Have we run out of stories, or the attention to watch them?
By Alexandra Shemagina
Cinema has been pronounced dead so many times that you would think someone might stop writing the obituary. Yet an industry whose future increasingly resembles its past is hardly helping its case. Stories end, credits roll, and somebody in a boardroom asks whether the protagonist’s grandmother deserves a trilogy. Apparently, leaving a successful film alone is now financially irresponsible.
The appeal of a franchise is obvious. A new story needs an introduction; an established one arrives with fans, merchandise and several thousand TikTok edits. Why persuade an audience to care when they already own the Halloween costume? Nostalgia is the real ace up the studio’s sleeve. It sells us a story alongside the possibility of feeling how we felt when we first watched it. And, honestly, who am I to pretend I am above a Twilight rewatch?
But loving an original does not mean wanting its corpse repeatedly wheeled out for inspection. Take the Gossip Girl reboot, cancelled after two seasons. We returned to the Upper East Side, but an expensive postcode could only do so much. The original’s appeal was never simply that rich teenagers existed. It was the particular, frequently ridiculous world they inhabited, and our willingness to believe in it.
Then there is And Just Like That…, which sometimes feels like an experiment in how much goodwill Sex and the City accumulated. Watching familiar characters navigate contemporary life could have been interesting. Instead, the effort to demonstrate cultural awareness can feel painfully conspicuous. We came back for people we knew, only to find them apparently attending a compulsory seminar on everything that had happened since we last saw them. Perhaps nostalgia becomes harder to sell when it keeps reminding us how much time has passed.
Elsewhere, expansion replaces resurrection. The Hunger Games takes us back to Panem through prequels; Netflix is developing an animated Midnight Sun, revisiting Twilight from Edward’s perspective. There may be worthwhile stories left in both worlds. Still, how many perspectives does one fictional relationship require? At some point, surely somebody else in the forest deserves a film.
Calling this a crisis of ideas is tempting. But perhaps it is also a crisis of attention. Our days are already crowded with news, deadlines, recommendations and people insisting that one more three-hour podcast will change our lives. By the evening, being introduced to twelve characters and an unfamiliar political system can feel less like entertainment than additional reading.
Calling this a crisis of ideas is tempting. But perhaps it is also a crisis of attention
Familiar stories ask less of us initially. We know the characters, recognise the references and understand the memes. Even before watching, we can participate in the conversation. Something new must compete for that privilege. A franchise already has it, along with a dedicated account explaining why its most emotionally unavailable character is misunderstood.
Streaming should make discovery easier. Instead, it can turn choosing a film into the evening’s main activity. Forty minutes of browsing later, the familiar title starts looking remarkably attractive. There is a comforting lack of negotiation involved: I know what this is, I know roughly how I will feel, and nobody needs to explain the lore. The same convenience that rescues our evening may help keep everything else out of sight.
Original cinema does, of course, exist. Parasite makes class inequality architectural; The Platform makes it horribly literal. Their subjects are familiar, but their ways of presenting them are distinctive. Cinema does not need to discover a previously unknown social problem every Tuesday. It needs to make us see something differently. Recognising that capitalism might be bad is not, by itself, a screenplay.
Even A24, whose logo can function as a personality trait, is subject to commercial pressures. TheWrap reported in 2023 that it was seeking action films and established intellectual property alongside its arthouse projects. There is an irony here: a company associated with originality has become a reassuring brand itself. Sometimes we want something different, provided we recognise who is selling it.
Barbenheimer offers hope, with qualifications. Audiences embraced two ambitious, distinctive films. But Barbie was hardly an unknown newcomer, and Christopher Nolan’s name came with considerable reassurance. We were willing to try something fresh, with references supplied.
I will still rewatch my favourites. The problem begins when that affection becomes the organising principle of an entire industry. Every familiar fictional world once had to introduce itself. We should probably let a few more do the same, before the next major cinematic event turns out to be Twilight, as remembered by Bella’s driving instructor.
Image credit: Creative Commons license/Digital News

