How will students vote in the general election?
With the general election looming, it is time for us all to be thinking about who will best represent our views. As students there are probably a few issues which are of common concern. It is probable, for example, that the students of Durham University will be more interested in higher education funding than, perhaps, EU fishery quotas (though we know they are important too, fish lovers).
But what really are the key issues for Durham students in this election? In the name of gauging student opinion, and at absolutely no expense to the taxpayer, Durham Political Activist Society recently asked you the following questions:
1. Are you registered to vote? (441 polled)
a. Yes- 301 (68%)
b. No, but I am interested in registering- 88 (20%)
c. No, and I am not interested in registering- 52 (12%)
A pleasingly large bunch were already registered to vote (for those interested, you can register at www.aboutmyvote.co.uk). The remaining twelve per cent replied that they were not interested in voting. That was a conversation killer.
Although it is not certain that all students who indicated that they were registered to vote will turn up at the polls, the number registered is an encouraging indication that the student participation rate could well be higher than the national turnout of 61.3 per cent at the last general election. Surely a good sign of what a charmingly politically active lot Durham students are.
2. Who will you vote for? (389 polled)
a. Labour – 69 (18%)
b. Conservative – 105 (27%)
c. Liberal Democrats – 83 (21%)
d. Other political party– 16 (4%)
e. Undecided – 104 (27%)
f. Decide on the day – 12 (3%)
Let us get to the juicy bits. I can hear the hushed gasps of shock reverberating through our college halls upon reading that over a quarter of students asked said they would vote for the Tories. The majority of those voting for some ‘other’ political party commented that their environmental concerns prompted them to choose the Green Party.
Revealingly, a significant 27 per cent of those questioned were as yet undecided on who to vote for. You may not be surprised, reasoning that it will be the first vote in a general election for the majority of our undergraduates; deciding what the important issues are and who to vote for is new and uncertain territory.
The responses we received highlighted a belief that the old distinction of ‘left’ and ‘right’ in politics is increasingly indistinct, as parties try to dominate the political centre, which along with difficulty in accessing the finer distinctions between parties’ manifestos may muddy the water for first-time voters.
On the other hand, a lot of students confessed to simply not being well enough informed on what they felt were the key issues and how the main political parties will tackle them. A person becoming informed, though, is not like plants absorbing water. Nor is it like being Cinderella, waiting for your pumpkin of political awareness to be turned into a stagecoach. Bam! Wow! Now I am informed!
If you do not look, you do not see much, and it might take a bit of stone-turning to see past the headlines to the real differences that exist between different parties. Televised political debate between the leaders of the three main parties will take place in the next few months. Three debates are planned: one to be broadcast on ITV, one on Sky, and one on the BBC. There are plenty of opportunities to get interested and informed and we are hopeful that these debates will be happening in Durham too, so stay tuned.
3. What is the key issue in choosing who you will vote for? (389 polled)
a. Party manifesto/presentation of plans – 131 (34%)
b. Personality of leader – 22 (6%)
c. Loyalty to party or family history of voting for a party – 64 (16%)
d. Need of government change (in general) – 81 (21%)
e. Other – 91 (23%)
Almost a fifth of those students asked responded that they would base their vote on family loyalty to a party (and who said tribalism was not alive and well in Britain?). Is it a good thing that students supposedly developing their independence of mind choose their leader based on the views of mum and dad?
Though the personality of leaders seems unimportant to students, our poll indicated this may be an election for Gordon Brown and Labour to lose, rather than one for the opposition to win. A fifth of respondents base their vote on dissatisfaction with the incumbent party, rather than on the merits of the opposition.
The poor performance of the economy inevitably reflects badly on Labour, as the current party in power, but who will be the best at ensuring the conditions in which there are jobs available for us lot in a couple of years’ time?
The American politician Tip O’Neill once said all politics is local. His view is partially borne out by the responses of those opting for the ‘other’ category on this question, most of whom said local politics was their deciding factor.
Most students have a choice of voting in Durham or in their home constituency. It may be thought of as a reflection of which community a student feels stronger allegiance to, or those seeing the bigger picture may tactically choose where to vote, noting that Durham is a marginal seat, and realistically could go to either Labour or the Lib Dems (the last general election saw only nine per cent voting Conservative in Durham).
Students mentioned that they would base their votes on issues such as addressing the deficit, student tuition fees and concerns about transparency and accountability. Student response was also tempered with a general disillusionment which could be said to be representative of a national feeling of mistrust towards politicians, cynicism of the system and hostility towards certain parties.
One would have had to have been trekking across some distant tundra on one’s GAP year for the last twelve months not to have picked up on public reaction to the MPs’ expenses scandal. These revelations were precipitated by the Freedom of Information Act and the revolutionary freedom offered by the internet, meaning that ordinary people- the ‘bloggerati’- now have limitless opportunities to observe and comment.
In a Populus poll for The Times this week, 77 per cent said that there are far fewer people in public life that they admire than there used to be. Now that we have ‘had it all out’, is the system now being monitored closely enough to ensure that tomorrow’s taxes will not be going to towards housing mallards at the bottom of our MPs’ gardens? It will soon be our money being spent.
With the Chilcot Inquiry underway, politicians are being reawakened to polarised public opinion. For those who contend that Blair lied to Parliament in order to gain approval for action, the anger has not subsided.
There are others who hold that the decision to go to war in Iraq was a noble act of statesmanship. How the incoming party intend to prioritise military spending, and address our future in Afghanistan, is of crucial importance.
As well as these issues, students will be voting on a whole range of others, of serious importance to the country’s immediate future: balancing civil liberties and effective security, the future of media such as the BBC and online digital content, redistribution of wealth and related matters such as pensions and benefits, and antisocial behaviour.
The next parliament will have an increasingly difficult job dealing with policy on all these issues because of the effects of the recession; it is generally acknowledged that there need to be very significant spending cuts in the near future. Exactly what is cut, how, and when, will be the major dividing line between the parties and will be on the minds of many students as they go to the polling station.
We admit that deciding how to vote is no easy business. It is, however, an important one that, as the kids who will soon be running this society, we are in the best position to get informed about. Let us start the political chat: who will you vote for?
