A game of two halves: does English football need an independent regulator?
By Waseem Mohamed and Ben Pawlowski
In a feature included in every print edition, two writers take part in a head-to-head debate surrounding a key issue in the world of sport. This week, we asked Sport Contributor Waseem Mohamed and Sport Editor Ben Pawlowski whether they agreed or disagreed with the statement: English football needs an independent regulator.
Yes: Waseem Mohamed (Sport Contributor)
In a comeback even more surprising than Nottingham Forest’s return to the top-four, plans for an Independent Football Regulator have once again resurfaced. After previous plans by the former Conservative government were halted by the general election, Labour have kicked-off proceedings for the Football Governance Bill to finally become law.
At its core, the Independent Football Regulator has three objectives – ensure financial soundness of football clubs, encourage systemic financial resilience, and safeguard football heritage. The regulator would cover all men’s clubs in the top five divisions of the English football pyramid and aims to (among other things) introduce new tests for prospective club owners to prevent irresponsible ones from taking over, and mandate better engagement between clubs and fan groups.
Labour’s implementation of the Football Governance Bill also aims to address some previous concerns about the Independent Regulator. This includes a pledge to investigate the controversial “parachute payments” awarded to recently relegated Premier League clubs, and expand the criteria for when football clubs are required to consult their fans regarding changes, such as ticket prices and relocations.
As much as powerful club owners and traditional football fans like to complain about the growing involvement of politics in football, it is evident that our beautiful game is not in a healthy state and better regulation could at least help begin to resolve football’s most pressing issues
Calls to implement such regulators have been growing for years, amid continued turmoil in the footballing world. It has almost been four years since the “big six” Premier League clubs announced an attempt to join a breakaway European Super League, a move which was met with disgust from fans and politicians alike. Many smaller clubs have meanwhile been struggling with their finances by continuing to operate with heavy financial losses, putting them at risk of insolvency.
As much as powerful club owners and traditional football fans like to complain about the growing involvement of politics in football, it is evident that our beautiful game is not in a healthy state and better regulation could at least help begin to resolve football’s most pressing issues. If the new regulator is given the necessary powers to robustly implement the rules in an otherwise ungovernable industry, it would be a major victory for fans and smaller clubs who have for too long been exploited for their passion for the game.
Some people will argue that an Independent Regulator is not needed in an industry which has historically governed itself. I argue that without a new regulator, English football as we know it could collapse altogether, as a greedy few continue to ruin the game for everyone.
No: Ben Pawlowski (Sport Editor)
Modern English football has its fair share of problems. Matchgoing fans continue to be treated with contempt, whether with sky-high ticket prices that remain on the rise or last-minute fixture alterations for TV that disregard the concerns of supporters. On the pitch, VAR continues to irritate just about everyone.
But does this nation’s ‘beautiful game’ really need a regulator to deal with these issues? Supporters of the Football Governance Bill, currently going through the House of Lords, believe so. Framed as being on the side of the ordinary supporter, its proponents say it will protect clubs from rogue owners, ensure fans have a greater voice, and defend the integrity of the footballing pyramid. I remain unconvinced.
To understand why, we have to rewind all the way back to the murky Covid-infected depths of 2021, when an audacious attempt to create a European Super League descended into a farce, stopped at the first hurdle by supporters who filled the streets to protest in vitriolic anger at the outrageous decision of leading European clubs to create their own breakaway league.
Forever partial to announcing a half-baked policy on a populist whim, everyone’s favourite blonde buffoon Boris Johnson leapt on the bandwagon and announced his government’s intention to establish an independent regulator. ‘We will stop this’, Boris proclaimed, and so this bill came to life.
I fear that this bill will overstep the mark and do irreversible damage to one of our nation’s greatest products
On the face of it, its intentions seem noble. After all, who would be against providing fans with a greater voice, or stricter rules on owners to prevent the sad demise of clubs such as Bury or Macclesfield Town? Nevertheless, I fear that this bill will overstep the mark and do irreversible damage to one of our nation’s greatest products.
The Premier League is, probably, the UK’s greatest bastion of soft power. It contributes £8 billion to the UK economy annually and sustains over 90,000 jobs. Every Saturday at 3pm, the eyes of the world turn to watch matches at grounds in Bournemouth, Brighton, and Brentford. Kids spanning the world from Melbourne to Mumbai wear the shirts of their favourite teams – Manchester United, Liverpool, Chelsea. It is one of the UK’s great success stories.
So why tamper with it? Why put its destiny in the hands of our government? After 14 years of Tory incompetence and six months of Labour flattering to deceive, the idea of cabinet ministers shaping the future of this country’s national sport fills me with trepidation. This would be reality, too, because despite it being ostensibly labelled as ‘independent’, its hard to believe there won’t be an element of government control as the regulator inevitably oversteps its mark. The warning bells have already sounded. Unlike Emi Martinez, Alisson or Matz Sells, the government is not a safe pair of hands. So leave football alone.

