Review: Little Piece of You: An Atypical Musical in Concert

By Alex Roy

★★★★★

(TW, mention of suicide, depression, and anxiety)

Last week I had the pleasure of venturing back home to see the European Premiere of Little Piece of You: An Atypical Musical in Concert at Theatre Royal Drury Lane. Being lured in both by the impressive venue, and by the promise of a stellar cast, featuring powerhouse Dujonna Gift, and the ever-adored David Bedella, I was excited. Such excitement ebbed away however, leaving me with more questions than anything else.  

Little Piece of You, written by 17 year old Kjersti Long, tells the story of Britt, 16 year old part-time student and full-time fangirl whose life is thrown into turmoil by the suicide of her idol, fictional pop star Sidney Hill. Already struggling with anxiety, Britt finds herself spiralling. Such spiral exists in tandem with her mother’s own struggles with depression. In search of an outlet, Britt begins avoiding school, finding an escape through creativity – painting in her attic. As the story unfolds, we are taken on a generational journey: first, to 1998, where we see Britt’s mother at 16 (also portrayed by Dujonna Gift) navigating the challenge of having unconventional dreams, and then to 1973, introducing Britt’s grandmother as a driven student, eager to break free from the patriarchal constraints of home life. The final narrative brings us back to 2023 for a heartfelt exchange between Britt and Shannon, her mother, about mental health, illustrating how both struggle and talent echo through generations. 

One of the show’s biggest strengths is Long’s music

One of the show’s biggest strengths is Long’s music. Marketed as ‘atypical’, her songwriting veers away from traditional musical theatre, thus feeling refreshingly unique. Tracks like “Burn It Down” are real showstoppers, giving the cast – particularly Gift – a platform to showcase extraordinary vocal range and power. Another standout for me was “The Disguise”, which brought a cinematic quality to the emotional peak of the musical, with Gift once again utilising the material, working with great direction (in this instance) to emotionally elaborate on the pre-existing characterisation of her character. Unlike most musicals, whereby the songs advance the plot, here the music provides emotional punctuation, evoking movement, primarily. Movement in scene, movement in emotion, movement in time, and movement in prop. In this sense, it was somewhat akin to Standing at the Skies Edge, which was equally unique in its utilisation of song as a means of conveying emotion as opposed to directly progressing the storyline. While this choice worked for the most part, it was a little disappointing to see a talent like Bedella relegated to a role which didn’t utilise his voice, especially given the show’s marketing around his recent return from Broadway.

As I have already nodded to, Gift truly stole the show. Following her recent success in Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York, she brought the same unmatched energy to her performance as Britt. Her talent in capturing subtle character shifts between the different generational roles she played made each transition convincing and engaging, despite the lacking writing (which I shall explore in due course). Kjersti Long herself played fictional pop star Sidney Hill. While Long played the role with conviction, the character’s purpose felt tenuous, seemingly solely to place the writer in the story instead of meaningfully driving the story. Despite this, she brought an undeniably convincing pop star to life, with a voice that had no trouble filling such a large venue. Bedella, as Britt’s father, made the most of a role that could have benefitted from being more fleshed out. His charisma and warmth shone, though his lack of characterisation felt like a missed opportunity, particularly insofar as his vocal showcase is concerned. Finally, Mica Paris portrayed Britt’s mother with a less powerful vocal presence. This left me deliberating whether it was her struggling to grapple with the material, or whether it was an artistic choice to reflect the subdued nature of the role she portrayed. Regardless, her characterisation of the mother figures was beautiful, and her chemistry with both Gift and Bedella was convincing enough to move the audience. The ensemble deserves a special mention. The “atypical” nature of this musical is reflected in the use of the ensemble as they are cleverly integrated into the staging. They embodied a degree of omnipresence. Whether it was supporting the leads through dance, acting as vehicles for props, facilitating seamless scene changes, or providing vocals to complement the other voices on stage, they aided the movement of the story in such a beautiful way. The simplicity of the choreography pointed to the possibility of under-rehearsal, which is something I would be keen to see re-workshopped for the future life of this show. 

Unlike most musicals, whereby the songs advance the plot, here the music provides emotional punctuation

Despite the promise of this beautiful cast, Little Piece of You suffers from a lack of cohesion in its book. While Long is clearly an incredibly talented songwriter, the book of this show undermines her musical ability. Three of the four principal roles – the mothers, the fathers, and even Sidney Hill, felt more like plot devices than fully-realised characters. The narrative leap across three timelines was a fascinating idea, and again, one reminiscent of Standing at the Skies Edge, but it seemed to be working solely to convey the eventual message as opposed to serving to recognise the present moment on stage. It might have been, in this sense, more impactful to gradually weave these flashbacks, instead of cramming them all in Act 2.

Little Piece of You has so many promising elements. In line with the aforementioned, the music of this production stands out from other new musicals and had this been a review of the EP alone, it would look very different. For such a large venue, and grand means of breaking into the sphere of London’s theatrical scene, it ultimately felt both underwritten and under-rehearsed, thus failing to amount to its initial promise. The message of the show is heartfelt at its core, but the fractured storyline means that the message struggles to resonate fully amidst the structural shortcomings. 

The “atypical” nature of this musical is reflected in the use of the ensemble as they are cleverly integrated into the staging

While this concert staging may not have fully achieved the cohesion it aspired to, Little Piece of You nonetheless showcased some wonderful talent from the cast and crew alike, broadcasting Long as a songwriter with immense potential. In time, with refinement and further workshopping, this show could evolve into something special. 

Little Piece of You: An Atypical Musical in Concert ran at Theatre Royal Drury Lane from 31 October-1 November, and the world premiere recording album is available to stream on all streaming platforms.

Image credit: Roger Alarcon