Friend or Foe? China’s changing global status

By Oscar Duffy

China finds itself at a crossroads. Perusing various news networks will no doubt result in forecasts of Chinese domination in the 21st century, usually in comparison to the United States as a waning force. It’s an attractively simple picture, yet it doesn’t capture the complex contours of geopolitics. Indeed, China’s economic penetration of global markets is expert in both its assertiveness and its undetectability. The western mainstream public, still basking in the afterglow of former domination, are slow in realising China’s capacity to be more than just a peripheral nation. Kishore Mahbubani asserts that the West has become complacent in their status as world leaders, taking Francis Fukuyama’s assertion that the end of the Cold War meant the “end of history” and swapping the alert suspicion which defined its 20th century rivalries for careless interference in the developing world.

Criticisms of growing Chinese dominance did not begin with Coronavirus. Underneath Trump’s rhetorical spats with Chinese President Xi Jinping exists an existential crisis in much of the West over reconciling its dependence on the United States while acknowledging China’s economic prowess. Nothing exemplifies this more than the development of 5G networks across the developed world. The UK has been less strict on the Chinese telecommunications company than the former Eastern Bloc and Australia, but US anger at the UK wavering on the issue has resulted in a more Sinosceptic Boris. He has since announced a plan to be free from Huawei influence by 2023 and Project Defend has been established in order to lessen British dependence on Chinese medical supplies. It is clear that states like the UK are currently reconciling the need to acknowledge a growing need to defer to China on economic matters whilst acknowledging its partnership with the US and its prioritisation of liberal democracy over communist authoritarianism as a model of governance.

China’s would-be critics are far more dependent on China than the other way around

Yet China’s experience with Covid-19 has seen it come under scrutiny more than ever before, not only on its specific handling of the outbreak, but also over its geopolitical position. Conspiracy theorists argue that China manufactured Covid-19 and are using the disease to assert dominance. While this is likely as untrue as Cummings’ Barnard Castle drive being for an eye test, more rational criticisms have involved the lack of transparency and the continued existence of wet markets in the country. Xi’s response to this is riddled with contradiction. On the one hand, China can afford to be fairly bullish. It’s clear would-be critics are far more dependent on China than the other way around. Chinese imports to the UK are double the value of UK exports to China, and that same economic leverage can be exercised elsewhere. Boris Johnson clearly doesn’t want to antagonise the country; he rather unsubtly said that he “loves China” on the phone with Xi last week.

However, there are signs of nerves in China’s response. The dynamic with Africa is especially interesting. Much has been said about China’s investment in the continent, and commentators have voiced disquiet at the possibility than China could capitalise on Africa’s economic weakness to establish a quasi-dependent relationship. However, criticism has been levelled at Xi for the treatment of Africans in Chinese cities under quarantine. Videos of forced evictions and generally dehumanising behaviour means that African states are arguably waking up to the possible danger that comes with such a close partnership. In his speech to the WHO Assembly, Xi placed emphasis on China’s commitment to providing humanitarian aid, something clearly directed at African political partners. This added to China’s relative lack of soft power and cultural exports always makes its status as a world power less firm than western states could claim in the 19th and 20th centuries.

This period sees the Chinese leadership under more observation than ever before. Many have been aware of the growth of Beijing in international leadership for some time, but Covid-19 has illustrated how frightened many in the West truly are of that possibility. Yet the pressure is also on for Xi himself. He hasn’t been completely successful in his handling of the pandemic, undermining his relationship with Africa. China must balance assertion of its huge economic leverage whilst also reconciling with the fact that the eyes of the world are now firmly on them.

Image: UN Women via Flickr