Can a new spring dawn on Hollywood?
By Katie Trahair-Davies
April Fool’s Day 2025. An announcement that the casting of a new Beatles biopic has been finalised. Paul Mescal, Barry Keoghan, Harris Dickinson and Joseph Quinn each in one of the starring roles. What a fantastic prank for Hollywood to pull on this day, I thought, as I glanced at the news that morning.
Yet, Hollywood isn’t joking. And it turns out a large portion of the internet are just as unhappy about the matter as I am. A multitude of questions are arising as to whether these actors have been chosen simply due to their preexisting stardom, if they will be able to hold a convincing enough Liverpudlian accent, and most importantly, if they will be able to embody the camp whimsy that the Beatles displayed throughout much of their career.
Valentine’s Day 2026. The recently announced official release date for the newest adaptation of Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights. An innovative marketing technique, seeing as this novel has always been known for its tragic nature. Margot Robbie, an actress synonymous with her The Wolf of Wall Street blonde bob, cast as the dark haired and moody Cathy. Jacob Elordi, Saltburn star and evident muse of director Emerald Fennell, playing Heathcliff – a casting that goes directly against the ethnicity ascribed to the character in Brontë’s original imagining of the tale.
Are casting directors lazily resorting to already famous actors because it is an almost guaranteed route to commercial success?
These two events made me come to reflect upon the epidemic of dire casting that appears to be upon us. Are casting directors lazily resorting to already famous actors because it is an almost guaranteed route to commercial success? Or is this an overly pessimistic view that neglects to acknowledge that these actors are indeed famous for a reason: they can act well?
With such famous subjects of adaptation, it is likely that an audience would be attracted regardless of the cast. This begs the question of whether more creative casting choices could have been facilitated – perhaps allowing new faces an opportunity to work alongside respected directors, or discovering an actor that is more suited to the role. We must ask whether it is the responsibility of projects like this to facilitate new talent, or is this an unfair burden to place on them?
Undeniably, the biggest miscast of these two films is that of Elordi in Wuthering Heights. Despite his acting experience that will no doubt bring the character’s complexity to life, this casting choice raises questions surrounding diversity within the production, as he is effectively denying another actor of a rare POC role in one of the most enduringly famous period dramas. Instead, Fennell appears to be completely disregarding this vital piece of Heathcliff’s identity in favour of once more picking Elordi for a role, choosing to rely instead on the commercial success raked in by their last collaboration, Saltburn.
Much of the online commentary on sites such as TikTok surrounding the previewed pictures of Fennell’s Wuthering Heights appears to hold genuine disappointment on the perceived lack of attention to other historical details, such as Robbie’s costume and hair. Similarly, diehard fans of the novel are confused at the romantic focus that has dominated the film’s initial promotion, with groans that everything is being turned into a romance these days. Although Fennell has built a reputation for successfully pulling off creative-turned-daring twists and re-imaginings in her past directorial works, it has to be questioned whether this will translate successfully with a novel that is so culturally enduring.
Furthermore, if the industry persists in churning out replicas of the same material at a startling pace, each adaptation faces the challenge of displaying the same attention to detail that cinephiles admire, and an originality that will keep them interested
Furthermore, if the industry persists in churning out replicas of the same material at a startling pace, each adaptation faces the challenge of displaying the same attention to detail that cinephiles admire, and an originality that will keep them interested. Whilst Fennell’s and Mendes’ adaptations should not have to appease every super-fan of the tale they wish to adapt, and it is perhaps too soon to fully judge whether in fact their productions will leave viewers in the lurch, early reactions appear unsure whether the two directors have been able to strike a successful balance between narrative accuracy and originality.
If one wants to rake in the viewers, then it is evidently no easier than to cast Elordi, Robbie or any of the fabulous four young male actors. Although diehard Brontë or Beatles fan may leave the cinema disappointed, Mendes and Fennell are guaranteed success through the credence that these names alone bring to their projects. In a time where the entertainment industry is becoming more precarious, this may be a balance that established directors like themselves have to maintain.
And, as evidenced by my writing here and the general cultural discourse, perhaps the best way to publicise your new film is to cast notorious heartthrobs regardless of whether they fit the bill or not, and then watch the world argue over their suitability, safe in the knowledge that if anything, they will come to watch your film out of disgruntled curiosity over how on earth you are going to make this work.
Illustration: Carly Tait

