English education: a system in disarray?
By Jake Garvey
The 1976 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural rights states that the right to education is “fundamental” to society. Fundamental though it is, globally the access to education is differential and even in developed nations, such as the UK, access and engagement with education (at all levels) remains an issue too closely tied to socio-economic status.
Education in the UK operates on a devolved system, with all nations of the United Kingdom operating education systems with deviations from that of the English school system, yet with some similarities. In England, your success is too often tied to your socio-economic status, with the 7% of the population which have been privately educated holding over 71% of senior judicial positions (as outlined by the Commission for Social Mobility, 2014). Statistics such as these raise an important question: how far does your socio-economic background influence your experience of the English education system?
In England, your success is too often tied to your socio-economic status.
Since the election of the 2010 coalition government, austerity policies have widened the wealth gap. People at the lower end of the spectrum have been pushed further and further into ‘absolute poverty’ by welfare changes, which have stripped them of valuable benefits which necessitate their very survival. The UK now has one of the highest rates of child poverty in the developed world, with over 30% of children being classified as ‘poor’ (according to The Guardian, 2017). A 2017 study by the Joseph Rountree Foundation found that over 55% of families who worked were classed as being “in poverty” despite working, and the welfare benefits which topped up their income had not risen with inflation, leading families to a point of desperation. It is ‘inevitable’ that these issues would find themselves creeping into the classroom. According to the National Union for Headteachers, more and more schools are playing ‘piggy in the middle’ in that they hold families back from absolute poverty with vital services.
Data plays a role of undeniable importance in quantitatively displaying this ‘disadvantage gap’ at work. Children from poorer backgrounds, for example, are statistically less likely to achieve 5 A*-C grades at the end of KS4, with only 1 in 3 achieving this level in 2017. Although there are many explanations for this, 47% of the families classed as ‘poor’ are also families relying on unstable sources of income (according to the Child Poverty Action Group, 2018). This will lead to an unstable home environment, where children will be unable to focus. Often the worries of the home situation engulf these children, widening the gap with their wealthier peers who are, on average, more likely to receive parental encouragement and participation in their education.
Universal education in the UK is, it seems, quite the opposite.
There is no symbiosis between the welfare and education system in the UK. A 2017 study by the Child Poverty Action Group revealed that more than 70% of parents surveyed said that losing their free school meal entitlement when they began to work was a major disincentive to actively find work. If you work 16 hours or more per week, your entitlement to Free School Meals (FSM) automatically ends, placing the onus on the parents to provide everything to complement their child’s education. Yet these households are those who are unable to pay their energy bills, relying on unstable, zero-hours, minimum wage contracts, and are seemingly being penalised by the system for working. The government has unreasonable expectations of families and schools. More often than not schools are becoming a stopgap between families and destitution, with the associated health problems of poverty costing the NHS millions of pounds per year and affecting education. Children in receipt of FSM due to home circumstances are less likely to attend a ‘good’ school. Only 19% of children living in poverty in the UK attended a school rated ‘Outstanding’ by OFSTED, but more than 44% attended schools rated ‘Inadequate’ or ‘Requires Improvement’. Why is it that the system appears to favour the wealthier children and allows those with unfortunate circumstances to seemingly languish with an ennui towards participation in education?
Children living in these circumstances experience a variety of issues: food insecurity, fuel poverty, financial worries, to name just a few. These all play a very large role in shaping their educational experience. Pupils from backgrounds that are classified as ‘poor’ (which currently stands at 1 in 4 of the general state education population) are likely to be twice as behind as their peers, simply due to personal circumstances. The system makes no exceptions for them, with total spending per pupil falling by 8% in real terms between 2017-18. Valuable support is stripped away from these already unsupported children, exacerbating the development gap and increasing the creation of a new generation of ‘destitute’ children. They are seemingly failed by the system and let down by education, simply because of the situation into which they were born.
This argument raises a very important question: in a county which scored 14th highest on the HDI, why have only 38% of the population have attended any form of higher education? Should children be left to languish behind due to no fault of their own? Universal education in the UK, is quite the opposite.
Image: elinerijpers. Available via Flickr.
