The United Nations approves the first carbon credit initiative

By Katie Trahair-Davies

On 26th February, a UN body approved the first credits to be issued under the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism (otherwise known as Article 6.4 or PACM).

First conceptualised under the 2015 Paris Agreement, the scheme aims to incentivise participation in carbon-reduction projects. These initial credits have been issued in compensation for a project funded by South Korean businesses that will supply carbon efficient cookstoves across Myanmar. However, the scheme launches amidst wavering resolve in governments to reach Net Zero, as well as growing scrutiny from activists and climate watchdogs over claims of greenwashing.

The scheme launches amidst wavering resolve in governments to reach Net Zero, as well as growing scrutiny from activists and climate watchdogs over claims of greenwashing

But what is the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism? Previously known as the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), Article 6.4 is an updated, stricter version of this UN-run carbon offsetting scheme. Now, roughly a decade after the Paris Agreement, The UN has remodelled the CDM to correspond with new Net Zero goals and tighter environmental regulations.

Described by BioEnergy Times as “a new global market set up to help reduce greenhouse gas emissions”, the scheme encourages both companies and countries to offset excess emissions through financing programmes that help to reach other nation’s climate goals.

Headed by a supervisory board that oversee the market’s progress and regulations, the UN hopes that the market will be seen as a structured and supervised route by which countries can “implement national action plans more affordably”. It also hopes to work as a scheme of mutual beneficiaries, with donors receiving credited compensation for their investment that will help them to comply with emission reduction obligations, whilst the recipient nation will additionally receive a share of the proceeds that can help build even further climate resilience.

These changes to the CDM, which led to the creation of the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism came to fruition at the 2024 COP29 summit in Azerbaijan. Mkhuthazi Steleki, Article 6.4 Supervisory Body Chair, said: “By applying updated values and more conservative calculations, the credited reductions are about 40 percent lower than what older systems would have issued. The result is consistent with environmental integrity requirements and ensures that each credited tonne genuinely represents a tonne reduced and contributes to the goals of the Paris Agreement.” 

The inclusion of both governments and private firms within the scheme highlights its aims to channel sources of additional finance within all aspects of the global market towards developing nations, which often struggle to fund climate initiatives. Article 6.4 involves the inclusion of a clearer framework of guidance for the regulation of these credit exchanges, hoping to avoid the over-inflation of credits to donors.  

The Myanmar initiative kickstarts the implementation of PACM across Asia, Africa and Latin America, with the UN confirming that over 165 projects that were approved under CDM are seeking to transition into the new system.

Executed by a South Korean NGO and with investment from private South Korean firms, the project in Myanmar will work to implement cleaner cooking across the nation through more sustainable cookstoves. Credits gained from the initiative are expected to be used by South Korean polluters to reach their commitments under South Korea’s emissions trading system. This will also allow the government to legitimise these units towards their own emission reduction targets. Any remaining credits will be passed to Myanmar, in order to aid the country in maintaining its own national climate plan.

The UN’s Climate Change Executive Secretary Simon Stiell commented that the first credits “show how this mechanism can support solutions that make a big difference in people’s daily lives, as well as channelling finance to where it delivers real-life benefits on the ground.”

This mechanism can support solutions that make a big difference in people’s daily lives

Simon Stiell

However, climate watch dogs and environmentalists have raised concerns, claiming that there are significant disparities between the promise of the scheme and how private companies and governments may treat it. Prominent environmental group Greenpeace has argued that companies could find loopholes in the scheme that will allow them to continue polluting. Furthermore, there are worries that there have not been sufficient policy changes in the changeover from CDM to prevent companies and governments from overstating, or greenwashing, their emission reductions.

Credit inflation is a concern for many, with NGO Carbon Market Watch claiming that the project could potentially generate up to 26 times more credit than it should. Furthermore, offsetting strategies hold the potentiality to encourage companies and governments to purchase credits, rather than investing in more profound emission reductions at home.

However, if PACM is used in conjunction with more rigorous climate action instead of acting as a replacement, there is hope that this scheme could be a positive addition to the global fight against climate change.

Image credit: UK Government via Wikimedia Commons