An interview with Lucy Foley: modern day murder-mystery, literary inspirations and her latest novel

By Katie Trahair-Davies 

A few weeks ago, Durham became a hive of literary activity as the annual Durham book festival took place in the Gala theatre. On the Sunday morning, myself and my fellow Books editor Emily settled down to watch the panel ‘Thrilling Fiction with Lucy Foley and Matthew Blake’, hosted by one of Durham University’s own, Professor Simon James. 

Having stayed up for a night earlier in the week enthralled by Foley’s recent book The Midnight Feast, I was excited to hear both the panellists discuss modern crime fiction and the thriller genre, and to pick Lucy’s brains further in a private interview after the event. The talk was wide ranging: discussing both the authors personal lives and inspirations, the conventions, their differing writing processes, and the future of the thriller genre, amongst other topics. 

Sat in the gala theatre café, still bustling after the event, Lucy and I spent half an hour discussing her writing and literary influences in more depth. Warm and bubbly, she was a pleasure to interview: receptive to my questions and full of interesting insights surrounding her new novel. 

The Midnight Party is a mystery thriller set in a West Country manor house-turned health retreat, bringing the trope of the country house murder so often found in Golden Age murder mysteries into the modern day. This is intertwined with aspects of folklore tradition – Foley is quick to point out the prevalent Folk-horror and Folk-mythology traditions still rife in this part of the world, saying that researching this aspect of the novel felt like “pulling a thread and realising there was just so much there I could use that would feed its way into my own folk-legend”. 

Leading us on to the topic of her literary inspirations, Foley cites Thomas Hardy as a huge influence on this aspect of the novel. Coming to his work through Tess of the d’Urbervilles and Jude the Obscure, she says that she drew most heavily upon his “creepy” short stories during the writing of The Midnight Party. Without creating spoilers, another noticeable horror aspect of the novel is the theme of birds: a direct reference to Daphne De Maurier’s The Birds – a story she found so inspirational that she felt that she had to outwardly pay homage to it. Asked further about her literary relationship with De Maurier, Lucy expands: “I have this unholy trinity of female writers I’m really inspired by: De Maurier for atmosphere, [Patricia] Highsmith for character and [Agatha] Christie for plot”, explaining that she is constantly thinking of what they would do whilst writing her thrillers.  

“I have this unholy trinity of female writers I’m really inspired by: De Maurier for atmosphere, [Patricia] Highsmith for character and [Agatha] Christie for plot”

Foley goes on to say that The Midnight Party is a book where there are “lots of Ripley-adjacent things going on, because you have these characters that turn up under different names and identities” and that “everyone in the book is wearing a mask”, evolving the time-old literary theme of the double. As this is something that she wanted to achieve in a way that didn’t feel too clever or synthetic, she used a method of scattering “breadcrumbs” throughout the text; making sure that the clues are there, but at the same time distracting the reader, so that the truth is partially obscured until looking back retrospectively once all has been revealed.

Following in the footsteps of many crime giants in the literary world, it was inescapable for the panel to discuss Lucy and Matt’s relationship with the work of the queen of the English murder mystery story. I revisited this within my interview, asking if Agatha Christie’s influence had played a role in both her most recent novel, as well as her earliest thriller (and most ‘Christie-esque’ story) The Hunting Party. After alluding to the overarching inspiration that Christie has provided her, she discloses that “When I wrote The Hunting Party, I was unknowingly inspired by her, but wasn’t setting out to write a classic ‘who-dunnit’”. She believes that there are fundamental differences in their two approaches to writing crime fiction, saying that “for me it all comes back to character”, or a greater interest in the “why-dunnit” and ‘who was it done to’, whereas she sees Christie as being more driven by a “how-dunnit attitude”. 

She believes that there are fundamental differences in their two approaches to writing crime fiction, saying that “for me it all comes back to character”, or a greater interest in the “why-dunnit” and ‘who was it done to’, whereas she sees Christie as being more driven by a “how-dunnit attitude”

This interest in personality and human nature is evident in her character of Francesca, a larger than life satirical portrayal of the new-age wellness industry. She confesses with a laugh that, upon beginning the novel, she decided that with Francesca “I’m going to go outside the other end of ridiculous”. Circling round to the conversation of narrative technique held during the panel, she adds that the value of her multi-narrative structure is that the other voices balance out the ridiculousness of each character, weaving in and out of different perspectives seemingly effortlessly, but in actuality with a lot of design. 

 She humorously recalls the fun she had playing with the ‘eat the rich formation’, arguing that she wanted to “find the modern formulation of that ‘upstairs-downstairs’ dynamic that is found and so important in a Golden Age murder mystery” and pay homage to the subtle class discussion found in Christie’s work. In substitute for the omnipresent and omnipotent butler or loyal manservant found in Christie’s works, Foley’s character of Eddie and the hostilities between the locals and richer ‘intruders’ deftly weaves a thoughtful and relevant conversation surrounding the implications of internal migration by the upper class and the negative transformations this can create in rural communities. She touches on the idea of invisibility, reflecting that like Eddie, her time working as a waitress was a great exercise in observation and helped ground her writing, as her perceived ghostly presence gave her privy to a wide range of conversations.  

She humorously recalls the fun she had playing with the ‘eat the rich formation’, arguing that she wanted to “find the modern formulation of that ‘upstairs-downstairs’ dynamic that is found and so important in a Golden Age murder mystery”

Speaking more on her journey to becoming an author, Lucy mentions her time at Durham’s English department, and the very thorough grounding it gave her; saying that any student that has studied in the university’s Literature programme will be able to notice the various references and odes to works studied on the course itself. And, staying true to Durham’s stereotypes, she jokingly talks about how important it was to her to get revenge on her Oxbridge rejection by making sure all her unlikeable and murderous characters in her novel The Hunting Party were Oxfordians.

Coy when asked about her plans for further novels, she remarked that she feels protective of her future work: teasingly suggesting that she wants to do something different, as “there’s a new avenue that doesn’t really feel like people have travelled down and I want to explore it”. It appears that it will not be long before we shall be reading her most creative method for murder yet…

Image credit: ‘Night Prowler’ by Jane Ianniello via Pinterest