VAT at Mallory Towers (i.e. private school)

By Abigail Tobias

“Wow, so you’re from Leeds,” one of my cohort in my first ever Calculus tutorial exclaims, as we go round the table, sharing where we had come from before starting at Durham. “Did you, like, get a contextual offer because you’re Northern?” Contextual, for those who don’t know, means easier. This was not the first experience at Durham University where I felt marked out because of the state comprehensive I had attended in Leeds. Another interaction was, perhaps, more my fault; I had not realised Lacrosse was a real sport, thinking it was made up for Mallory Towers in the same way as Quidditch was for Harry Potter, and had proceeded to have a good chuckle when being asked if I was trying out for the team. Those girls, it transpired, were not interested in being my friend after this.

It was only on arriving at university that I realised I was entering a whole new world full of Private Schoolers – particularly from the South East. After spending time forging friendships and overcoming cultural barriers (the confusion of me calling dinner “tea” led to many misunderstandings), I also came to realise why some of these students’ parents had paid such exorbitant fees to send their children to private schools, and it was not just the education.

True, many of them had the chance to study options not offered at my comprehensive- Latin, Greek or Mandarin, whilst I only got to study one language. They couldn’t believe it when I told them my school had had to stop providing triple science GCSE after running out of funding. Yet this was not the key incentive to go private.

The key realisation for me was that opportunity and success in the elite job market depended, not always on what you know – apparent after spending my Freshers Week arguing with those who claimed the economy would never be stronger than under Liz Truss – but who you know. Work experience and job opportunities are frequently obtained through networking, often family or friends will offer you work experience or an internship. Private schools are aware of the power connections hold; many offer alumni networking events where students can meet leaders in the field and make contacts. At university, students can still contact their former alma maters for contacts and connections if struggling to find a job. Whilst there have been amazing initiatives to level the field, such as The 93% Club at university for state-schooled students, the cycle is self-perpetuating.

The key realisation for me was that opportunity and success in the elite job market depended, not always on what you know – apparent after spending my Freshers Week arguing with those who claimed the economy would never be stronger than under Liz Truss – but who you know.

Only earlier last week, a candidate for Oxford University Chancellorship Peter Mandelson highlighted how Oxford should widen access to disadvantaged students. Despite general acknowledgement that there is huge inequality in the education sector, few of Labour’s manifesto policies have caused such an outpouring of outrage as their introduction of VAT on fee-paying schools. As a current undergraduate at Durham University, which ranked second for private school intake in 2023 (39.1% of students compared to just 7% nationally), I must admit I was puzzled by the furore. The discussion was only about whether it would improve the public finances, or limit parental choice: not about tackling inequality. Similarly, discussions around contextual offers or quotas are, in my experience, often met with gasps of horror. “It puts private school children who have worked hard at a disadvantage” many respond, alongside claims that this goes against meritocracy. There’s no acknowledgment that VAT exemption – which after all is meant to be for charities, not rich people’s children – is also special treatment and one subsidised by the taxpayer.

Since starting University I’ve had access to a wealth of opportunities. I’ve worked my way on to the Editorial Board of our student paper, interviewed a baroness and human rights lawyer, attended debates between Conservative and Labour Ministers at The Durham Union, and even been invited to a drinks reception for Dominic Cummings (I thought my dad would disown me, but he merely commented I should ask Dominic if he had come via Barnard Castle). I’m grateful for all these, and to my wonderful comprehensive who made them possible. It would be good if others acknowledged the role of good fortune too.

Image: theirhistory via Flickr