Purposeful protests: how can a protest lose its poignancy?
By Jake Garvey
Trigger warning: this article focusses on both the ongoing systemic discrimination of and violence towards the black community in the USA and beyond, along with the responses of the Black Lives Matter movement. It contains sensitive and distressing information, which some may find upsetting
Recent events have brought the discrimination and outright violence the police wield towards the black communities in the USA and beyond to light. The murder of George Floyd by Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin on 25th May brought international attention to a problem which is continually pushed aside, simply being dismissed as ‘how it is’.
A wave of protests erupted (both in the USA and on an international level) fighting for justice for George Floyd and the countless other members of the black community who had been brutally murdered because of their race. On paper, race is simple; it is a word. Black or white. However, in a wider context it is complicit with a multitude of differential meanings. It is intertwined with ethnic histories and, in the USA at least, a long history of systemic and blatant racial discrimination against black people. Put into action in the late 19th century, the blatant racism perpetuated by the Jim Crow Laws still permeates American society to this day. It manifests in the avoidable deaths of many and an unjust society, with people being viewed as second class citizens simply because of the colour of their skin.
Let me begin my argument by saying this, I am completely in support of the Black Lives Matter protest movement; a world without tolerance and a world without equality for all is not a world in which I wish to partake. However, in some locations, perhaps, have the meanings of the protest somewhat lost their effectivity?
[blockquote author=”” ]in some areas of the USA, the protests appear to have lost their way[/blockquote]
Fighting for justice and equality is of the upmost importance, without protest movements some of the most fundamental societal changes of the 19th, 20th and 21st centuries would not have been achieved. Raising awareness of causes which are too often unobserved to some, but experienced by many is a sure way of creating effective and meaningful change. Nevertheless, in some areas of the USA, the protests appear to have lost their way.
[blockquote author=”” ]the actions of the police are inexcusable, and in no way are protest movements an overreaction[/blockquote]
This is, of course, not a homogenous statement aligning with all protestors. Many are raising awareness in the best way possible; lobbying for change and engaging white allies across the world to stand in solidarity with the black community.
To make it clear, the actions of the police are inexcusable, and in no way are protest movements an overreaction. Indeed, we must remember that the media will seek to represent protestors in the most violent way possible, to engender reactions from those who perhaps, garner less support for the black community. A recent video posted onto the Facebook page NowThis Politics showed the true cost of these protests. An undeniably important force for raising awareness, attacking the very communities of those they were advocating. New York City neighbourhoods, where the majority of their population is of BAME decent were ransacked in the name of ‘Black Lives Matter’. These neighbourhoods are statistically deprived, and lack access to essential services, rendering the few essential services that these very people rely on out of order. Where were they meant to get help from now? In this one instance, had the protests became more of a hindrance than a help?
[blockquote author=”” ]when does the violence become more about violence for violence’s sake, and less about protecting lives and raising awareness?[/blockquote]
The message of the protests, in this instance, lost its way. For some protestors it became more about creating a melee of violence, rather than spreading and raising awareness. Violence is to be expected. Decades of facing violence and oppression by the police force in the USA will of course engender an equal reaction given the chance. However, when does the violence become more about violence for violence’s sake, and less about protecting lives and raising awareness? Some people will take this opportunity for violence, regardless of the message that the protest wishes to spread. How do we regulate this and ensure protests have some degree of order to ensure their meaning doesn’t become lost.
Change is necessary. Change needs to occur to foster global development. We cannot be passive in this, we must act. Use our collective and individual voice to lobby for change. Do everything in your power to raise awareness to the systematic discrimination of the black community.
White privilege is real. All white people experience it. White people must break down that racial gap and become an ally to the black community. Take real, tangible action and create a more sustainable and equal future for the black community globally.
The NowThis Politics video can be accessed via the link below:
https://www.facebook.com/NowThisJustice/videos/1211471149195477/
Follow this link for a document detailing the ways in which YOU can help and take real action:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1el0DK1xXaLdOfJHX92U1f8s1idrgG5QYIVTEO_akqMw/edit
My thanks must go to the amazing Jade Gavigan of St. Cuthbert’s Society for creating the above resource. She is tireless in her pursuit for equality and to make a measured and tangibly positive impact on the lives of black people everywhere. Thank you Jade!
Feature image by Aaron Fulkerson. Available via Flickr.
