New Year, New Kemi? A crunch year for the Tory leader
By Kate Sherry
As we welcomed in the new year, party leaders took stock and reminded us of their priorities looking forward to the year ahead. Kemi Badenoch’s political resolution is no small feat. The Leader of the Opposition plans to rebuild the Conservative Party, returning it to its founding principles. Whilst she will espouse policy aims in generalised terms, the minutia of the 2029 General Election manifesto will be left up to ‘policy Commissions’ and party members who will be consulted through surveys.
In years gone by, Ms Badenoch’s steady approach to deciding her party’s direction would certainly have been the prudent one. Sir Keir Starmer’s government is still in its in fancy and, as former Conservative Senior Advisor and pollster James Johnson has stated, the public “aren’t really paying attention.” Ms Badenoch also has the advantage that any semblance of a honeymoon the new Labour government may have enjoyed has ended. Labour’s weakness in the polls, and projections that the fourth quarter – like the third – will show zero economic growth, puts the Tories in a strong position to demonstrate competence in opposition.
However, the insurgent threat of Nigel Farage’s Reform Party vying to subsume ever-larger portions of the party’s base has only intensified the Tory tendency towards impatience with its leaders. Whilst the public may still be undecided on Kemi Badenoch, backbenchers are already privately mumbling about a replacement. Where she argues her approach is steady, her critics see it as sluggish. Ms Badenoch is far from a centrist yet there are some amongst the Tory ranks that believe she should be taking greater credence from Mr Farage’s successful brand of right-wing populism. Some have suggested that a pact between the two parties should be formed in advance of local elections in May to avoid splitting the vote on the right, whilst Suella Braverman is amongst those tipped to defect to Reform.
Sharing space on the right with Reform undermines the Conservatives’ opposition and poses a serious threat to the party’s future
Sharing space on the right with Reform undermines the Conservatives’ opposition and poses a serious threat to the party’s future. Writing in The Telegraph, Sherelle Jacobs argued Kemi Badenoch’s last hope was to distinguish the Tories from Reform by creating a “meticulous plan… that it claims Reform has no ‘inclination’ to craft.” Badenoch appears to hope that support for Reform will decline as she demonstrates competence in opposition. This hope is not completely without basis. She and Mr Farage share a ‘straight-talking’ persona which appeals to voters. Many senior Tories – including former leader Iain Duncan Smith – believe that if Ms Badenoch uses her elevated platform and avoids getting into unnecessary spats with Mr Farage, she will win back lost trust. However, it seems unlikely that the base whose frustrations with, what Mr Farage labelled in his own New Year speech as “societal decline” will be satiated by a list of unclear policy goals.
The interference of Elon Musk, billionaire and apparent torch-bearer of the alt-right in UK has been an early indicator of the right-wing populism we can expect to dominate political conversation in 2025. After Mr Musk launched an unsubstantiated attack against Sir Keir Starmer, accusing him of complicity in child rape, numerous leaders of the right piled on to demand a fresh inquiry into the ‘grooming gang scandal’ which began in 1997. Amongst these voices was Kemi Badenoch’s, though as the story progressed, she grew quiet, instead allowing Robert Jenrick to take the lead by making inflammatory remarks about the ethnicity-related dynamics of the scandal. Writing for the BBC, Chris Mason suggested Ms. Badenoch is challenged from the right of the party by Robert Jenrick who has “carried on campaigning as if the leadership race was still on,” forging a message for the party on his terms. Whilst it is possible to view Ms Badenoch’s limited presence in this instance as a shrewd political move to preserve her voice for when she really wants to make an impact, it seems that the party is moving to the right with or without her.
Whether Ms Badenoch is able to captivate voters by returning the party to its roots remains to be seen, but if this week’s events have shown us anything it is that she has the potential to be crowded out by the loud men of the alt-right.
Image credit: House of Commons/Wikimedia Commons

