Insolvent institutions?

By Ben Pawlowski

A new academic year is underway, heralding the return of the familiar sights and sounds that typify Durham life. The Billy B is teeming with finalists, the Jimmy’s dancefloor is packed with freshers, and long, snaking queues have returned to Durham’s brunch spots. All appears well – but underneath the surface, at universities up and down the country, a crisis is slowly bubbling away.

Simply put, the United Kingdom’s higher education institutions are tiptoeing towards financial oblivion. Set against a backdrop of rampant inflation, operating costs have surged, whilst tuition fees, which provide over half of universities’ revenue, have remained frozen at an annual rate of £9,250 since 2017.

So far, 70 universities have announced redundancy and restructuring initiatives in an attempt to cut spending, with almost half of university chancellors expecting that their institutions will run deficits this year. There may well be worse to come, not least given that applications from international students, who pay a higher rate to attend university in the UK than their domestic peers, have fallen in the wake of a cynical attempt from the previous Conservative government to drive down migration figures by targeting the dependants of foreign postgraduate students.

The situation is perilous. Many within the sector, including union leaders, academics and executives, are warning of the very real prospect of bankruptcy and insolvency, potentially derailing the education of thousands of young people across the country. That is an outcome that must be avoided – but how?

Professor Shitij Kapur, vice chancellor and president of King’s College London, has suggested that tuition fees should rise to £12,500 per year to help universities break even. However, the new Labour government, which until under a year ago had campaigned to abolish tuition fees altogether, has ruled out any hike in costs for students.

Tuition fees should rise to £12,500 per year to help universities break even

Professor Shitij Kapur, King’s College London

This is the right move. Under no circumstance should the toll of financial mismanagement be passed onto students who, on average, are already straddled with over £40,000 in debts upon graduation. To do so would be an outrageous insult to a cohort who have already had their educational experience indeterminably damaged by Covid-19, mass industrial action and the cost-of-living crisis.

Rather, the resolution lies in radical root-and-branch reform of an antiquated funding model riddled with fundamental flaws. Firstly, an end to the processes of commodification and monetisation which have prioritised profit over the needs and wants of students and academic staff. In Durham this is highlighted by the volatility of the housing market, symbolised with the annual tradition of students camping outside the offices of estate agents in a desperate bid to source accommodation, then juxtaposed by administrative ambitions to expand the number of colleges and boost student intake.

Secondly, an end to the disparaging political discourse which has demonised universities, for example through the pathetic rhetoric surrounding so-called ‘Mickey Mouse’ degrees. We ought to be proud that this island of ours is home to several of the world’s very best universities and diverse courses, breeding grounds for innovation and an immense source of soft power and international prestige. They are some of our last great institutions and do not deserve to be belittled by the powers that be.

Thirdly, we need to adopt a funding model which appreciates that universities are vehicles for remarkable economic growth. Sir Keir Starmer entered 10 Downing Street on the back of a manifesto wedded to the idea of growth and wealth creation as the fundamental lever for societal improvement. If he wants somewhere to invest, I would suggest universities which, according to Universities UK, produce £14 of economic impact for every £1 received in government funding.

This principle should guide how higher education is funded. The tuition fee system should firstly be overhauled. Instead of students paying via a government loan, the government itself should pay a sum amount to universities to provide the funding they need, perhaps increasing the level of investment depending on factors including research quality and student satisfaction. Maintenance grants would need to be reintroduced to help students cover day-to-day costs and increase the accessibility of courses.

How to fund all this? Firstly, acknowledge universities as an investment vehicle which produces growth everywhere. Then, instead of a loan repayment system, introduce a small tax on all graduates once they enter the world of work. Those who earn the most, contribute the most. This would ensure that students no longer have to worry about mounting debt repayments, and would ensure our prestigious universities are not teetering on the verge of insolvency.

Photography by Seana Barrett