The life of a football referee in the age of social media

By Alfie Winter

Waking up early on a frosty Sunday winter morning, getting shouted at by 22 strangers for 90 minutes and running an average of 12km per game: why would anyone want to be a referee? It is unfortunately this exact realisation that has led to the decline in referees across the UK and worldwide. The FA have continuously tried to improve refereeing conditions by cracking down on misconduct, yet, in the age of social media, it could be argued that the refereeing climate is becoming more hateful than ever. While post-match memes and tweets constantly ridicule referees, managers and clubs who critique officials only add to the hostility towards them. But with the emergence of a video allegedly showing the Premier League referee David Coote making derogatory comments about JĂĽrgen Klopp, do referees deserve the vilification that they face in the media?

I passed my referee test as a 15-year-old and since then I am proud to say that I have received two promotions progressing from a youth official to a senior county referee. Undoubtedly my skills and confidence have built enormously over my years of refereeing, and I have had the great privilege of working with many other great referees, officiating in county cup finals, league cup finals, and even last year’s men’s floodlit final! However, this is not to say that my experience as a referee has always been positive: I was confronted on the pitch by an angry parent in an U14’s fixture, a manager that I sent off proceeded to hide in a bush and refused to leave the field of play, I was shoulder barged by an aggravated manager and I had to call off a cup final following claims of racism leading to an all-out brawl on the pitch.

Unfortunately, this sort of experience is not at all rare. According to a Radio 5 Live survey, 98% of referees state that they had received verbal abuse, 32% reported they had received physical abuse, and alarmingly 6% claimed to have received a death threat towards themselves or a loved one. For such a reason, it is unsurprising that so many refs are giving up the job due to the ongoing abuse that they receive. While many excuse this behaviour, claiming that football is an aggressive sport where emotions may naturally “run high,” I am always astounded to see the respect that rugby referees receive in an arguably more physical sport. So, if the aggression towards officials does not originate in the sport itself, how has football culture led to the increase in this abuse?

According to a Radio 5 Live survey, 98% of referees state that they had received verbal abuse, 32% reported they had received physical abuse, and alarmingly 6% claimed to have received a death threat towards themselves or a loved one.

Referees are the most important person on the pitch. Ultimately, they determine the outcome of the game – thus, faithful fans, players and staff feeling decisions are not going their way often respond in disquiet aggression. However, while chants such as “you’re not fit to referee” have echoed around stadiums for many years, I believe social media has aggravated the abuse. One example of this is Nottingham’s Forest public critique following their match against Everton on 21st April in the 23-24 PL season. Their tweet expressing their discontent regarding several penalty incidents was posted just short of five minutes after the match. It read:

“Three extremely poor decisions – three penalties not given – which we simply cannot accept.

We warned the PGMOL that the VAR is a Luton fan before the game, but they didn’t change him. Our patience has been tested multiple times. NFFC will now consider its options.”

The tweet accused Premier League referee Stuart Atwell of bias and cheating due to his affiliation to Nottingham Forest’s relegation rival Luton Town. Quite rightly, Forest were heavily sanctioned with a £750,000 fine, although this does not mitigate the knock-on effect caused by their public claim. A football club should exemplify appropriate treatment of officials, but their questioning of PGMOL’s integrity only creates more distrust, hence abuse towards referees amongst players and fans from the very top to the very bottom of the football pyramid.

Another example is the legendary manager José Mourinho, well known as one of the most charismatic, successful, and best-loved managers of all time. He is adored by football fans across the world, yet his recent action on his Instagram account has me questioning if his influence is indeed positive. In the 82nd minute of Fenerbahçe’s match vs Trabzonspor on November 3rd, 2024, a potential penalty incident was reviewed by the VAR, Atilla Karaoglan, who decided not to overrule referee Oguzhan Cakir’s original decision of no penalty. Following an already lengthy and insulting post-match rant, in which Mourinho called Cakir “a little boy,” the Fenerbahçe manager proceeded to post the video of the entire penalty incident on his Instagram account. The video was captioned: “Watch and smile. If you like it watch the game because the funny situations don’t stop with this clip”.

However, not all is doom and gloom as refereeing is progressing in the right direction. On 26 December 2023, PL refereeing debuts were given to Sam Allison, the first black premier referee for 15 years since the long-serving Uriah Rennie, and Rebecca Welch, the first ever female referee to officiate in the Premier League

While this public statement already ridicules the referee and his team, what is arguably more damaging is the content of the video. At several points, the referee is surrounded by around eight players and is repeatedly seen trying to usher them away to create himself some space. Mourinho’s comment of this video being a “funny situation” is more harmful than initially thought, normalising and mocking the mistreatment of referees working in a highly challenging and hostile environment. Public comments like Mourinho’s must stop as they risk spreading this toxic treatment of referees to the new footballing generation, where instead we should be advocating mutual respect.

By contrast, certain referee’s actions do not do football officials any favours. Take for example the recent emergence of a video clip showing a man, alleged to be Premier League referee David Coote, making derogatory comments about Jürgen Klopp and his Liverpool side following their 1-1 draw against Burnley in July 2020. In the video, the man calls the former Liverpool manager “arrogant,” among other insults, claiming “he (Klopp) had a right pop at me,” during the game in question. The individual may indeed be justified in calling out Klopp’s poor behaviour towards officials: during Liverpool’s last minute 4-3 win over Tottenham in April 2023, Klopp excessively celebrated in the face of fourth official, John Brooks. While I understand that it is incredibly difficult to be disciplined and professional when being faced by unjustified aggressive behaviour, it is fundamental that referees restrain from adding to the hostile player-official relationship. The investigation of this video is currently under review by PGMOL, and action will surely be taken if the individual is proven to be Mr Coote. Let this serve as an example that we must not let hate and aggression win in football, and instead we must promote a culture of respect and forgiveness.

However, not all is doom and gloom as refereeing is progressing in the right direction. On 26 December 2023, PL refereeing debuts were given to Sam Allison, the first black premier referee for 15 years since the long-serving Uriah Rennie, and Rebecca Welch, the first ever female referee to officiate in the Premier League, both serving as a significant role model for under-represented groups in the elite leagues. Furthermore, PL’s new show “Mic’d Up” hosted by Michael Owen, gives PGMOL’s chief refereeing officer, Howard Webb, the chance to explain refereeing decisions and mistakes. This positive move creates a link between officials and fans, allowing us to understand how they came to their final decision, be it right or wrong. Overall, transparency between referees, fans and clubs within the media could be key in improving the treatment of officials, and in creating a more inclusive and welcoming environment for all involved in the beautiful game.

Image: Steindy via Wikimedia Commons