Monsoon reveals fractures in Karachi’s infrastructure and politics

By Adam Leese

Heavy rains have wreaked havoc in the Pakistani city of Karachi, leaving numerous neighbourhoods and streets underwater whilst also killing at least 90 people. Hundreds of thousands of people living in the city’s low-lying informal settlements have been trapped by extreme waterlogging and the city’s 22 million residents have been left without power for days on end.

Rainfall in August has shattered records that date back to 1931. The 484mm that fell in Karachi throughout August is also more than 10 times the monthly average, with 223mm falling on Thursday the 27th alone.

These figures follow record levels of monsoon rains across South Asia, with Bangladesh and India also suffering from severe flooding. Between 2014 to 2019, Pakistan saw 70 rain-related deaths, however at least 106 people over and above the death toll in Karachi have been killed since June due to the pronounced levels of monsoon rainfall.

Despite its status as Pakistan’s financial hub, Karachi has suffered disproportionately due to a serious deficit in the basic infrastructure facilities needed to withstand such a deluge, despite the regular annual monsoon rains.

The rapid and uncontrolled expansion of residences and commercial sites across the city has played an outsized role in the predicament; there is a lack of roadside drainage channels, whilst existing drains have not been adjusted to cope with the greater size of the city nor the greater levels of rainfall. Additionally, the informal settlements across the city have obstructed the flow of water.

These issues are exacerbated by the poorly managed waste disposal system in a city that generates an estimated 13,000 tonnes of waste daily

These issues are exacerbated by the poorly managed waste disposal system in a city that generates an estimated 13,000 tonnes of waste daily; waste is frequently dumped on the sides of the street and swept into the drains, causing blockages that mean that only a relatively small amount of rain can cause flooding and difficulties for residents.

All of this culminated in Karachi being added to the Economist Intelligence Unit’s list of the 10 least livable cities in its Global Livability Index 2019.

On Friday 18th August, all government and private institutions were closed to ensure public safety and people have been urged to stay at home, whilst schools have been vacated and requisitioned to house stranded residents.

Pakistani military forces have been instructed to deploy emergency response teams to aid the struggling civil administration, with the navy commencing rescue operations and the army establishing a Flood Emergency Control Centre to provide medical assistance and food, water, and other essential items. The army has also been instructed to assist in pumping rainwater out of inundated areas.

This crisis has exacerbated political tensions between the city, the provincial, and the federal governments. Karachi is governed by the Muttahida Quami Movement (MQM), however the Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) calls the shots provincially.

Their fractious relationship has seen both parties blaming the other for the position in which Karachi finds itself

Their fractious relationship has seen both parties blaming the other for the position in which Karachi finds itself; the MQM asserts that they are unable to provide relief because the necessary powers have not been decentralized, whilst also accusing the PPP of neglecting Karachi. 

Raza Haroon, the Secretary-General of the Pak Sarzameen Party, a splinter group and affiliate of the MQM has stated that “the PPP doesn’t feel obliged to serve the city as it doesn’t have much electoral representation.”

In recent days, citizens of Karachi have focused their anger on the city government, who, they argue, have demonstrated their gross incompetence in failing to prepare the city for what the Pakistani Met Office have long been forecasting.

Prime Minister Imran Khan appears to be looking to use this crisis to recentralize power in Islamabad, seeing it as an opportunity to roll back the 18th Constitutional Amendment which devolved powers, including financial responsibilities, to the provinces.

In this vein, the ruling party, Pakistan Tehree-e-Insaf, has launched a social media campaign to undermine the provincial government. Additionally, Khan and the federal government have started to play a more active role in the recovery of the city, promising a “Karachi Transformation Plan” to remedy the inadequacies in the city’s infrastructure.

Islamabad has previously had control over Karachi, however the many issues faced by the city’s residents went unsolved.

With further rain predicted for September and a recent small uptick in Covid-19 cases, it is imperative that Karachi’s infrastructure rapidly receives the necessary repairs and protections needed to ensure its citizens safety.

Image: All Terrain Civic via Creative Commons