on June 9th, the Israeli Supreme Court rejected calls to legalise the Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank, meaning that Palestinian landowners are now able to legally reclaim their privately-owned property.

Crucially, however, Netenyahu retains the support of President Donald Trump, who he has described as the “greatest friend Israel has ever had in the White House”. Having already overturned US foreign policy by recognising Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, acceding Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights, and unilaterally declaring that Jewish settlements are not “inconsistent with international law”, Trump is expected to support the annexation. 

Image: Michael-Ann Cerniglia via Flickr