Jadon Sancho: has he been unfairly treated?
By Ben Pawlowski
Manners maketh man, and man management maketh manager. Whilst the tactical side of football has undoubtedly become increasingly advanced, so too has the side of man management. For many of the great managers, from Sir Alex Ferguson to Carlo Ancelotti, their key to success laid in learning how to handle players – harnessing egos, ensuring squad discipline, establishing a culture of respect, and cultivating a cohesive unit are imperative to achieving success and longevity.
Erik Ten Hag, now in his second year as Manchester United manager, has experienced a crash course in this underappreciated part of the game since arriving at Old Trafford. A litany of disciplinary issues involving several star players, both within and outside of football, has sought to undermine a managerial reign already compromised by a lack of footballing identity, over-expensive recruitment, and the perpetual issue of the deeply unpopular Glazer family ownership.
Exacerbated by a frustrating start to the season including three losses, Ten Hag will have been deeply annoyed once again to be forced into dealing with further off-field issues. Jadon Sancho, who arrived from Borussia Dortmund in the summer of 2021 for a deal worth £73million, is now training “away from the first team group pending resolution of a squad discipline issue”.
The saga began when Ten Hag dropped Sancho from his playing squad for the fixture away at Arsenal in early September, citing Sancho’s “performance in training” as the principal reason. Sancho took to X to vent his frustration at the manager, claiming that he has “been a scapegoat for a long time”, and that, in contrast to Ten Hag’s assertion, had conducted himself “very well in training” that week.
It appears that Sancho’s reluctance to delete the post and his further unwillingness to issue a public apology has left him outside of the first team for the foreseeable future, and potentially forever.Â
For many, this will appear a clear-cut case in favour of Ten Hag. Since joining in 2022, Ten Hag has dealt with both minor and major professional issues in his squad in a firm manner. Last December, Marcus Rashford was dropped to the bench after he missed a team meeting ahead of a fixture against Wolves. After Cristiano Ronaldo’s explosive interview with Piers Morgan last November, Ten Hag didn’t allow the player’s superstar nature to affect his judgment, going onto say Ronaldo “had to leave… it was quite clear.” Therefore it could be argued that the punishment Sancho has received is in line with the precedent Ten Hag has set.
However, it must be noted that this case, and the case of Sancho’s underwhelming Manchester United career to date, remain far more nuanced than a sweeping commentary of affairs may suggest.
The pressures of missing a penalty in such a scenario will have been tough enough to deal with mentally, let alone the racist abuse received too.
Sancho spent a significant portion of the first half of 2023 away from the United squad due to what Ten Hag described as “physical and mental issues”. If it is clear that Sancho has been suffering from mental health issues, then he is entitled to a duty of care from his club that does not include public banishment. At the very least, he requires a regime of support to help him, primarily as a human being, and secondly as a Manchester United footballer.
Sancho has struggled to truly settle in since making the switch from the Bundesliga in 2021, with just 9 goals in 58 Premier League appearances, compared to the 38 goals he scored in 104 Bundesliga outings. While it may be inappropriate to speculate, it should be noted that Sancho’s arrival in Manchester coincided with the Euro 2020 tournament where Marcus Rashford, Bukayo Saka, and himself all missed penalties in the shootout final defeat against Italy.
Horrifically, the trio all suffered repugnant racist abuse on social media. The pressures of missing a penalty in such a scenario will have been tough enough to deal with mentally, let alone the racist abuse received too. Sancho was just 21 at the time, and it would be unreasonable to suggest that such a moment would not have profoundly impacted him. This may serve to explain his slump in form and recent issues of indiscipline.
Ultimately, Manchester United should realise that they have a duty of care towards Sancho, still just 23 years of age. Whilst Ten Hag needs to ensure squad discipline, and has every right to do so considering his own managerial position, that should not come at the potential cost of a player’s wellbeing. As with the revelations recently revealed by Dele, a fellow young England international seemingly destined for stardom before his career stagnated, we never know what footballers are experiencing away from the football pitch. Perhaps in this case, it might be worth giving Sancho the benefit of the doubt.
Image by Ardfern wia WikiMedia Commons
