A game of two halves: is Trent Alexander-Arnold right to leave Liverpool?
By Joseph Saunders and Ben Pawlowski
YES – Joseph Saunders (Sport Editor):
Of course he should. The triumph of winning the 2024/25 Premier League title, this time with fans present in the stadium, was Alexander-Arnold’s final hill to conquer. One victory each across the UEFA Cuper Cup, Club World Cup, Community Shield, FA Cup, League Cup, and Champions League creates a tantalisingly symmetric trophy cabinet for Trent and one that is complete. Simply put, he has won it all with Liverpool.
But he won’t be satisfied. At 26 years old, the right-back has plenty of time to supplement his personal legacy. Alongside Lionel Messi, Manuel Neuer, and N’Golo Kante, Alexander-Arnold is one of the few true gamebreakers of the 21st century. His utility as a genuine goals/assists provider from right-back has been remarkable to witness in a Premier League environment still fixated on Marcus Alonso and Victor Moses’ success in Antonio Conte’s 3-4-3 system when he arrived in the 2016/17 season. Alexander-Arnold provided that threat in a flat back four with a greater passing range and more defensive responsibility. Liverpool built their structure around Trent. In return, opposing teams had to build theirs to stop him. Leaving his boyhood club will be hard, but even Steven Gerrard’s head was turned by Chelsea.
It is no secret that Real Madrid are the only club Trent would move to. Trent’s gamebreaking status, iconic 66 shirt number, and association with eternal footballing culture moments (think ‘corner taken quickly’ and ‘pressure is for tyres’) fit into Florentino Perez’s ‘Galactico’s 2.0’ ethos perfectly. Dani Carvajal’s injury and age will see him drop to the bench and Lucas Vazquez is versatile and committed enough to remain at the club too. Perez’s tendency bring shiny things into his nest means he will overlook any tactical nuances Trent’s arrival might bring, though Carlo Ancelotti’s likely departure for Brazil (whether or not Madrid get their way about his deferment for the Club World Cup) at the end of the season will allow for a new face to work with the Liverpudlian from the outset. Jude Bellingham is already a very familiar face for him, and the echoes of Steve McManaman, Michael Owen, and David Beckham are impossible to resist.
NO – Ben Pawlowski (Sport Editor):
Ian Rush. Kenny Dalglish. Steven Gerrard. With one FA Cup, one League Cup, one Champions League and now two Premier League titles, Trent Alexander-Arnold is well on his way to adding his name to this glorious list of all-time Liverpool legends.
Adored and revered by the red half of Merseyside, the right-back is a rare shining light within the often-grubby landscape of modern football. A local lad and an academy product, wearing the now-iconic No.66, Trent has played a pivotal role in success not seen at Anfield in decades. More than that, his unique profile – the audacious passing range, the spectacular assists – has changed the very way the role of the full-back is understood. Liverpool fans will talk about his best moments for decades – the free kicks, the late left-footed winner at Leicester, ‘corner taken quickly’. After all, he is the ‘Scouser in our team’.
So why throw that all away? Perhaps he could be forgiven for succumbing to the allure of the Bernabéu if, like Steven Gerrard, his Liverpool career coincided with a rare drought of titles. But that is not the case. In fact, Liverpool look primed for a period of domestic dominance under the wise tutelage of Arne Slot, with several other sides going through a period of transition. More Premier League titles and more cups surely await.
Real Madrid may be an understandably attractive proposition, but they are not the guarantee of glory they have been in recent years. This season, they have been usurped domestically by Hansi Flick’s electric Barcelona side, whilst their comprehensive Champions League defeat to Arsenal exposed their frailties and, moreover, a generally unpleasant demeanour that emerges when things go wrong. There are tactical considerations, too. Real rely heavily on individual brilliance from their Galactico 2.0 stars – the likes of Kylian Mbappe, Vinicius Jr and, of course, Trent’s great buddy Jude Bellingham. While Trent is no stranger to moments of superlative magnificence, Real’s style of play is worlds apart from the tactical systems of Slot and Jurgen Klopp under which the Liverpudlian has thrived.
But, perhaps most importantly of all, Real are no match for the spine-tingling, lump-in-the-throat-inducing moments that Liverpool can bring. Stood in front of the Kop as a young Scouser, listening to thousands of Redmen who adore you singing ‘You’ll Never Walk Alone’ as the side celebrate a Premier League title? Trent, don’t let that go.
Image: Damine178 via Wikimedia Commons

