Why AFCON deserves more
By Alfie Winter
Liverpool legend and football pundit Jamie Carragher is once again at the centre of attention for all the wrong reasons. In his post-match analysis after another sterling performance from Mohamed Salah in Liverpool’s 2-0 victory over Manchester City, pundits Roy Keane, Micah Richards, Daniel Sturridge and Carragher were discussing Salah’s chances to win this year’s Ballon d’Or. The die-hard Liverpool fan claimed that Salah, as an Egyptian, and thus “not playing in the major tournaments”, means that he has to do well in either “the Champions League” or the Premier League to win the greatest individual football accolade. Richards then interjected saying “AFCON is a major tournament” to which Carragher replied “God” and rolled his eyes to the camera. This unsurprisingly sparked a lot of outrage online and it has many questioning what AFCON actually represents to audiences across the World. Is the tournament a deadbeat competition created to keep in trend with the “superior” European and South American editions, or can we actually consider it on the same level?
Every continent in the world has their own intercontinental football championships organised by their retrospective football governing bodies. The first edition of the EUROs, known as the European Nations’ Cup at the time, was held in 1960 and was won by the U.S.S.R. AFCON is actually older than the EUROs, dating back to 1957 in Sudan which, ironically, Egypt won. So, if it is not a case of age and history, why is it that some, including Carragher, regard AFCON as a lesser competition? It cannot be because Europe’s top five leagues are lacking in African ballers with the likes of Mo Salah running the show this year.
Aside from the Egyptian King, many teams across Europe are lucky to have such high-quality players from Africa. Look no further than 2024 African Player of the Year Ademola Lookman, who bagged a hat-trick against an unbeaten Bayern Leverkusen side in last year’s Europa League final. In that very same side, Xavi Alonso’s main man upfront was Victor Boniface, who got 23 goal contributions in just as many games in the Bundesliga last season. In the Premier League this season, there have been many standout African players including Palace’s Ismaila Sarr, West Ham’s Mohammed Kudus, Brighton’s Yankuba Minteh, Nottingham Forest’s Ola Aina. I could go on.
Pundits are hugely influential on football fans across the nation, and I hope that they…use their platform for the good in advocating equality and respect in our game
All in all, there is no lack in quality amongst African players across Europe and the world, which to me renders this argument of AFCON being a lesser tournament completely meaningless. However, one of the reasons many people take issue with the tournament is due to when it takes place in the football calendar. AFCON’s next edition is due to be played from 21 December 2025 to 18 January 2026. This means that European-based African players will need to take time out of playing for their club to represent their country. AFCON is played at this time of the year as this is the dry season, allowing African players and fans alike to enjoy the tournament at an optimal time of the year.
Ian Wright is someone I hugely admire as an ex-Arsenal legend, but also as an advocate for equality and solidarity in football. Ahead of AFCON 2021 Wright commented, “You are getting journalists asking players […] if they will be honouring the call-ups to their national teams. Imagine if that was an English player representing the Three Lions. Can you imagine the furore?”. It seems that there are hypocritical expectations from English and European fans for their African players to sacrifice playing for their nation to continue competing for their club. It is the biggest honour of any player’s career to get called up for their country therefore to truly support our African players, we must not only respect their decisions but encourage them to follow their international endeavours as a footballer and as an individual proudly representing their nation.
I understand that Jamie Carragher is not in fact discouraging Salah from attending AFCON, yet his comment as one of Sky Sports’ flagship pundits undermines his own employer. Just like in the last edition of the competition, AFCON will be exclusively on Sky Sports for UK viewers. In 2023, the tournament reached new heights for TV viewership and over 2 billion consumers tuned in to watch the competition across 180 countries around the World. Social media also played a key part in increasing visibility of the tournament, and we can only hope that this upwards trend continues. Carragher’s comments during the aftermath of one of the Premier League’s most watched matchdays dangerously fuelled the narrative of AFCON as an inferior competition and subverted Sky Sports’ investment and commitment to giving the tournament the attention that it deserves. Pundits are hugely influential on football fans across the nation, and I hope that they, like Richards and Wright, use their platform for the good in advocating equality and respect in our game.
Image: Ben Sutherland via Wikimedia Commons

