Pints and pennies won’t fix the student cost of living crisis

By Daisie Mackay

Now, I don’t like to be a cynic, so I will start by saying that there are actually some positives to the Budget, most notably in the message it communicates. To preface, political apathy in the UK is a pervasive and dangerous sentiment. We have seen an increasing decline in electoral turnout, in the 2024 general election it was just 59.7%, and widespread disengagement from politics due to mistrust in the political establishment. Politicians are widely seen as out of touch with the electorate, but our latest prime minister, Andy Burnham is generally doing a lot better than his predecessors at meeting people where they are, at conveying a message that says he is listening to them. 

Yes, the Government is focusing on breathing space for today, but what about tomorrow?

The chancellor has said that this Budget is about giving people “breathing space”, something that reaches the public a lot more tangibly than just going on about how your “father was a toolmaker”, as former prime minister Keir Starmer loved to remind us. And in all fairness, it is making these kinds of changes that people actually see in their immediate, everyday lives, that will help to shift the negative view people tend to have of politics. The £100 rebate on energy bills is something very visible; the Government will pay money directly into people’s bank accounts. That makes a difference, and it shows how bothered the Government is about not alienating the public. This is probably one of the most effective governments thus far in really getting to people, responding to what they are asking for (or, more accurately, complaining about).

However, while this Budget is helping the Government’s wider strategy, it leaves much to be desired, particularly from a young person’s point of view. Unfortunately, this energy bill rebate will likely not reach most students, and the energy price cap is expected to rise 27% in January anyway, which means this rebate is akin to pouring water into a bucket full of holes that keep appearing. Not to mention that there is so much more that could be done on energy, starting with continuing the drive to switch to more renewables, because guess what it is that is driving energy costs up so high: that’s right, it’s oil and gas! But just days before the Budget, the Government announced its approval of gas production at the Jackdaw gas field, with a further oil field at Rosebank in the pipeline. There is not only, therefore, a lack of action on clean energy, but efforts to move towards it are being actively undermined. This continual dismissal of climate change does not spell good news for young people’s futures, another way in which the Budget has left them out of its “breathing space”. In fact, by the time these policies are enacted, there will likely be no clean air left to breathe. Yes, the Government is focusing on breathing space for today, but what about tomorrow?

For someone who came in on what was widely perceived as a movement for a more radical approach, Burnham is wide of the mark

The Budget also scrapped import tariffs on a number of food items, including garlic, gherkins, beans, and sweets, so great, the weekly food shop will be cheaper! But it will be cheaper by a couple of pence. The Government said that the tariff cuts will allow families to save up to £21 on their food shop each year, so it follows that for students these savings will be even less. Helpful, yes, but really? Only £21? This is what I mean when I say these are positive but extremely lacking measures. This is not going to help the student struggling to juggle all their finances for food shops, bills, rent and socialising, among many other costs. But then, this policy was not cooked up with students in mind. In fact, it seems like none of them were. Students are a crucial part of the Labour voting bloc, and while the ‘Burnham bounce’ may be going strong for the moment, it will soon wear off as students tire of yet another government which fails to address worries about student loans, the potential of a life laden with debt, and few graduate job prospects. For someone who came in on what was widely perceived as a movement for a more radical approach, Burnham is wide of the mark. And yes, he is held back by the 2024 Labour Party manifesto, but he could have done more than this. It is as the Leader of the Opposition said: “Is that it?”

Image: Zara Farrar via Wikimedia Commons