To defer or not to defer? That is the question

By Sophie Garnett

Inevitably, incoming freshers have concerns about the university experience awaiting them this Autumn, with a survey finding that almost one in four of 2020 freshers have seriously considered deferring. This is understandable given uncertainty surrounding teaching methods and social life, with many believing they will not have the university experience they signed up for when they applied. To understand the conflict many are currently facing, I spoke to some incoming Durham freshers about deferring.

Missing out on the social side of university is certainly a concern for many incoming students, with research showing this may be reason enough for them to defer. Rachel, who is due to start at South College, said that “it seems initially you make friends through activities and going out in freshers week, [but social distancing will limit] the opportunity to make friends in the first couple of weeks”. However, others felt that this is not a sufficient reason to defer. An incoming Trevelyan College student commented that he set up a college group chat which has put many at ease – they’ve organised “drinking Zoom calls on a Tuesday and a college quiz on a Thursday”. Perhaps friendship groups could form easier due to fears of missing out on making friends? Societies will be utilised to the fullest extent to meet people in combination with online interactions inevitably occurring.

Many are hesitant about the impact of the online learning likely in October

Online learning is an adjustment for all students, and this is no less the case for current year 13s. Many are hesitant about the impact of the online learning likely in October. Nicole, who is preparing to study Sociology commented, “I feel like with lectures being online I do think it’s not value for money or what I signed up for”, while Joe believes online lectures will make him “feel like we are paying for information we can already find online and we won’t have the help of a professor”. However, despite these concerns, raw deferral figures are not as high as expected – at the beginning of June, only 31,380 applicants had at least one deferred choice, compared to 30,760 at the same point last year. Perhaps concerns are not translating to actions, with incoming freshers instead waiting until they can gain a clearer view of the situation. 

However, there could be benefits of deferring aside from simply ensuring a more normal university experience. Students who take a gap year are said to perform better throughout their degree, a higher proportion gaining a first. Though I did not take a gap year I believe I would have been more motivated in first year having had a break from education. Were I in the position of current year 13s, I would seriously consider taking a year out as long as I could simply defer my place. James, starting at Grey in September, took a gap year and thinks in a similar way; “I do feel I’ll be more motivated when I start than I would’ve been without a break”. 

Unfortunately, gap years are not possible for many students who, amidst the current tough job market, may have lost their jobs and be unable to support themselves. Gap years are also looking undesirable without travel prospects. Nicole takes this view: “after all this time off I couldn’t think of anything worse than being off for another year – I think it would completely demotivate me to go back to uni”. This trend of thinking is clear, seen in the 19% decrease in ‘un-deferrers’ from last year’s numbers, the trend of traditional gap years falling by the wayside.

Alongside unfavourable gap years, there are plenty of other reasons freshers have decided to embrace the new normal. Paul, due to start at St John’s, took a gap year and comments that, “one year out has been more than enough. At this point I want a degree, anything to get my life moving forward again.” No doubt, it will also be more difficult to re-apply to university in 2020 for 2021 entry due to applicants being put off by Covid-19, which will create a larger applicant pool. Honor, set to study law, comments she “would be worried about being offered a place at Durham [for a second time] as I feel it is difficult to get a place”. 

Overall, 2020 freshers are looking on the bright side of what is no doubt a difficult situation. Many agree that they will have to find new ways to socialise but that this will not detract from the experience, instead giving them unique stories and encouraging them to get more involved in sports and societies. Deferrals are looking unlikely anyway, several universities blocking year 13 attempts to defer aside from in cases of ‘serious medical conditions’. In all likelihood, the 2020 freshers cohort will be arriving at universities across the country eager to start university life despite facing some challenges. 

Image: Grace Shih-Chia Tseng via Flickr