What does the budget tell us about the new Labour government?

By Kate Sherry

First budgets are always consequential for new governments, crystallising their economic and political principles, but Rachel Reeves’ autumn statement was one of historical importance, seeing the largest rise in taxes (£40bn, she states) since Norman Lamont’s budget of 1993, increases in almost every area of public spending and alteration of fiscal rules to allow for higher borrowing for capital spending. All this aside, she interrupts an 800-year streak of male chancellors presenting budgets, being the first woman to do so. But what do these massive sums mean in reality, and what can it tell us about Labour’s priorities as they emerge from their first one hundred days in government?

As promised by Sir Keir Starmer, Labour’s budget aims to ensure it “the broadest shoulders” that take the burden whilst ‘working people’ are protected. Ms Reeves’ measures reflect these values. In addition to the much talked about abolition of ‘non-dom’ tax status and the introduction of a 20% VAT on private school fees, capital gains tax will be increased, loopholes regarding inheritance tax closed and taking direct aim at the former PM, air passenger duties for private jets will go up by 50%.

“Protecting people’s payslips” proved a dominant doctrine. The minimum wage will expand to £12.21 for over 21s from April next year and Labour’s manifesto promise not to increase National Insurance contributions (NICs) for employees was upheld.

However, the bulk of this tax hike (an enormous £25bn) will be recouped in the form of employer NICs. Whilst Labour insists this 1.2% increase burdens employers for the sake of public services for ‘working people,’ the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) has stated that the impact will also be felt by employees as the rise limits businesses abilities to hire and give pay rises. Beyond this, sceptics may question in the coming days if it is not small business owners, many of whom consider themselves working people, who will be most adversely impacted by this policy.

Labour’s first budget in 14 years might be called “a kitchen sink budget”

Across the board, massive spending increases have been put in place – the Department for Education will see a 19% real terms increase, £5bn will be spent on housing and the NHS will receive an additional £22.6bn for its day-to-day budget. A £3.4bn warm homes plan was announced alongside £2.9bn in additional defense spending and a £1.3bn grant for local government.

In total this represents a spending increase of 1.5% on day-to-day spending and a 1.7% increase on capital spending in real terms. Labour argues this is necessary to try and reverse the effects of years of austerity, irresponsibility and refusal to acknowledge the extent of overhaul required to fix broken public services. In their own words – “invest, invest, invest” to overcome an inherited black hole in funding of public services to the value of £22bn. In response in the Commons on Wednesday, Rishi Sunak proffered that the OBR has declined to backup claims of such a black hole.

Another sticking point for Mr Sunak is Ms Reeves’ new fiscal rules. Her so-called investment rule will change how debt is measured allowing for increased borrowing. The Tories have suggested this irresponsibly removes constraint on borrowing, preventing Labour from having to take tough decisions on cuts elsewhere.

Reflecting on Wednesday afternoon, the BBC’s economics editor stated the Labour’s first budget in 14 years might be called “a kitchen sink budget,” with the government throwing everything at public services to fix the situation it inherited. However, huge increases in spending for the next two years, this expansion will then flatten off.

If the government is successful in stimulating growth and restoring public services in the next two years, it will have paid off, if not the Chancellor will no doubt be forced to come back for more tax revenue in her next budget.

Image credit: Kirsty O’Connor/Treasury/Wikimedia Commons