A melting of the diplomatic ‘‘ice age?’’ PM Sir Keir Starmer visits China

By Daisie Mackay

In his recent trip to China, Sir Keir Starmer became the first British Prime Minister to visit the country in 8 years, following Baroness (Theresa) May’s visit in 2018. On this trip, Sir Keir was joined by 60 representatives of Britain’s biggest businesses and cultural organisations, in his efforts to form a ‘more sophisticated’ relationship with China. He met President Xi Jinping, as well as having a separate meeting with Premier Li Qiang (China’s second-in-command), discussing areas in which they could operate for the benefit of both the UK and China, including in the commercial sphere, in addition to addressing areas of disagreement. These discussions clearly paid off, with £2.2bn in export deals and visa-free travel to China being secured, as well as a halving of whisky tariffs from 10% to 5%, and the lifting of sanctions on 6 parliamentarians. 

”These discussions clearly paid off, with £2.2bn in export deals and visa-free travel to China being secured, as well as a halving of whisky tariffs from 10% to 5%, and the lifting of sanctions on 6 parliamentarians”

Whilst these payoffs may seem significant, this trip did not come without its fair share of criticism, both at home, and, perhaps more worryingly, abroad. The President of the United States, Donald Trump, seemed to decry the trip, saying it was “very dangerous” for the UK to engage with China in this way. Such engagement comes off the back of several unpredictable moves from the United States, including a number of tariffs ranging from 10% to 50% on many British exports to the US such as copper and passenger vehicles; before President Trump came into office, these figures were far lower, at an average of 2.2%. China is the UK’s third-biggest trading partner, behind the European Union, and the US, therefore the argument has been made that, with such unpredictable moves from the US, Britain will benefit from strengthening relations with China. Indeed, UK business minister Chris Bryant attacked the US President’s rhetoric, saying it would be “bonkers frankly for the UK to ignore the presence of China on the world stage”, also calling out the President’s hypocrisy, pointing out that he himself will be visiting China in April. Such rhetoric is not without the potential for action, however, as evidenced in President Trump’s threats to levy 100% tariffs on Canada following Prime Minister Mark Carney’s China visit earlier this year, should they go through with the deal they struck. Though the increasingly common idea of TACO (Trump always chickens out) puts far less stock into these threats than there previously has been.

Furthermore, domestic opposition has been no less restrained, with Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp claiming the government was trading “national security for economic crumbs off the Chinese table”, emphasising such national security reasons to justify why the Conservative government did not venture to China for so long when in office. Not only this, but those parliamentarians who had sanctions lifted, including MPs Sir Iain Duncan Smith and Tom Tugendhat among others, even said that they would prefer to “remain under sanction indefinitely than have our status used as a bargaining chip to justify lifting British sanctions on those officials responsible for the genocide in Xinjiang,” referring to the atrocities committed against the Uyghur people. The UK did confirm that no sanctions have been lifted on Chinese individuals, though those mentioned above insisted that they took “no comfort” in this move for reasons above as well as the fact that Jimmy Lai, a British-Hong Kong citizen and pro-democracy campaigner, remains imprisoned in China.

”Jimmy Lai, a British-Hong Kong citizen and pro-democracy campaigner, remains imprisoned in China”

Opposition to this trip has been loud, with the government struggling to find much support at home as well as disapproval from the country that has long been been its greatest ally, the US. However, with the deals on the table, and the potential for economic growth that comes from this visit, as well as following in the global trend of countries seeking out a more productive relationship with the growing power that is China in the face of a less and less reliable US, some have argued that this move may just help Britain to successfully reposition itself on a rapidly changing world stage.

Image: No 10 Downing Street via Wikimedia Commons