Are the latest VAR changes a step in the right direction?

By Alfie Winter

On Wednesday 8th January, during Tottenham’s Carabao Cup semi-final clash against Liverpool, referee Stuart Atwell made history by becoming the first official to announce his decision over the Tannoy system in the stadium. Dominic Solanke thought he put Spurs into the lead, slotting a tidy finish home past Liverpool keeper Alisson, before VAR ruled out the goal due to an offside offence which Atwell explained over the stadium’s PA. A lack of in-stadium communication has been an ongoing issue since the introduction of VAR to English football so could this measure relieve the frustration of anxious fans, eager to hear the referee’s final decision?

VAR announcement was firstly introduced in a Club World Cup fixture between Al Alhy and Flamengo but was more famously implemented throughout the Women’s 2023 World Cup. While referees previously changed their decision with the sole explanation being a simple message on the stadium screen, this new measure instructs referees to explain their change of decision following VAR review. Following the use of in-stadium announcements in the Women’s 2023 World Cup, PGMOL’s chief officer Howard Webb confirmed his desire to implement the measure in English football. This was previously prohibited by IFAB, the body responsible for producing, and adapting football rules. The use of stadium announcements in the Carabao Cup semi-finals was therefore undoubtedly a break-through step in English football officiating, possibly preceding a wider-scale implementation of the measure across the Premier League.

During the fixture, Atwell’s exact landmark words were as follows: “After review, Dominic Solanke was in an offside position in the build up to the goal. My final decision is offside.” While this is a relatively basic decision to overturn, it will be more interesting to see how referees explain themselves in more contentious scenarios such as when overturning penalties or issuing red cards. Overall, these subjective decisions in need of explanation are the reason for stadium announcements and it is in this case where we will be able to truly assess how effective the new system could be. And while I believe that this is a good measure in improving communication with fans, I still think that there are other necessary steps in improving the stadium matchday experience with regards to VAR.

Stadium announcements are an interesting step in improving communication, more simple steps should be taken to ensure that spectators are kept up to date on VAR activities in real time

I will draw on my own experience of a match I recently went to watch at Brentford’s G-tech stadium, which was my beloved Arsenal’s away fixture against the Bees on New Year’s Day. We were desperately searching for an equaliser after Mbuemo’s early opener, and a chance was eventually converted by Gabriel Jesus. While I was delighted about the goal, my cynical referee side felt that the delay could only be bad news following a scrappy build-up to the goal. What was most annoying, however, is how we were left in the dark in the stadium: unlike TV viewers able to see close-up replays, we were not given any information about what was happening. Eventually, around two minutes following the goal, a VAR message reading “review for possible handball” was shown on the big screen, only for the referee to blow his whistle two seconds later and confirm the goal.

This was my first premier league match I had ever seen with a VAR review, and only first-hand can you really understand the frustration that fans feel, unaware of what the video assistant referees are checking for, thus hampering true, authentic celebrations. It feels as if the fan’s experience was secondary to ensuring the correct decision whereas football is, and always has been, all about the fans. For this reason, I feel that simple, yet necessary adaptations must be made to improve the stadium integration of VAR.

Firstly, as soon as a VAR check begins, this must be communicated on the big screens so that fans are informed of reviews being made. Furthermore, the screen should communicate exactly what the Video Assistant Referee is looking for in real time, be it a handball, serious foul play or any other offence. I am aware they currently do put this information on the screens, but from my experience, it was ineffective as it was far too delayed. Despite the simplicity of these efforts, they will heavily reduce confusion, anxiety and frustration in stadiums which are ultimately directed towards the referee rather than the video assistant team sitting comfortably at Stockley Park.

I will therefore conclude this article inspired by Mr Atwell: After my review, my final decision is that VAR must better adapt to the matchday stadium experience. While I do believe that stadium announcements are an interesting step in improving communication, more simple steps should be taken to ensure that spectators are kept up to date on VAR activities in real time. Currently, VAR better suits the TV viewer, benefitting from close-up replays, and, in my opinion, we are yet to identify the best solution for fans in stadiums when it is them who should be priority. Atwell’s offside call is a moment in English refereeing history, and I hope that PGMOL builds on this landmark by continuing to explore ways to ensure the complete, seamless integration of VAR into the matchday stadium experience.

Image: Артем Гусев via Wikimedia Commons