The hope and disappointment of the Nations League

By Alfie Winter

England’s 5-0 home win against the Republic of Ireland came as a relief to many: not only did the young Three Lions side put in an excellent performance, but they also secured automatic promotion to League A of the UEFA Nations League. Following relegation after a poor campaign in 2022, Gareth Southgate’s side were not looking good heading into the 2024 EUROs. Perhaps England exceeded expectations, finding their way into the final, but the less said about what happened that night in Berlin, the better. Overall, Lee Carsley succeeded as caretaker manager, earning the Three Lions automatic promotion to League A, bringing England’s Nations League campaign to a close. However, for many other nations, their competition could be far from over.

Introduced in 2018, the Nations League aimed to replace meaningless friendlies with competitive fixtures, giving teams a chance to test themselves before major tournaments like the World Cup. The original Nations League format concluded with automatic promotion of the team finishing at the top of their group in each of the four leagues (A, B, C & D), and automatic relegation of teams at the bottom of Leagues A and B. The only previous play-off in the competition was for the bottom four teams in League C who would be paired up to play a two-legged fixture, determining two nations to join the two groups of League D.

From now on, the third-ranked team of League A and B will have to compete to retain their place by winning a two-legged play-off versus the runners up of the league below

While automatic promotion for League B and C winners and automatic relegation of bottom-placed teams remain in place, this new format sees a few changes to the original structure. From now on, the third-ranked team of League A and B will have to compete to retain their place by winning a two-legged play-off versus the runners up of the league below. If they lose, they will be relegated, and their opponent nation will take their place in their league. However, for League C, the two highest UEFA-ranked of the bottom-placed teams will play a deciding two-legged play-off fixture against League D’s two runners-up. There is no doubt that this format is more confusing, and many believe this change to be a pointless addition of games, adding to the increasingly demanding football calendar.

Yet to fully assess the new format, it is essential to look at the broader implications for all teams, not just England. Any result other than automatic promotion would have seen disappointment for the Three Lions who are currently ranked as number 1 in UEFA rankings and number 4 in the FIFA rankings. The closest ranking team in England’s group, B2, is Greece who sit at 13th in Europe and 42nd in the World. Greece enjoyed a fantastic campaign, securing a historic 2-1 win over England at Wembley, only missing the top spot by goal difference. While a play-off fixture would have seemed an inconvenience to England, Greece will cherish the opportunity to secure a second successive promotion following topping their League C group in the 2022-23 Nation’s League campaign.

Greece’s exceptional performance in Group B2 has set up a nail-biting fixture vs Scotland which will be played in March 2025. If the main goal of the Nation’s League is to give teams a better opportunity to play more competitive matches, then the implementation of play-offs can only be a positive addition. While Scotland will be determined to retain their League A spot, Greece will do everything in their power to cap off what has already been an exceptional campaign. Competing under this level of pressure may not fully rival the intensity of the World Cup, but it undoubtedly gives teams in the play-offs a critical goal to strive for. The opportunity is undoubtedly more exciting for runners-up with a chance for promotion; however, it also gives teams in third place the chance to prove themselves, under more intense pressure, following a poor campaign.

The Three Lions will still play competitive matches in the March 2025 international break but instead, in their charge for World Cup qualification

Yet we must also debunk the myth that automatically promoted and relegated teams, including England, will play fewer games. The Three Lions will still play competitive matches in the March 2025 international break but instead, in their charge for World Cup qualification. It will be in these matches that the new manager, Thomas Tuchel, will take the helm and possibly lead England to their long-awaited major trophy. This means that England will not be drawn into a group with any of the play-off teams, as those nations will be focused on their two-legged fixtures during the international break.

Overall, this new play-off format seems a positive addition to the Nations League, giving teams a chance to meaningfully compete under high pressure similar to that of major international competitions. England’s most recent Nations League campaign has not had such competitive fixtures like they may have had in League A however we cannot let this undermine the excitement that fans of Greece, Armenia, or Malta may be feeling, eager to see their nation promoted. Instead of dwelling on England’s shortcomings in the competition, we should look forward to the upcoming play-off matches as a neutral fan – games that hold immense significance for the nations fighting for their place on the world stage. The UEFA Nations League play-offs will be played on Thursday 20th and Sunday 23rd March 2025 and details of all the fixtures can be found on the Nations League website.

Image: Saggittarius A via Wikimedia Commons