The album isn’t dead. We just stopped listening to it.
By Molly Kirk
The album is having something of an identity crisis.
We have never had more music available to us, yet increasingly little reason to listen to it in the way artists intended. Spotify shuffles, personalised playlists, and algorithmic recommendations allow us to move endlessly between songs. TikTok can make a few seconds of a track instantly recognisable before many listeners know which album it came from.
Music has not become less important. But it has become increasingly fragmented.
It is in this context that RAYE was crowned winner of the 2026 Mercury Prize for her second album, This Music May Contain Hope. She beat a shortlist including Paul McCartney, Florence + The Machine and pre-ceremony favourite Olivia Dean, in a victory which might initially seem unusually predictable for a prize associated with championing the unexpected.
But the more interesting question is not whether RAYE is too famous to win the Mercury Prize. It is what, in 2026, the prize is actually for.
The Mercury has long distinguished itself from more commercially driven awards. Its shortlists have long placed emerging and experimental musicians alongside some of the biggest names in the industry, giving it a reputation for rewarding records which might otherwise be overlooked. RAYE hardly needs discovering.
Already a chart-topping artist and record-breaking BRIT Award winner, she entered Newcastle’s Utilita Arena with far more public recognition than many of her fellow nominees. Following Sam Fender’s victory last year, another established winner risks making the Mercury look safer and more mainstream.
That concern is understandable. The Mercury matters partly because it gives smaller artists a platform they are unlikely to receive elsewhere. If it simply mirrors the charts, much of what makes it distinctive disappears.
Yet popularity and artistic merit are not opposites.
The purpose of the Mercury Prize cannot be to find the least commercially successful album on its shortlist. RAYE’s success should not count against her any more than another artist’s obscurity should automatically count in their favour. A prize centred on artistic achievement becomes equally limited if being mainstream is treated as evidence of being artistically uninteresting.
r. A prize centred on artistic achievement becomes equally limited if being mainstream is treated as evidence of being artistically uninteresting
And This Music May Contain Hope is a fitting winner precisely because it demands to be considered as an album. Divided into four sections and moving between jazz, soul, R&B and classical influences, its structure is part of the experience. The Mercury judges praised its scale and ambition while defending the album as a vital form of artistic expression in the streaming age. That defence feels increasingly necessary.
Streaming has transformed music for the better in many ways. Listeners can move from global stars to artists recording from their bedrooms within seconds. But the same platforms which have widened our musical horizons have also encouraged us to treat songs as individual products: something to save, skip or add to a playlist.
An album asks for something different. Its order matters. Songs can develop ideas introduced several tracks earlier. The song you skip can become the one you return to months later. Listening from beginning to end means temporarily giving up the endless choice streaming has made normal.
Perhaps this is why an award devoted to albums still has a role. The response to RAYE’s win suggests audiences think so too. In the days following the ceremony, This Music May Contain Hope saw a 275% increase in chart sales, while several other shortlisted artists also saw increases in streams.
The Mercury did not simply reward an album. It persuaded people to listen to one.
Its return to Newcastle matters for similar reasons. The city hosted the ceremony for the second consecutive year, after the Mercury moved outside London for the first time in 2025. This year’s accompanying Fringe programme brought more than 30 events across the city.
For a British cultural industry still heavily concentrated in the capital, that shift is significant. For the North East, visibility matters too: hosting a prize of this scale brings national cultural attention to a region too often treated as peripheral to Britain’s creative industries. A national music prize should not require artists and audiences to look towards London whenever they want to take part in national cultural life. Returning the Mercury to Newcastle challenges that assumption, even as its choice of winner appears more conventional.
The Mercury does not need obscurity for obscurity’s sake. Nor can it reverse the way streaming has changed how we consume music.
But it can remind us that convenience is not the same as attention. The album has not disappeared. We have simply become less accustomed to giving one the time it asks of us.
Image credit: Wikimedia Commons/Drew de F Fawkes

